Review on RB & GH3

[Garthdude2]

Now we of cource all know what Rock Band is and Guitar Hero 3, well which one do you think is better? most of you would choose Rock Band, and i like RC more than GH3! now i'm not sayning i hate GH3, but RB is better by far. RB delivers what GH 1 and 2 deliver and even more. so much more you cant take it. But maybe went a little bit too far. A lot of peoples instruments are breaking and i dont think Harmonix was full 100% ready with RB they just wanted to bring it out before christmas, but i am getting it and i think it is freaking awesome. GH, since Harmonix left, has had a lot of troubles, see i bought GH3 and i wasn't disappointed, it was different than what i expectedd. It is a competetive game and GH 1 and 2 and Rock's the 80's werent like that, they were the game where you could have fun with ur friends or urself. For competetive wise, its awesome. But most of the time, when i play games i am in the sit down and have some fun time. 1 out of 10, 10 being best, i think Rock Band is a 10 and GH3 a 9! what do you think? reply a rating for the games and why!

[Badosh]

my favorite of the guitar-based series would be gh the original
but rock abdn is the best since that one
Gh: 10/10
Gh2: 9/10
Gh3: 8/10
Rb: 9.5/10

[phulcrum1984]

I love both of them. RB is harder for me due to the smaller window to hit notes with the guitar but drumming is awesome and singing is fun when I'm drunk. Both get a solid 9 from me.

[dylan13]

I am renting guitar hero 3 right now and have betten it.they have alot of good songs,but I dont really like it.I think Rock Band is alot better even though I dont have it yet.

[Garthdude2]

i dont have it either, but i played on the tour and i love it!

[dylan13]

I have only played it at best buy.

[shadus]

Now we of cource all ...<SNIP>... reply a rating for the games and why!

GH 8/10, the FO/HO were annoying
GH2 9/10, best of the franchise imho
GHE 5/10, This was a song pack, nothing more, nothing less. Sucked.
GH3 7/10, Difficulty felt contrived.
RB 9/10, Excellent on G & D, only thing that bothers me is the "doot, doot, doot" sections in the singing, its bloody stupid.

[teh_roc]

RB for the whole group experience, drums and mic. GH3 for solo or 2 player guitar playing.