Fantasy All-Star Rock Band, Day 75: Pick A 5TH INSTRUMENT! (???)

[cherokeesam]

Welcome to Day 75, Band 11, of the Fantasy All-Star Rock Band Challenge!

Congrats to...um....JOAN JETT, who becomes the band's....uh....Bassist? :confused:

I'm not gonna argue with Joan. Would you? She'd kick your ass six ways from Sunday if you did. :(

Now it's time to expand our horizons a little. Normally, this is the part of the show where we'd pick a Keyboardist, or maybe a Rhythm Git. (heh.) But per Wings' excellent suggestion, I'm leaving this slot wide open for ANY "fifth instrument." You pick --- keyboard? Rhythm guitar? Sax? Accordion? Whatever you want, whoever....within the usual 1950s+ rock genre.


Just write the name of the artist you choose (subject to restrictions off the Retiree list below, as usual), AS WELL AS the instrument(s) he/she plays.

Day 1: Vocalist: Tom Waits
Day 2: Guitarist: Stevie Ray Vaughan
Day 3: Drummer: Mitch Mitchell (Jimi Hendrix Experience)
Day 4: Bassist: Joan Jett
Day 5: Fifth Instrument (any):
Day 6: Songwriter:
Day 7: NAME THIS BAND

The new (updated) retired band roster (you may not choose anyone on this list):

Ann Wilson
Steve Howe
Stewart Copeland
Geddy Lee
Rick Wakeman
Roger Daltrey
Eric Clapton
Keith Moon
Paul McCartney
Rod Argent
Freddie Mercury
Mick Ronson
Ian Paice
Dennis Dunaway
Brian Eno
Ronnie Van Zant
Duane Allman
Hughie Thomasson
Frank Beard
Berry Oakley
Buddy Brayfield
Jello Biafra
Mick Jones
Earl Hudson
Matt Freeman
Johnny Ramone
Eddie Vedder
Dave Navarro
Dave Grohl
Les Claypool
Buzz Osborne
Ronnie James Dio
Carlos Santana
Aynsley Dunbar
Jack Bruce
Jon Lord


For further rules and formatting, go here:

http://www.rockband.com/forums/showthread.php?t=116814


Good luck, and happy voting! (Voting closes at ***10 PM EST*** tomorrow.)

[cherokeesam]

John Coltrane (sax): 1

[MovieFreak921]

Leroi Moore (sax): 1
John Coltrane (sax): 1

RIP Roi.

[Fizzeler]

Bob Dylan (Rhythm Guitar/Harmonica): 1
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1

[cherokeesam]

Current:

John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 1 (it's still only one vote, Fizz, even if your artist plays multiple instruments)

[Fizzeler]

Current:

John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 1 (it's still only one vote, Fizz, even if your artist plays multiple instruments)

I know I had to edit like 5 times cause of the triple post

[MovieFreak921]

Current:

John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 1 (it's still only one vote, Fizz, even if your artist plays multiple instruments)

I changed my vote to Roi after realizing a harmonica player was a dumb idea, but I think Fizz copied and pasted my vote before I saved the change. Can I keep it?

[Fizzeler]

I changed my vote to Roi after realizing a harmonica player was a dumb idea, but I think Fizz copied and pasted my vote before I saved the change. Can I keep it?

is that a Dylan vote or Roi vote?

[ArmsAreLoud]

John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2

[MovieFreak921]

is that a Dylan vote or Roi vote?

Roi.

[Fizzeler]

Roi.

Okay

Current:
Bob Dylan (rhythm guitar/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1

Please specify it is rhythm guitar

[Hungryfreak]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1

So maybe it wouldn't fit, but you don't know until you try!

[cherokeesam]

Please specify it is rhythm guitar

Good point. :)
And Movie, your Bob Dylan vote never showed up on my thread, I only saw the Leroi vote. I'm assuming that Roi is the one you're keeping?

[Fizzeler]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1

So maybe it wouldn't fit, but you don't know until you try!

I think it would after all the more random the better :)

[cherokeesam]

I think it would after all the more random the better :)


TBH, Tom Waits would probably have a ball with a motley crew like this.

(CRUE!!! w00t. sorry)

[Fizzeler]

TBH, Tom Waits would probably have a ball with a motley crew like this.

(CRUE!!! w00t. sorry)

lol good one still Dylan and Waits for songwriter!

[thedaniel]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1

[Rockbandfan23467]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1

[WingsOfSteel]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 1

If anyone wants to know what the Joan Jett is, it means that she does percussion like footstomps and handclaps and whatnot.

[Runesmith]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1

[MronoC]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1zC4SSbdmU&feature=related): 1

[a21schizoidman]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1

[schmeankman]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion)

[kwami42]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1

[UneasyMonkey]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1

Literally lmao: "If anyone wants to know what the Joan Jett is, it means that she does percussion like footstomps and handclaps and whatnot."

[cherokeesam]

Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 1

If anyone wants to know what the Joan Jett is, it means that she does percussion like footstomps and handclaps and whatnot.

Okay, if (make that "when") Joan Jett wins, this band is officially shot to hell....:rolleyes:

Guess we can call this our "April Fools" band....sheesh

[My name is Fez]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

Because I will vote for him until he wins. Even if it's a thrash band.

[Soror_YZBL]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

[willdabeast21]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

[neckermanncj]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Maynard Ferguson (Trumpet): 1
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

[cniffd]

Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 2
Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Maynard Ferguson (Trumpet): 1
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

[MrFruitLord]

Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 2
Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 2
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Maynard Ferguson (Trumpet): 1
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Djalu Gurruwiwi (Didgeridoo): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1
Captain Beefheart (harmonica/sax): 1

[Hungryfreak]

Switch my vote to Beefheart for now.

[Rockbandfan23467]

Changing Vote.

Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 2
Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 3
Joan Jett (the Joan Jett): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Maynard Ferguson (Trumpet): 1
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1
Captain Beefheart (harmonica/sax): 2

[WingsOfSteel]

Okay, if (make that "when") Joan Jett wins, this band is officially shot to hell....:rolleyes:

Guess we can call this our "April Fools" band....sheesh

I never expected her to win, I was just voting for her as a goof and she ended up winning. If you want, you could pull her out and replace her with the runner-up, since I don't want her to be out of the running for next week.

Also, I'm changing Joan Jett (the Joan Jett) to Joan Jett (alternate lead vocals).

You know, like the New Pornographers have Neko Case and that other guy trade off lead vocal duties on different songs. I think it could work for this band.

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 3
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 2
Joan Jett (alternate lead vocals): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Captain Beefheart (harmonica/sax): 2
Maynard Ferguson (Trumpet): 1
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

[Fizzeler]

I never expected her to win, I was just voting for her as a goof and she ended up winning. If you want, you could pull her out and replace her with the runner-up, since I don't want her to be out of the running for next week.

Also, I'm changing Joan Jett (the Joan Jett) to Joan Jett (alternate lead vocals).

You know, like the New Pornographers have Neko Case and that other guy trade off lead vocal duties on different songs. I think it could work for this band.


I could see Waits and Jett in a duet also, for the name how about Tom Waits and the Stevie Dylan Jett Experience or 2 Old guys, 2 dead guys, and Joan Jett ;)

[UneasyMonkey]

Since Joan Jett isn't playing the Joan Jett anymore, I change my vote to Stevie Wonder...

[punkfan]

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 3
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 3
Joan Jett (alternate lead vocals): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Captain Beefheart (harmonica/sax): 2
Maynard Ferguson (Trumpet): 1
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Nancy Faust (keyboards/piano): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

Bob Dylan should really be saved for a chance to do vocals

[a21schizoidman]

i change my vote to Beefheart

Bob Dylan (rhythm/harmonica): 3
Scruffy Wallace (Bagpipes): 3
Joan Jett (alternate lead vocals): 2
John Coltrane (sax): 2
Captain Beefheart (harmonica/sax): 3
Maynard Ferguson (Trumpet): 1
Stevie Wonder (Piano/Harmonica): 1
Leroi Moore (sax): 1
Herman Li (Kazoo) :1
Steve Earle (Acoustic/rhythm guitar): 1
Ekona Jatta (Akonting): 1
Scott Crago: (Percussion): 1
Miles Davis (Trumpet): 1
Jake Shimabukuro (Ukulele): 1

[cherokeesam]

*sigh* Jesus H. Kristofferson, this week is getting out of hand....

After today, no more changing votes except in the event of a tie.

Speaking of ties (surprise, surprise), break this one.....next vote for an artist below wins it:

Bob Dylan
Scruffy Wallace
Capt. Beefheart

[Fizzeler]

bob dylan

[a21schizoidman]

Aye Aye CAPTAIN!

[cherokeesam]

buzzer-beater goes to:

Fizz, and Bob Dylan!

*polls closed*

[Gowienczyk]

Beefheart!

[Fizzeler]

buzzer-beater goes to:

Fizz, and Bob Dylan!

*polls closed*

w00t harmonicas FTW!

[Rockbandfan23467]

Dylan.