Best Fictional Supergroup

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

Pick The Supergroup you think is the greatest

[DethTung]

I only picked the second one because I know who most of them are.

[AKALink]

I was gonna say spinal tap.

[tridentgum0]

3rd one.

[Aragha]

I dunno who Ian Gillan is, soo... Yeah. But I know the other people in the first.

But I'm torn between the 2nd and 3rd... Both would be pretty neato.

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

I dunno who Ian Gillan is, soo... Yeah. But I know the other people in the first.

But I'm torn between the 2nd and 3rd... Both would be pretty neato.

Ian Gillan is the frontman for Deep Purple for most of there career

[BaneOfIcarus]

Gotta be group #3 for me. Keith and Jimi in #2 were a close second.

[Swivle]

I picked #3. Best all-around talent, I think, and Entwistle just edges out McCartney.

Also, I was thinking of Ian Gillan as the energetic singer for Jethro Tull, but I guess that's another Ian :D

[tridentgum0]

I picked #3. Best all-around talent, I think, and Entwistle just edges out McCartney.

Also, I was thinking of Ian Gillan as the energetic singer for Jethro Tull, but I guess that's another Ian :D

Anderson, Ian Anderson.

[classicrockdude]

i picked 1#, because Page and Gillian together would rock

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

i picked 1#, because Page and Gillian together would rock

That would be killer:)

[gmarsh]

the 3rd one is hard to deny

my supergroup
robert plant, jimi hendrix, john enwhistle(keith moon or neil peart, you choose)

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

the 3rd one is hard to deny

my supergroup
robert plant, jimi hendrix, john enwhistle(keith moon or neil peart, you choose)

I would only choose Neil Peart because I don't like using more than 1 member from an original band in a supergroup

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

No love for the first one:(:(:(

[macamatic]

Phil Labonte, Kris Norris, Greg Tribbett, and Danny Carey. :P

[sonicnerd23]

Group one, although I don't see how Paul will work.

[Corey-Volting]

Terry Bozzio - drums
Geezer Butler - bass
Dimebag Darrell Abbott- guitar
Mike Patton - vocals

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

Group one, although I don't see how Paul will work.

Why not?

[Corey-Volting]

Cuz the other guys aren't vegetarians. And they can't harmonize.

JK, I dont know.

It could be because he couldn't keep up with that level of talent. (IMO)

[Zeleii]

I dislike Classic Rock so those wouldn't be a "super" group at all.

Brann Dailor (Drums) - Mastodon, Lethargy, Today is the Day
Troy Sanders (Bass/Vocals) Mastodon
Kyle Shutt (Rhythm Guitar) - The Sword
Bill Kelliher (Lead Guitar) - Mastodon, Lethargy, Today is the Day
Josh Homme (Vocals) - Kyuss, Queens of the Stone Age (Notably)


That would be a sexy, thick, powerful Sludge/Stoner Metal Super Band I'd fap

[franticfish]

I like classic rock, but not as much as I used to. My super group would look more like this.

Bobby "Blitz" Ellsworth (Vocals) - Overkill
Roger Patterson (Bass) - Atheist
Gene Hoglan (Drums) - Dark Angel, Death.
Tommy T. Barron (Tommy Vetterli) (Lead Guitar) - Coroner
Eric Peterson (Rhythm Guitar) - Testament

Would be a tech thrash band with jazz elements courtesy of Roger Patterson and soaring Bruce Dickinson-esque vox of Bobby Ellsworth.

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

I dislike Classic Rock so those wouldn't be a "super" group at all.

Brann Dailor (Drums) - Mastodon, Lethargy, Today is the Day
Troy Sanders (Bass/Vocals) Mastodon
Kyle Shutt (Rhythm Guitar) - The Sword
Bill Kelliher (Lead Guitar) - Mastodon, Lethargy, Today is the Day
Josh Homme (Vocals) - Kyuss, Queens of the Stone Age (Notably)


That would be a sexy, thick, powerful Sludge/Stoner Metal Super Band I'd fap

That is just a ridiculous statement

[Zeleii]

That is just a ridiculous statement
Right my opinion is ridiculous... grow up and gtfo

[rowtheboat]

2

Hendrix + Plant = Win

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

Right my opinion is ridiculous... grow up and gtfo

The term "super group" wouldn't even exist without these guys

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

Right my opinion is ridiculous... grow up and gtfo

Look at the bold part, you can't say those wouldn't be super groups, I have no problem that you don't classic rock

[LegendofRock3021]

Right my opinion is ridiculous... grow up and gtfo

No, your opinion like everybody else's about whatever subject that's posted here should be respected upon since you can't be right or wrong with an opinion. These groups wouldn't be super groups to you since you are not a fan of classic rock, which is fine and RBF disagrees with you on that, which is also fine. I think you misunderstood a bit what point he was trying to get across.

[Soror_YZBL]

none of the above.

[classicrockdude]

2

Hendrix + Plant = Win

agree. I picked 1, because Page+Gillian=win

[Zeleii]

No, your opinion like everybody else's about whatever subject that's posted here should be respected upon since you can't be right or wrong with an opinion. These groups wouldn't be super groups to you since you are not a fan of classic rock, which is fine and RBF disagrees with you on that, which is also fine. I think you misunderstood a bit what point he was trying to get across.
I clearly said in my post "to me" but apparently these Classic Rock ass kissing fanboys missed that

[LegendofRock3021]

I clearly said in my post "to me" but apparently these Classic Rock ass kissing fanboys missed that

I'm sorry I missed the "to me" part of your post, I apologize for not looking at it closer. Point is nobody should be bashing your opinion since it's something you believe in.

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

I dislike Classic Rock so those wouldn't be a "super" group at all.

Brann Dailor (Drums) - Mastodon, Lethargy, Today is the Day
Troy Sanders (Bass/Vocals) Mastodon
Kyle Shutt (Rhythm Guitar) - The Sword
Bill Kelliher (Lead Guitar) - Mastodon, Lethargy, Today is the Day
Josh Homme (Vocals) - Kyuss, Queens of the Stone Age (Notably)


That would be a sexy, thick, powerful Sludge/Stoner Metal Super Band I'd fap

Where does it say "to me"?

[tridentgum0]

Phil Labonte, Kris Norris, Greg Tribbett, and Danny Carey. :P

Phil kills this group.

So many better vocalists in metal out there.

[Insane3]

#2 except I would prefer with Ian Gillan. Bruce+Hendrix+Moon=win

[Zeleii]

Where does it say "to me"?
Anyways, god forbid someone have an opinion.

Get over yourself I think classic rock sucks. I dislike it... if I don't like a bunch of artists collective what makes you think I'll believe they'll be "super" in a "super" group? Oh wait, that's right you like "superior" music so of course your opinion is more credible, it's worth more. Your opinion is FACT

Wouldn't is when used in a sentence with I usually implies opinion.
AREN'T would state that what I said is "fact"

Only artist in there I like in Jimi Hendrix and that's because he played more Psychedelic Blues. Every other one is your run of the mill classic rock band. I'll stick to my 80's Prog, Metal, Shoegaze and JMusic thank you.

[FastSolo.]

#1 cause Gillan is a superhero

[gmarsh]

actually I should have voted the 2nd one, its got three fourths of my dream supergroup so thats actually what I vote for.

[neckermanncj]

theres no "none" choice

[macamatic]

Phil kills this group.

So many better vocalists in metal out there.
Opinionated post is opinionated.

I'll explain why I picked him though. Two reasons:
1. He's crazy diverse. He can do singing and screaming across the spectrum and death growls too, and do it all well. That's not exactly common.
2. I love his voice, both singing and screaming.

Out of curiosity, who would you pick?

[franticfish]

Anyways, god forbid someone have an opinion.

Get over yourself I think classic rock sucks. I dislike it... if I don't like a bunch of artists collective what makes you think I'll believe they'll be "super" in a "super" group? Oh wait, that's right you like "superior" music so of course your opinion is more credible, it's worth more. Your opinion is FACT

Wouldn't is when used in a sentence with I usually implies opinion.
AREN'T would state that what I said is "fact"

Only artist in there I like in Jimi Hendrix and that's because he played more Psychedelic Blues. Every other one is your run of the mill classic rock band. I'll stick to my 80's Prog, Metal, Shoegaze and JMusic thank you.
I don't even like classic rock that much but too say Keith Moon was run of the mill is just stupid...

[Zeleii]

I don't even like classic rock that much but too say Keith Moon was run of the mill is just stupid...
Didn't say Keith Moon was a run of the mill drummer, but the bands are your average run of the mill Classic Rock bands.

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

Didn't say Keith Moon was a run of the mill drummer, but the bands are your average run of the mill Classic Rock bands.

the term "Super group" came from these bands

[ryan12147]

The 2nd one because of Keith Moon :)

[Zidane]

Number 3 for obvious reasons.

[Irnbruguy]

None of these.
This is one i had flying about for a while...


Bruce Dickinson on Vox
Paul Gilbert on Lead Guitar
Dave Mustaine on Rhythim
Les Claypool on Bass
Thomas Lang on Drums