Led Zeppelin vs. Brokencyde

[Soror_YZBL]

Which do you prefer? Vote above!

[ImHotterThanYou]

Led Zeppelin by so much that I can't even vote.

[Tank9088]

Brokencyde by SOOOOO much. Every time I listen to a brokencyde song it just makes me cry. They're just so poetic.

[a21schizoidman]

Brokencyde by SOOOOO much. Every time I listen to a brokencyde song it just makes me cry. They're just so poetic.
they make me cry, but for other reasons

[sozozoso]

Are you too scared to actually put Led Zep. in the poll choice.

[afterstasis]

i've determined i can't vote in anymore polls today, unless "neil young" is an option.

[a21schizoidman]

i've determined i can't vote in anymore polls today, unless "neil young" is an option.

i think Abnormality should've been in this one

[Fragory123]

It's hard to argue. Brokencyde is a good band and all but i'm putting my vote in for Brokencyde. They just have so much more going for them over Brokencyde.

[back_blows]

i've determined i can't vote in anymore polls today, unless "neil young" is an option.

Neil Young vs. The Mountain Goats?

[afterstasis]

Neil Young vs. The Mountain Goats?

BANNED, good sir!

[Mega-Tallica]

Zeppelin

[b4nny]

there about equal if u ask me

[back_blows]

BANNED, good sir!

I'm extremely tempted to put this poll in general.

[ImHotterThanYou]

Are you too scared to actually put Led Zep. in the poll choice.I think that's what it is.

[neckermanncj]

i would have voted for brokeNCYDE anyways, i HATE Led Zeppelin

[sonicnerd23]

Which Brokencyde is Led Zeppelin?

[Fragory123]

Which Brokencyde is Led Zeppelin?

The first one.

[Lolicat]

there about equal if u ask me

Are you kidding? brokenCYDE invented rock music! It's a fact, you can prefer Zepp if you want, but it's a fact that brokenCYDE are better. You can argue with my opinions but not my facts, my facts are right.

[MronoC]

The more I think about it, the more I think I genuinely enjoy listening to Brokencyde more, yeah they're awful, but they're hilariously awful, and if the whole thing is, in fact, a joke, then they might just be the most brilliant, high-concept, performance artists of all time.

[King_Nuthin]

This poll:
Great poll or Greatest poll.

[Idiostock]

The more I think about it, the more I think I genuinely enjoy listening to Brokencyde more, yeah they're awful, but they're hilariously awful, and if the whole thing is, in fact, a joke, then they might just be the most brilliant, high-concept, performance artists of all time.

Only a select few can pick out the best trolls.

[tridentgum0]

Nickelback.

[WingsOfSteel]

Brokencyde is my favorite grunge band, so I'm going with them.

[SteelersFreak1]

At least brokeNCYDE doesn't rip off music.

















I went there.

[classicrockdude]

Brokencyde is my favorite grunge band, so I'm going with them.

lol

[Alright_Computer]

At least brokeNCYDE doesn't rip off music.

















I went there.

Actually, if you listen to the song, the melody in "Freaxxx" is clearly lifted directly from Stairway to Heaven.

[classicrockdude]

Actually, if you listen to the song, the melody in "Freaxxx" is clearly lifted directly from Stairway to Heaven.

ya, But Page can't compete with BrokENCYDE's guitarist

[Alright_Computer]

ya, But Page can't compete with BrokENCYDE's guitarist

brokeNCYDE are too crunk for a guitarist. Se7en samples all of the stuff, it's awesome.

[NormanCoxwell]

Why the HELL does this thread even exist!

[MronoC]

Why the HELL does this thread even exist!

inorite? Brokencyde win by so much it's not even funny.

[classicrockdude]

brokeNCYDE are too crunk for a guitarist. Se7en samples all of the stuff, it's awesome.

BrokeNCYDE is too crunk for music. Their that good

[afterstasis]

BrokeNCYDE is too crunk for music. Their that good

it's not just a music, bro... it's a lifestyle.

[cherokeesam]

Depends....are you talking about BrokenCYDE's post-hardcore-proto-ska-punk era, or their newer emo-goth Scandinavian death metal/trad jazz fusion experimental phase?

[Mystlyfe77]

it's not just a music, bro... it's a lifestyle.

It's not just a lifestyle, bro... it's brokeNCYDE.

[Lolicat]

Actually, if you listen to the song, the melody in "Freaxxx" is clearly lifted directly from Stairway to Heaven.

You got it the wrong way around. Page stole all his best riffs from brokenCYDE, not that you can blame him. I mean, these are the guys who taught Woody Guthrie how to play punk, you know?

[Fragory123]

Depends....are you talking about BrokenCYDE's post-hardcore-proto-ska-punk era, or their newer emo-goth Scandinavian death metal/trad jazz fusion experimental phase?

I personally enjoyed their grunge-outlaw-country phase the most.

[SolidSnake526]

IT'S A TRAP!
Seriously, though, Zeppelin. It's the painfully obvious choice.

That's like saying Queen vs. Hollywood Undead...

[Evilbottom]

IT'S A TRAP!
Seriously, though, Zeppelin. It's the painfully obvious choice.

That's like saying Queen vs. Hollywood Undead...

Yeah, who WOULDN'T say Hollywood Undead?

[Fragory123]

Yeah, who WOULDN'T say Hollywood Undead?

Queen is talentless drivel compared to Hollywood Undead. Every song Hollywood Undead has ever released is a pure masterpiece.

[Soror_YZBL]

Queen is talentless drivel compared to Hollywood Undead. Every song Hollywood Undead has ever released is a pure masterpiece.

But Hollywood Undead vs Brokencyde would be a draw. Two powerhouses of awesomeness like that could possibly put an end the universe. I hope no one makes that thread.

[Lolicat]

But Hollywood Undead vs Brokencyde would be a draw. Two powerhouses of awesomeness like that could possibly put an end the universe. I hope no one makes that thread.

Can you imagine if they worked together to produce an album? It'd be like the Wyld Stallions!

[Soror_YZBL]

Can you imagine if they worked together to produce an album? It'd be like the Wyld Stallions!

that's too sexy for this cowgirl.

[Mystlyfe77]

Can you imagine if they worked together to produce an album? It'd be like the Wyld Stallions!

I just creamed in my trousers.

[ImHotterThanYou]

i would have voted for brokeNCYDE anyways, i HATE Led Zeppelin



Guys stop dissing Led Zeppelin. Zeppelin WAS a VERY mythical and influential band even outside of just the music world. Zeppelin also helped and influenced many authors!!!! Led zeppelin lyrics/music helped influence Tolkien to write The Lord of the Rings series, which is one of the most famous series of novels of ALL TIME! IF YOU PEOPLE ACTUALLY GAVE ZEPPELIN A CHANCE AND LISTENED TO BATLLE OF EVERMORE YOU WOULD KNOW THIS ALREADY!!!!!!!!!!!

THIS ZEPPELIN SCENE WAS A VERY STRONG INFLUENCE ON TOLKIEN AND HELPED CREATE EFFECTS AND IDEAS FOR THE LOTR MOVIES!!! (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdnPrj8-mwA)

THINK BEFORE YOU POST!!!

[Lolicat]

I just creamed in my trousers.

Me too. Double cream is awesome.

[MronoC]

But Hollywood Undead vs Brokencyde would be a draw. Two powerhouses of awesomeness like that could possibly put an end the universe. I hope no one makes that thread.

Unstoppable force, meet immovable object

[Evilbottom]

Guys stop dissing Led Zeppelin. Zeppelin WAS a VERY mythical and influential band even outside of just the music world. Zeppelin also helped and influenced many authors!!!! Led zeppelin lyrics/music helped influence Tolkien to write The Lord of the Rings series, which is one of the most famous series of novels of ALL TIME! IF YOU PEOPLE ACTUALLY GAVE ZEPPELIN A CHANCE AND LISTENED TO BATLLE OF EVERMORE YOU WOULD KNOW THIS ALREADY!!!!!!!!!!!

THIS ZEPPELIN SCENE WAS A VERY STRONG INFLUENCE ON TOLKIEN AND HELPED CREATE EFFECTS AND IDEAS FOR THE LOTR MOVIES!!! (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdnPrj8-mwA)

THINK BEFORE YOU POST!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qa6qpgLvH30

^^ That beats anything and everything by Led Zepplin ^^

[ImHotterThanYou]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qa6qpgLvH30

^^ That beats anything and everything by Led Zepplin ^^

That music and band is horrible.
Sorry but your lil *** modern band cannot compare to the classic gods which is LED ZEPPELIN!!!!

[instantdeath999]

Honestly, the only input I can give...

...lol.

[Idiostock]

Led zeppelin lyrics/music helped influence Tolkien to write The Lord of the Rings series

Correct me if I'm wrong, but all the novels were written and released long before Led Zep came into being.

[instantdeath999]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but all the novels were written and released long before Led Zep came into being.

Yeah, LOTR were written in the early 50's, I believe.

[Oscar-Rio]

poll win :up:

[Idiostock]

Yeah, LOTR were written in the early 50's, I believe.

Yeah, wiki says writing began in the 30s and publishing in 50s.

Zep started in '69, right?

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

Yeah, wiki says writing began in the 30s and publishing in 50s.

Zep started in '69, right?

Formed in 68, but whatever.

[Idiostock]

I assumed that Zep fanboy got the year right, if nothing else. *shrug*

[Cpt. Overkill]

Guys stop dissing Led Zeppelin. Zeppelin WAS a VERY mythical and influential band even outside of just the music world. Zeppelin also helped and influenced many authors!!!! Led zeppelin lyrics/music helped influence Tolkien to write The Lord of the Rings series, which is one of the most famous series of novels of ALL TIME! IF YOU PEOPLE ACTUALLY GAVE ZEPPELIN A CHANCE AND LISTENED TO BATLLE OF EVERMORE YOU WOULD KNOW THIS ALREADY!!!!!!!!!!!

THIS ZEPPELIN SCENE WAS A VERY STRONG INFLUENCE ON TOLKIEN AND HELPED CREATE EFFECTS AND IDEAS FOR THE LOTR MOVIES!!! (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdnPrj8-mwA)

THINK BEFORE YOU POST!!!

Does that mean people can't dislike them? No. Just because they were influential doesn't mean people have to like them. I respect them for what they did, but I'm not big into them.

Ah. You seem like me two years ago. I thought the same things you did. Don't worry, you'll come around.

[Meatwad555]

That music and band is horrible.
Sorry but your lil *** modern band cannot compare to the classic gods which is LED ZEPPELIN!!!!

He was obviously joking. Calm the hell down.

[ImHotterThanYou]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but all the novels were written and released long before Led Zep came into being.

Oh I didnt know. I dont even like lord of the rings.....other than the movies =)

[Idiostock]

THINK BEFORE YOU POST!!!
.

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

oh i didnt know. I dont even like lord of the rings.....other than the movies =)

think before you post!!

You might as well expand your horizons now. I was like you maybe a year ago. I thought Zep were the absolute best. But then I began to try out the recommendations given by the peeps in the HoR forum and I realized Zep weren't really that good to begin with. It was a big let down and I rarely listen to them anymore.

[tridentgum0]

Hotter, lrn2sarcasm. Every post in here regarding brokeNCYDE being good is sarcastic.

[ImHotterThanYou]

Hotter, lrn2sarcasm. Every post in here regarding brokeNCYDE being good is sarcastic.
I didnt know that I had not even heard of the group. So I couldnt detect the sarcasm.

[a21schizoidman]

I didnt know that I had not even heard of the group. So I couldnt detect the sarcasm.

if you'd ever heard any of the songs, you'd know right away

but, lucky for you, you hadn't :p

[Idiostock]

Obviously, the best advice is LURK MOAR

Sorry, I spent time earlier on Encyclopedia Dramatica. But yeah, BrokenCYDE is about as fantastic as Nickelback. whichisnone

[Meatwad555]

if you'd ever heard any of the songs, you'd know right away

but, lucky for you, you hadn't :p

Uhh..


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qa6qpgLvH30

^^ That beats anything and everything by Led Zepplin ^^


That music and band is horrible.
Sorry but your lil *** modern band cannot compare to the classic gods which is LED ZEPPELIN!!!!

She actually did.


Which further proves my point that she is a troll.

[ImHotterThanYou]

Uhh..





She actually did.


Which further proves my point that she is a troll.
I had not heard the band until I clicked the link.

[Rockbandfan23467]

Kenny's here!!!!!

*hugs Kenny untill his head pops off*

N E Way, Hottie, we're just jokeing about BrokENCYDE being better than Zeppelin.

[a21schizoidman]

N E Way, Hottie, we're just jokeing about BrokENCYDE being better than Zeppelin.

yeah, we all know they are on par with one another

[Rockbandfan23467]

yeah, we all know they are on par with one another

/facepalm.

[Alright_Computer]

I actually prefer listening to brokeNCYDE. I at least get some entertainment value from listening to them since they actually have comedic value. With Zeppelin all I hear is boring, snooze-tastic dadrock.

[Buffdog18]

You should've put Brokencyde or BrokeNCYDE, duh, there is a difference!

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

You should've put Brokencyde or BrokeNCYDE, duh, there is a difference!

Wow

I get it now

just... wow

it took me THAT long?

[MronoC]

Wow

I get it now

just... wow

it took me THAT long?

Yes, it's a play on words for "broken inside" because their such deep, tortured, artistic souls.

[ImHotterThanYou]

I actually prefer listening to brokeNCYDE. I at least get some entertainment value from listening to them since they actually have comedic value. With Zeppelin all I hear is boring, snooze-tastic dadrock.

haha

[tridentgum0]

haha

He's right. They don't sound different from any other band, save Plant's orgasmic, annoying vocals, which doesn't help.

[neckermanncj]

haha

your sig is incorrect

i believe ALL is a better band than Led Zeppelin

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ALL_(band)

[Alright_Computer]

haha

I literally want to fall asleep when I hear Stairway to Heaven or Kashmir, and their other songs don't do anything for me either.

[a21schizoidman]

Wow

I get it now

just... wow

it took me THAT long?

congratulations, you won the first annual montgomery burns award for outstanding achievement in the field of excellence

[ImHotterThanYou]

your sig is incorrect

i believe ALL is a better band than Led Zeppelin

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ALL_(band)

No that band sucks all I had to do was look at the punk rock label to know that.

[ImHotterThanYou]

I literally want to fall asleep when I hear Stairway to Heaven or Kashmir, and their other songs don't do anything for me either.

Your not deep enough for zeppelin then. There not anything that your going to dance or headbang too.

[neckermanncj]

No that band sucks all I had to do was look at the punk rock label to know that.

how ignorant can you be?

[Alright_Computer]

Your not deep enough for zeppelin then. There not anything that your going to dance or headbang too.

lolwut. Without trying to be too arrogant here, I find a good 80% of the music to be a lot deeper than Zeppelin could ever be.

[ImHotterThanYou]

lolwut. Without trying to be too arrogant here, I find a good 80% of the music to be a lot deeper than Zeppelin could ever be.

of what music?

[ImHotterThanYou]

how ignorant can you be?

Music taste is irrelevant to how smart you are. A genius could be a Britney Spears fan. I dont like punk rock so i'm not gonna praise them for that type of music.

[neckermanncj]

Music taste is irrelevant to how smart you are. A genius could be a Britney Spears fan. I dont like punk rock so i'm not gonna praise them for that type of music.

i said nothing about how smart you are, i have no idea where you got that from.


do you know what ignorant means?

[a21schizoidman]

Your not deep enough for zeppelin then. There not anything that your going to dance or headbang too.

really? you think Zeppelin is "deep"? this one song alone is much deeper than anything zeppelin is capable of (http://www.last.fm/music/Can/_/Halleluhwah?autostart)


No that band sucks all I had to do was look at the punk rock label to know that.

wow, you are afraid to listen to music that isn't led zeppelin, aren't you?

[supernova1324]

really? you think Zeppelin is "deep"? this one song alone is much deeper than anything zeppelin is capable of (http://www.last.fm/music/Can/_/Halleluhwah?autostart)



wow, you are afraid to listen to music that isn't led zeppelin, aren't you?Haven't you heard? Classic rock is the ony rock.

[a21schizoidman]

Haven't you heard? Classic rock is the ony rock.

anything else is just indie :p

[Gowienczyk]

Classic Rock hipsters are hilarious, aren't they?

[neckermanncj]

really? you think Zeppelin is "deep"? this one song alone is much deeper than anything zeppelin is capable of (http://www.last.fm/music/Can/_/Halleluhwah?autostart)



wow, you are afraid to listen to music that isn't led zeppelin, aren't you?

that song was pretty cool

[a21schizoidman]

Classic Rock hipsters are hilarious, aren't they?

they aren't as stuck up as indie hipsters, just ignorant

[Alright_Computer]

Classic Rock hipsters are hilarious, aren't they?

So are /b/tards pretending to be classic rock hipsters.

[back_blows]

Music taste is irrelevant to how smart you are. A genius could be a Britney Spears fan. I dont like punk rock so i'm not gonna praise them for that type of music.

What "punk rock" have you listened to? Green Day?

[neckermanncj]

Classic Rock hipsters are hilarious, aren't they?

now i know how it feels dealing with an ignorant person :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: :rolleyes::D

[a21schizoidman]

that song was pretty cool

haha, you called a prog song cool

[Gowienczyk]

they aren't as stuck up as indie hipsters, just ignorant

Indie Hipsters are just as bad, yeah. But at least I feel they are a little more open-mind... wait, no they aren't. They have the exact same mentality but reversed. I guess indie hipsters just never bothered me much until I met some of the ones on this site.

[Fizzeler]

that song was pretty cool

I see so like Prog. now

a21 you should have put up Yoo Doo Right

[Gowienczyk]

Krautrock was one of the better progressive scenes at the time, though. So it's not a stretch.

[neckermanncj]

haha, you called a prog song cool


I see so like Prog. now

a21 you should have put up Yoo Doo Right

idk it wasn't that bad, better than zeppelin for sure


Indie Hipsters are just as bad, yeah. But at least I feel they are a little more open-mind... wait, no they aren't. They have the exact same mentality but reversed. I guess indie hipsters just never bothered me much until I met some of the ones on this site.

*raises hand*

[a21schizoidman]

Indie Hipsters are just as bad, yeah. But at least I feel they are a little more open-mind... wait, no they aren't. They have the exact same mentality but reversed. I guess indie hipsters just never bothered me much until I met some of the ones on this site.

i think they both are bad, but one seems more clueless and the other seems more "i know i'm right and you are wrong and you are evil because you listen to bands that are mainstream and signed to big record labels" and shove it all in your face

[Gowienczyk]

*raises hand*

You did definitely frustrate me, but you are improving from that niche of a hipster mentality.

[neckermanncj]

You did definitely frustrate me, but you are improving from that niche of a hipster mentality.

:p

[ImHotterThanYou]

really? you think Zeppelin is "deep"? this one song alone is much deeper than anything zeppelin is capable of (http://www.last.fm/music/Can/_/Halleluhwah?autostart)



wow, you are afraid to listen to music that isn't led zeppelin, aren't you?
I never said LZ was the deepest and I have already said many times I listen to lots of music other than them.

[Gowienczyk]

i think they both are bad, but one seems more clueless and the other seems more "i know i'm right and you are wrong and you are evil because you listen to bands that are mainstream and signed to big record labels" and shove it all in your face

Classic Rock Hipster: "All new music sucks, only old music is good and creative and crap. New music is all pop and crunk rap. New music will never be good unless they are imitating the greatest bands ever like the Beatles or Led Zeppelin!!!111"

I think thats equal to your indie quote. :)

[a21schizoidman]

I see so like Prog. now

a21 you should have put up Yoo Doo Right

i like Yoo Doo Right, but i prefer Halleluhwah

[Gowienczyk]

:p

Slowly improving, mind you.

[supernova1324]

Classic Rock Hipster: "All new music sucks, only old music is good and creative and crap. New music is all pop and crunk rap. New music will never be good unless they are imitating the greatest bands ever like the Beatles or Led Zeppelin!!!111"

I think thats equal to your indie quote. :)


That's sort of how my dad acts, but he is starting to get more and more open to newer music.

[neckermanncj]

Classic Rock Hipster: "All new music sucks, only old music is good and creative and crap. New music is all pop and crunk rap. New music will never be good unless they are imitating the greatest bands ever like the Beatles or Led Zeppelin!!!111"

I think thats equal to your indie quote. :)

what happens when they run out of music?? :eek:


Slowly improving, mind you.

i know

[ImHotterThanYou]

i said nothing about how smart you are, i have no idea where you got that from.


do you know what ignorant means?
Lacking knowledge.

[Fizzeler]

i like Yoo Doo Right, but i prefer Halleluhwah

still looking for the 6 hour version of the song :D

[Chopper13]

Are you kidding me? Brokencyde sucks. Some of the worst music I've ever heard.

[Alright_Computer]

evrything after 1994 is otomaticuly crap guiz

[Gowienczyk]

That's sort of how my dad acts, but he is starting to get more and more open to newer music.

Being old, arrogant and narrow-minded is called being old.

When you are under the age of 30 and act like that however...

[a21schizoidman]

I never said LZ was the deepest and I have already said many times I listen to lots of music other than them.

yet you fail to ever mention any of them :p


Classic Rock Hipster: "All new music sucks, only old music is good and creative and crap. New music is all pop and crunk rap. New music will never be good unless they are imitating the greatest bands ever like the Beatles or Led Zeppelin!!!111"

I think thats equal to your indie quote. :)

oddly, i never had an overly-agressive classic rock hipster talk to me, there are a lot whom are ignorant (hell, i was too at a point), but they always seemed more mellow, the indie hipsters act like they know everything and always got aggressive and irritating when i met them

[supernova1324]

Are you kidding me? Brokencyde sucks. Some of the worst music I've ever heard.

NounSingular
sarcasm
Plural
sarcasms


sarcasm (plural sarcasms)

(uncountable) A form of humor that is marked by mocking with irony, sometimes conveyed in speech with vocal over-emphasis. Saying something that is opposite of what is intended to be meant.

[a21schizoidman]

still looking for the 6 hour version of the song :D

always

[franticfish]

always
Can it get anymore prog than that?

[Fizzeler]

Classic Rock Hipster: "All new music sucks, only old music is good and creative and crap. New music is all pop and crunk rap. New music will never be good unless they are imitating the greatest bands ever like the Beatles or Led Zeppelin!!!111"

I think thats equal to your indie quote. :)

Swap that and you have my brother (he only likes modern pop and Nu-Metal)

[a21schizoidman]

Can it get anymore prog than that?

needs more banjo

[Gowienczyk]

yet you fail to ever mention any of them :p



oddly, i never had an overly-agressive classic rock hipster talk to me, there are a lot whom are ignorant (hell, i was too at a point), but they always seemed more mellow, the indie hipsters act like they know everything and always got aggressive and irritating when i met them

I've met plenty of aggressive, arrogant idiotic classic rock hipsters throughout several message boards.

[a21schizoidman]

I've met plenty of aggressive, arrogant idiotic classic rock hipsters throughout several message boards.

see, you're talking message boards, i'm talking real life

i can ignore those idiots on message boards

[ImHotterThanYou]

yet you fail to ever mention any of them :p



You must have missed the posts while trying to simply focus on the posts i make about LZ.

[a21schizoidman]

You must have missed the posts while trying to simply focus on the posts i make about LZ.

no, i've seen, you listen to 22+ bands, all mainstream major artists, and i can guess you only listen to the major albums and compilations, and can only name the hit songs, sure, you might say one of the others, but it's the internet, you can look that up in 3 seconds to type it without having a clue

[Gowienczyk]

see, you're talking message boards, i'm talking real life

i can ignore those idiots on message boards

I don't remember too many hipsters when I was in high school or otherwise in reality. My classic rock hipster-esque friend likes Primus for example... so yeah. Not exactly the same. Really, most of my friends are at least open to new things.

[classicrockdude]

ImHotterThanYou is a very bad troll

[ImHotterThanYou]

no, i've seen, you listen to 22+ bands, all mainstream major artists, and i can guess you only listen to the major albums and compilations, and can only name the hit songs, sure, you might say one of the others, but it's the internet, you can look that up in 3 seconds to type it without having a clue
Yeah theres nothing wrong with listening to mainstream artists and I know almost everything about the mainstream classic bands.

[supernova1324]

Yeah theres nothing wrong with listening to mainstream artists and I know almost everything about the mainstream classic bands.

So does every other 15 year old.

[a21schizoidman]

So does every other 15 year old.

zing!

[ImHotterThanYou]

So does every other 15 year old.Nope, barely anyone at my school listens to classic rock. The only old bands any of them know is like stones,beatles and gnr. They all like lil wayne, soulja boy, and stuff.

[neckermanncj]

So does every other 15 year old.

lock it up! :D

[Gowienczyk]

If you only listen to mainstream music, you are simply a limited individual with no will to branch into music and enjoy it on a greater basis. There is nothing wrong with mainstream musicians but if that's all you know, it's just depressing really.

[classicrockdude]

Would I be considered a classic rock hipster:D

[franticfish]

Would I be considered a classic rock hipster:DYeah, alebit a more tolerable type of classic rock hipster.

[supernova1324]

The only old bands any of them know is like stones,beatles and gnr.

I could say the same for you.

[Gowienczyk]

Would I be considered a classic rock hipster:D

You sure don't seem to show anything suggesting otherwise.

[Mystlyfe77]

I still can't believe brokenCYDE is beating brokenCYDE. I didn't think it was possible for brokenCYDE to lose!

[neckermanncj]

I still can't believe brokenCYDE is beating brokenCYDE. I didn't think it was possible for brokenCYDE to lose!

lol

[Fizzeler]

Nope, barely anyone at my school listens to classic rock. The only old bands any of them know is like stones,beatles and gnr. They all like lil wayne, soulja boy, and stuff.

Depends what group of people you talk to, but for the most part the "popular kids" in my school just like mainstream pop music

[ImHotterThanYou]

I could say the same for you. Na, when I said they knew them I meant that they have heard of them and could tell you it was a band. But they wouldnt know any members, albums or songs by name.

[a21schizoidman]

Na, when I said they knew them I meant that they have heard of them and could tell you it was a band. But they wouldnt know any members, albums or songs by name.

they could be like you and look upon wikipedia before they answer though! :p

[classicrockdude]

they could be like you and look upon wikipedia before they answer though! :p

lol

[neckermanncj]

they could be like you and look upon wikipedia before they answer though! :p

i always use wikipedia (#1 bookmark on my computer! :D) mostly to see if i'm DLing the right files for an album and to make sure the track names are correct

[Alright_Computer]

they could be like you and look upon wikipedia before they answer though! :p

Touche

[ImHotterThanYou]

If you only listen to mainstream music, you are simply a limited individual with no will to branch into music and enjoy it on a greater basis. There is nothing wrong with mainstream musicians but if that's all you know, it's just depressing really.
I dont see why it would be depressing. Alot of people listen to music just for pure happiness and joy. If they can achieve that by listening to people like Lil Wayne and Soulja Boy or any other mainstream pop artist than why diss them for it? Im the minority on this forum, You people diss me so much for listening to Mainstream Classic Rock almost to the extent that it seems like i'm the only one NOT following the trend.

[Gowienczyk]

Because it's depressing how limited people are. It always is. A narrow mind is a unhealthy one.

[ImHotterThanYou]

they could be like you and look upon wikipedia before they answer though! :pI wouldnt need to I know everything about my big classic rock bands.

[a21schizoidman]

I wouldnt need to I know everything about my big classic rock bands.

Zeppelin wasn't big, they only had 4 members! :p:p

[franticfish]

I wouldnt need to I know everything about my big classic rock bands.
Who did Jimmy Page intend to be the lead singer of Led Zeppelin before he found Robert Plant and what was the name of Bonham's band before Zeppelin?

[Mystlyfe77]

I wouldnt need to I know everything about my big classic rock bands.

What key is "Stairway to Heaven" and which chord in the song is seemingly "out of place" because of it?

[Fizzeler]

Who did Jimmy Page intend to be the lead singer of Led Zeppelin before he found Robert Plant and what was the name of Bonham's band before Zeppelin?

What album is your new avatar?

[Alright_Computer]

What is the 464th bass note in Stairway to Heaven, and what notes are sharp/flat in the harmonic minor of said note?

[instantdeath999]

What key is "Stairway to Heaven" and which chord in the song is seemingly "out of place" because of it?

No fair!!!1!

[franticfish]

What album is your new avatar?
Immense Intense Suspense by prog/avant garde death metal band Phlebotomized they have some awesome violin sections.

[Fizzeler]

Immense Intense Suspense by prog/avant garde death metal band Phlebotomized they have some awesome violin sections.

interesting :)

[ImHotterThanYou]

Who did Jimmy Page intend to be the lead singer of Led Zeppelin before he found Robert Plant and what was the name of Bonham's band before Zeppelin?
Bonzo was in two bands before Zep, A way of life and another one of them was with Plant the name was something of joy.

i dont know who page intended the lead singer to be tho

[franticfish]

Bonzo was in two bands before Zep, A way of life and another one of them was with Plant the name was something of joy.

i dont know who page intended the lead singer to be tho
So you dont know everything then do you.

[ImHotterThanYou]

What key is "Stairway to Heaven" and which chord in the song is seemingly "out of place" because of it?I dont know what key any song is in.

[classicrockdude]

Who did Jimmy Page intend to be the lead singer of Led Zeppelin before he found Robert Plant

Was it Stevie Winwood?

[franticfish]

Was it Stevie Winwood?
Nah it was Terry Reid.

[ImHotterThanYou]

So you dont know everything then do you.
No!
I could of thrown many guesses out though.

[classicrockdude]

Nah it was Terry Reid.

well, i heard he wanted Winwood in the band though. Maybe not singer.

[franticfish]

interesting :)
You should defintely check it out.

[Fizzeler]

You should defintely check it out.

Will do :D

[ImHotterThanYou]

Fine, I give in you people have convinced me to branch out a bit. Im going to start out with exploring into the catalog of The Yardbirds with more depth and a more open mind.

[Alright_Computer]

:rolleyes: Obvious troll is obvious

JUST IGNORE SCHLER

[Rockbandfan23467]

N E 1 see my tags?

[a21schizoidman]

N E 1 see my tags?

no, because no one looks at tags

[ImHotterThanYou]

N E 1 see my tags?I try to move to a less mainstream band yet all you people still diss me for it. I cant win =(

[a21schizoidman]

I try to move to a less mainstream band yet all you people still diss me for it. I cant win =(

what? he was talking about the tags at the bottom of the thread

[Rockbandfan23467]

Fine, I give in you people have convinced me to branch out a bit. Im going to start out with exploring into the catalog of The Yardbirds with more depth and a more open mind.

Imhotterthanyou, if you haven't already, mabye you should check out the music blog some of our regulars run. That will give you an idea. Or go to the "Come here for music recomendations" thread.

[Alright_Computer]

I try to move to a less mainstream band yet all you people still diss me for it. I cant win =(

Because the Yardbirds are so different from Zeppelin... oh wait, no. they aren't.

[Rockbandfan23467]

Because the Yardbirds are so different from Zeppelin... oh wait, no. they aren't.

Schee's genuninly trying to improve herself the way I see it.

[ImHotterThanYou]

Because the Yardbirds are so different from Zeppelin... oh wait, no. they aren't.
You dont wanna start off to drastic.

[Nuff_Said]

I try to move to a less mainstream band yet all you people still diss me for it. I cant win =(

Zeppelin is not that amazing.

Boy are you about to be disappointed.

http://www.associatedcontent.com/video/26428/led_zeppelin_rip_off_artists_.html?cat=33

[Zidane]

Looks like Brokencyde is winning, which makes sense since their lead singer's voice isn't as annoying as Led Zeppelin's.

[moose39]

Zeppelin is not that amazing.

Boy are you about to be disappointed.

http://www.associatedcontent.com/video/26428/led_zeppelin_rip_off_artists_.html?cat=33

Does everyone have to bring that video up? I'm aware that 40% of their music isn't original, and I'm perfectly fine with it. The stuff that isn't original is still Zeppelin and I still like it.

Seriously, people, I know that ImHotterThanYou is a "Zeppelin troll," but it doesn't mean you have to say "Zeppelin sucks" everytime one of these threads pop up. I know you think that Plant's a horrible/annoying singer and he says "baby" every other word, you think Jimmy Page isn't "all that great" of a guitarist, and Keith Moon, along with DOZENS of other drummers, are better than John Bonham, but STILL. I like them, and you should respect people's tastes in music, even if you do classify it as "bad."

[ImHotterThanYou]

Zeppelin is not that amazing.

Boy are you about to be disappointed.

http://www.associatedcontent.com/video/26428/led_zeppelin_rip_off_artists_.html?cat=33
Already knew about it. It's mainly lyrics except for dazed and confused thats a complete rip.

[Gowienczyk]

Respect is earned.

[Alright_Computer]

Already knew about it. It's mainly lyrics except for dazed and confused thats a complete rip.

...

How is the intro to Stairway to Heaven not a complete ripoff of the Spirit song?

[classicrockdude]

Ripping on Zeppelin is becoming more popular is can see.

[ImHotterThanYou]

...

How is the intro to Stairway to Heaven not a complete ripoff of the Spirit song?Lol because it's not the same notes. It has the same feeling but its not the same. If that band tried were to sue zep for some money or some credits they definitely would lose because the copyright's just dont cover stuff that vague. But I do believe Page got the idea for the riff directly from that song and with all the other songs I dont really think Zep was trying to steal the lyrics in a secret way. I believe they did it for a reason. Why else would they keep the same song titles from the originals? Also most of these songs come from the debut which was wrote and recorded in a little bit over a day. Im pretty sure they never thought the band was going to blow up like it did.

[Blinkerz]

Why don't people hate on Journey, REO Speedwagon, and Styx as much they do on Zep?
Seriously... They deserve it more.

[afterstasis]

i personally prefer journey and REO to zeppelin. that is all.

[MronoC]

Why don't people hate on Journey, REO Speedwagon, and Styx as much they do on Zep?
Seriously... They deserve it more.

Because there aren't obscene amounts of people claiming that Journey and Styx the greatest bands ever.

[Zidane]

Because there aren't obscene amounts of people claiming that Journey and Styx the greatest bands ever.

True that.

[a21schizoidman]

Because there aren't obscene amounts of people claiming that Journey and Styx the greatest bands ever.

exactly


i personally prefer journey and REO to zeppelin. that is all.

agreed, i LOVE REO

[ImHotterThanYou]

Never heard of REO.

[Fizzeler]

Never heard of REO.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YY6lXA-QPYc&feature=related

[Rockbandfan23467]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YY6lXA-QPYc&feature=related

I was dissappointed we didn't get the live Riden' The Storm Out.

[ImHotterThanYou]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YY6lXA-QPYc&feature=relatedOh "REO Speedwagon" I heard of them before but never listened to them. I was thinking "reo" as another bands initials.

[thedaniel]

The way I see it, at least Brokencyde can live up to the hype built up around them.

[Lolicat]

The way I see it, at least Brokencyde can live up to the hype built up around them.

This. Breee breee.

[chumsicles]

Why don't people hate on Journey, REO Speedwagon, and Styx as much they do on Zep?
Seriously... They deserve it more.

Agreed

For all their pretentiousness, bombast, and pomposity, Zep really were talented performers and excellent songwriters

Journey, REO, and Styx are all cliche, cheesy by-the-numbers arena rock garbage and deserve every amount of hate they get (which is not nearly as much as Zep gets) In fact, I don't think I know anyone who hates Journey besides me (and you I guess)

[Fragory123]

Agreed

Journey, REO, and Styx are all cliche, cheesy by-the-numbers arena rock garbage and deserve every amount of hate they get (which is not nearly as much as Zep gets) In fact, I don't think I know anyone who hates Journey besides me (and you I guess)

I absolutley despise Journey. I cannot bare to listen to "Don't Stop Believin'".

[chaosxflame]

I absolutley despise Journey. I cannot bare to listen to "Don't Stop Believin'".


i know what you mean although im not hating on the band, but that song drives me insane and yet the cover bands at the local bars near me play it constantly. to paraphrase a lewis black quote " I want to take a pencil and shove it in my ears"

[Fragory123]

i know what you mean although im not hating on the band, but that song drives me insane and yet the cover bands at the local bars near me play it constantly. to paraphrase a lewis black quote " I want to take a pencil and shove it in my ears"

To be honest, I hate all anthem/arena rock except Bang Camaro. Bang Camaro is the only band in the genre I actually like.

[a21schizoidman]

Agreed

For all their pretentiousness, bombast, and pomposity, Zep really were talented performers and excellent songwriters

Journey, REO, and Styx are all cliche, cheesy by-the-numbers arena rock garbage and deserve every amount of hate they get (which is not nearly as much as Zep gets) In fact, I don't think I know anyone who hates Journey besides me (and you I guess)

you've only heard the mainstream radio songs, haven't you?

Journey started as a jazz fusion band

Styx started as a prog band

REO Speedwagon started as a hard rock group in the late 60s

[JukeBoxHero]

you've only heard the mainstream radio songs, haven't you?

Journey started as a jazz fusion band

Styx started as a prog band

REO Speedwagon started as a hard rock group in the late 60s

It's pretty obvious man

[dalcyte]

lulz brokencyde is funnay

[cherokeesam]

To be honest, I hate all anthem/arena rock except Bang Camaro. Bang Camaro is the only band in the genre I actually like.

Why?
Not slamming....just curious.
I like Bang Camaro too, but I'm just wondering why you admit to liking a modern band that pays lip service to arena rock (possibly as parody, possibly as an homage....I'm still not sure which), yet you dislike the original arena rockers.

[camero1970]

Who the hell even made this thread up? Led Zeppelin vs Brokencyde. Really, can you even compare those 2 together. No, no you can not...I have an idea, lets do a compare on contrast situation(just like in high school).

Their first albums:
Led Zeppelin-The album was released in 1969 and according to entertainweekly, it received an A-. With songs like these:Good Time, Bad Times, Babe im gonna leave you, Dazed and Confused, and communication breakdown, ALL instant hits. This album is worthy of attention and if you havent even heard it, please, do yourself a favor and go check your brain, cause you might have cancer.

The album is certified 8X platinum
__________________________________________________ ________

Brokencyde-this album was released, this year, and recieved a 16, which is an F by absolutely punk. Thats awful.....in so many ways this album doesnt even need to be heard. I think the only people who would seriously listen to this band are possibly the same ones who follow, The Millionaires.

Quote from NME, "even if I caught Prince Harry and Gary Glitter adorned in Nazi regalia defecating through my grandmother’s letterbox I would still consider making them listen to this album too severe a punishment".[

Quote from the press, "might just be the most hated band in America,"

This album has sold 6000 copies.....
__________________________________________________ ________

Im pretty sure this is enough to convince you that, Led Zeppelin is better than brokeNCYDE.

other than this, im done, dont get mad, dont *****, this is true whether you realise it of not...

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

Who the hell even made this thread up? Led Zeppelin vs Brokencyde. Really, can you even compare those 2 together. No, no you can not...I have an idea, lets do a compare on contrast situation(just like in high school).

Their first albums:
Led Zeppelin-The album was released in 1969 and according to entertainweekly, it received an A-. With songs like these:Good Time, Bad Times, Babe im gonna leave you, Dazed and Confused, and communication breakdown, ALL instant hits. This album is worthy of attention and if you havent even heard it, please, do yourself a favor and go check your brain, cause you might have cancer.

The album is certified 8X platinum
__________________________________________________ ________

Brokencyde-this album was released, this year, and recieved a 16, which is an F by absolutely punk. Thats awful.....in so many ways this album doesnt even need to be heard. I think the only people who would seriously listen to this band are possibly the same ones who follow, The Millionaires.

Quote from NME, "even if I caught Prince Harry and Gary Glitter adorned in Nazi regalia defecating through my grandmother’s letterbox I would still consider making them listen to this album too severe a punishment".[

Quote from the press, "might just be the most hated band in America,"

This album has sold 6000 copies.....
__________________________________________________ ________

Im pretty sure this is enough to convince you that, Led Zeppelin is better than brokeNCYDE.

other than this, im done, dont get mad, dont *****, this is true whether you realise it of not...
1. This is a joke thread.
2. If album sales = quality, Miley Cyrus is better than the Velvet Underground.

[Oscar-Rio]

Who the hell even made this thread up? Led Zeppelin vs Brokencyde. Really, can you even compare those 2 together. No, no you can not...I have an idea, lets do a compare on contrast situation(just like in high school).

Their first albums:
Led Zeppelin-The album was released in 1969 and according to entertainweekly, it received an A-. With songs like these:Good Time, Bad Times, Babe im gonna leave you, Dazed and Confused, and communication breakdown, ALL instant hits. This album is worthy of attention and if you havent even heard it, please, do yourself a favor and go check your brain, cause you might have cancer.

The album is certified 8X platinum
__________________________________________________ ________

Brokencyde-this album was released, this year, and recieved a 16, which is an F by absolutely punk. Thats awful.....in so many ways this album doesnt even need to be heard. I think the only people who would seriously listen to this band are possibly the same ones who follow, The Millionaires.

Quote from NME, "even if I caught Prince Harry and Gary Glitter adorned in Nazi regalia defecating through my grandmother’s letterbox I would still consider making them listen to this album too severe a punishment".[

Quote from the press, "might just be the most hated band in America,"

This album has sold 6000 copies.....
__________________________________________________ ________

Im pretty sure this is enough to convince you that, Led Zeppelin is better than brokeNCYDE.

other than this, im done, dont get mad, dont *****, this is true whether you realise it of not...

...just, wow. Did you even look at the poll? Did you read the thread?

[camero1970]

1. This is a joke thread.
2. If album sales = quality, Miley Cyrus is better than the Velvet Underground.

I know, i wanted to actually see if this would piss off and "actual" BrokeNCYDE fan, if they exist.

And in certain situation album sales do mean quality. Led zeppelins first CD went 6 years and sold atleast 5 million record... claiming the fact that over time, people heard it and bought it..

[camero1970]

...just, wow. Did you even look at the poll? Did you read the thread?

YESSSSSSS, i was just LITERALLY making a comparison between the two.

[Oscar-Rio]

YESSSSSSS, i was just LITERALLY making a comparison between the two.

for what? incase we're a bunch of clueless boobs that have never heard of Led Zeppelin or BrokenCYDE?

[afterstasis]

Why?
Not slamming....just curious.
I like Bang Camaro too, but I'm just wondering why you admit to liking a modern band that pays lip service to arena rock (possibly as parody, possibly as an homage....I'm still not sure which), yet you dislike the original arena rockers.

my one close friend who strongly dislikes arena rock and hair metal is also a huge fan of the darkness (whom i also like, to be honest). it's bizarre.

[Lolicat]

I honestly get more out of brokenCYDE. Zepp are boring.

[xTerp]

Brokecyde since they bring all the fans of music together. Everyone, no matter what genre they listen to, hates them. Where there's mixed reactions on Led Zeppelin.

[JukeBoxHero]

I know, i wanted to actually see if this would piss off and "actual" BrokeNCYDE fan, if they exist.


Oh they exist, like any fans of a band, they are always holding up in some part of the internet.(I've seen a few online).

[Soror_YZBL]

hotter, lrn2sarcasm. Every post in here regarding brokencyde being good is sarcastic.

liar!

[WingsOfSteel]

Who the hell even made this thread up? Led Zeppelin vs Brokencyde. Really, can you even compare those 2 together. No, no you can not...I have an idea, lets do a compare on contrast situation(just like in high school).

Their first albums:
Led Zeppelin-The album was released in 1969 and according to entertainweekly, it received an A-. With songs like these:Good Time, Bad Times, Babe im gonna leave you, Dazed and Confused, and communication breakdown, ALL instant hits. This album is worthy of attention and if you havent even heard it, please, do yourself a favor and go check your brain, cause you might have cancer.

The album is certified 8X platinum
__________________________________________________ ________

Brokencyde-this album was released, this year, and recieved a 16, which is an F by absolutely punk. Thats awful.....in so many ways this album doesnt even need to be heard. I think the only people who would seriously listen to this band are possibly the same ones who follow, The Millionaires.

Quote from NME, "even if I caught Prince Harry and Gary Glitter adorned in Nazi regalia defecating through my grandmother’s letterbox I would still consider making them listen to this album too severe a punishment".[

Quote from the press, "might just be the most hated band in America,"

This album has sold 6000 copies.....
__________________________________________________ ________

Im pretty sure this is enough to convince you that, Led Zeppelin is better than brokeNCYDE.

other than this, im done, dont get mad, dont *****, this is true whether you realise it of not...

Uh, sorry, Brokencyde is punk as ****. You're a total sheep, liking what the music press tells you to. The only music publication that matters is MY ZINE, and it says Brokencyde is way better than Led ZeppeLOSERS.

[Mystlyfe77]

And in certain situation album sales do mean quality. Led zeppelins first CD went 6 years and sold atleast 5 million record... claiming the fact that over time, people heard it and bought it..

no. no. no. No. no.

Album sales NEVER directly relate to quality. Never.

[Alright_Computer]

liar!

This is quite possibly the greatest post ever. But WingsOfSteel's post comes close.

[Soror_YZBL]

no. no. no. No. no.

Album sales NEVER directly relate to quality. Never.

FACT: Milli Vanilli sold over 6 million records in the US.

Then again, girl you know its true was a tight track. :)

[Lolicat]

I'm gonna get the names of brokenCYDE tatooed on my testicles.

[classicrockdude]

I'm gonna get the names of brokenCYDE tatooed on my testicles.

Beat you to it:p

[Nuff_Said]

come ooooon. Brokencyde is only 4 votes back.

[tridentgum0]

come ooooon. Brokencyde is only 4 votes back.

No. BrokeNCYDE is winning and they should be. BrokeNCYDE sucks.