Which do you like better?

[vindictiv1177]

Ok, this is a stupid question to ask on the rock band forums and I doubt there will be ANY GHvotes but.....whhatever.
My friend and I had a fight over which is better
GH or Rock Band
I said rock band
He said Guitar hero
I know he is wrong!

So, out of u guys.....which u like better?

Guitar Hero (The series in genral) or Rock Band?

[pntbllrspdr]

Well, considering these are the Rock Band forums.... lol. I don't have the game yet, so I'm not going to vote. I think it's fairly easy for most people to say Rock Band is better, because you can sing, play, drums, guitar, and bass. You get the whole band experience. Guitar Hero is mostly for peopel that like/don't mind playing alone.

Of course, without Guitar Hero we wouldn't even have Rock Band. I can pretty much tell without even having the game yet that Rock Band will replace Gutiar Hero for me, mostly becuase there's so much to do! I don't plan on buying Guitar Hero 4, unless Activision does something amazing, but I'm not holding my breath..

[1guitarhero4]

Thats a tough choice becuase guitar hero is my favorite game (dont have rock band yet) and I love a good challenge cuz if its too easy its boring so idk guitar hero is a pretty amazing series but i think with friends and stuff rock band wins.

[borsdy]

I will tell you I don't like GH3.

[Lareden]

Wow, dumb poll. That's like polling Endgadget posters "what type of lifestyle do you prefer: Techie or Amish?"

For the record I've never bought any GH games. I've played them a couple times and had fun, but not enough to want to buy them.

[shadus]

Ok, this is a stupid question to ask on the rock band forums and I doubt there will be ANY GHvotes but.....whhatever.
My friend and I had a fight over which is better
GH or Rock Band
I said rock band
He said Guitar hero
I know he is wrong!

So, out of u guys.....which u like better?

Guitar Hero (The series in genral) or Rock Band?

Nothing wrong with GH, I just like the variety, it's like they stuffed 3 games into 1. You've more or a less got GH, Karaoke Revolution, and a drum game all in one convenient package and you can bust it up with your friends which makes it even better... our Saturday pnp rpg game has turned into Saturday pnp rpg game followed by a concert.

If you want to compare rockband's guitar and guitar hero's guitar, I'd say GH2 is better than Rockbands guitar, but rockband is better than 1 (fo/ho issues) and 3 (amount of notes feel contrived and don't feel like they fit the songs in many cases.)

[flrrb]

Aside from the atrocity that is GH3... I had to vote for the GH series.

Without it, the would be no RB. And it is the same guys from the GOOD guitar hero games... they just wanted to go bigger. They didn't want to churn out GH games and not move forward.

Bless you HMX, bless you every one!

Thanks for not settling to sit back and rake in cash. You experimented and you win. Ask this question in 3 years, my anser will be the RB platform.