Best Song: Like a Rolling Stone vs. A Day in the Life

[Quinarvy]

Previous Winners:

Hallowed be Thy Name (beat War Pigs)
Machine Gun (beat Achilles Last Stand)
La Villa Strangiato (beat My Guitar Wants to Kill Your Mama)
Civil War (beat Runnin' With the Devil)
Lithium (beat My Iron Lung)

Future Installments:

Fade to Black vs. Holy Wars
Beat It vs. '39


Like A Rolling Stone (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hr_G3e0rgI)
A Day in the Life (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AiFYOn1AFms)

[Rockbandfan23467]

1st to vote for A Day In The Life!

[Quinarvy]

1st to vote for A Day In The Life!

First to Vote for Like A Rolling Stone!

[LegendofRock3021]

First to Vote for Like A Rolling Stone!

Second to vote for Like A Rolling Stone!

[Alright_Computer]

Oh man, this is a really tough one. Both of the songs are masterpieces, but in completely different rights. I'm gonna have to sit on this one.

[Cubecubed]

This is a pretty easy decision for me. "A Day in the Life" it is.

[BuRn7 CaK3]

This is a pretty easy decision for me. "A Day in the Life" it is.

'greed.

[instantdeath999]

I do think that Like a Rolling Stone is a more bonafide masterpiece, but I enjoy A Day in the Life more... which in the end, is all that matters ;)

[harveyglobetrot]

That's a tough one. I gave my vote to A Day In The Life, but that doesn't take away any of my love for Like A Rolling Stone.

[Quinarvy]

Second to vote for Like A Rolling Stone!

Let us start a club!

The internet needs a sarcasm meter.

[afterstasis]

yeah, it's pretty tight for me but i slightly prefer "like a rolling stone"... "a day in the life" is very far from one of my favorite beatles songs.

[a21schizoidman]

i voted for Like A Rolling Stone

[Soratar]

ehh... tough choice. I think I like Like A Rolling Stone more though.

[clashcityrocker10]

My vote goes to "Like A Rolling Stone."

[seriousbusson]

Fizzuck. Went with "A Day in the Life", but I love both.

[CommonCriminal]

A Day in the Life has never really been a favorite of mine for Beatles' tunes to be quite honest. LaRS gets my vote.

[classicrockdude]

Have to go with Dylan n this one

[TheCoolGuy]

Both far from my favorite songs from both artists... Beatles has a slight edge, though.

[n4sc4r]

A Day in the Life for me, though I prefer the instrumental version that Jeff Beck plays live.

[Bub]

A Day in the Life easily. I hate Bob Dylan.

[instantdeath999]

A Day in the Life easily. I hate Bob Dylan.

I think I've spun Freewheelin' Bob Dylan about 10 times in the past month :(

[gmarsh]

A day in the life.

[a21schizoidman]

A Day in the Life easily. I hate Bob Dylan.

how can anyone hate Bobby?

[gmarsh]

how can anyone hate Bobby?

It's because of the Jewish thing ;)

[californication]

Like a Rolling Stone

[MrFruitLord]

Life a Rolling Stone is my favorite Dylan tune, vs. an average Beatles song.

Like a Rolling Stone it is.

[Alright_Computer]

A Day in the Life had the potential to be an average Beatles song, but those crescendos... oh man. I still went with Dylan because he needs it more.

[ZosoBaron]

Like a Rolling Stone, easily.

[TheRollingBones]

I love Like A Rolling Stone, but to me A Day In The Life is just a better song in almost every way. It's an epic in 5 minutes!

[Rockbandfan23467]

A Day in the Life won.


Why is there so much time between rounds?

[Quinarvy]

A Day in the Life won.


Why is there so much time between rounds?

Because my life is Like a Rolling Stone, and A Day In the Life of Quin is fairly hectic this (school) year.

[nbalive2005]

I think I've spun Freewheelin' Bob Dylan about 10 times in the past month :(

Me too. When i go out jogging, i always listen to the album, makes me feel like in a different time and place