Would you pay for this setlist

[Adam Norris]

Someone posted a 58 song setlist on here as a "what if". I thought it was 80% dissapointing so I decided to make one myself it ended up being like 70+ songs long but tell me if you would buy this and how much you would be willing to shell out if the songs were not individually downloadable if you had to purchase the entire 70 song pack.

AC/DC - Hell's Bell's
Alice In Chains - Man In The Box
Angel's and Airwaves - Everything Is Magic
Atreyu - Falling Down
Avenged Sevenfold - Critical Acclaim
Billy Joel - We Didn't Start The Fire
Bloodhound Gang - Along Comes Mary
BobaFlex - Bullseye
Breaking Benjamin - Until The End
Chevelle - I Get It
Chiodos - The Words "Best Friend"
Citizen Cope - Bullet and A Target
Coheed and Cambria - In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth:3
Cold - Back Home
The Cure - Love Song
The Darkness - I Believe In A Thing Called Love
Deadlights - Foolish Pride
Def Leppard - Love Bites
Deftones - Root
DethKlok - Duncan Hills Coffee Jingle
Dope - Take Your Best Shot
Dragonforce - Revolution Deathsquad
The Drama - My Only Escape
Dream Theater - Strange Deja Vu
Dropkick Murphy's - Shipping Up To Boston
Dry Kill Logic - Paper Tiger
The Dykeenies - Waiting For Go
Earshot - Someone
Elton John - Rocket Man
Eric Clapton - Layla
Finger Eleven - Paralyzer
Five Finger Death Punch - The Bleeding
Fuel - Shimmer
Hurt - Rapture
Incubus - Pardon Me
Iron Maiden - The Trooper
Jimmi Hendrix - Fire
Jimmy Eat World - Sweetness
Johnny Cash - Folsom Prison
Kansas - Dust In The Wind
The Killers - All These Things That I've Done
Korn - Coming Undone
Led Zepplin - Stairway To Heaven
Live - Lakini's Juice
Lustra - Scotty Doesn't Know
Lynyrd Skynyrd - The Ballad Of Curtis Lowe
The Mars Volta - Aberinkula
Meat Loaf - Paradise By the Dashboard Light
Micheal Jackson - Smooth Criminal
Mindless Self Indulgence - Straight to Video
Mudvayne - Death Blooms
Muse - Supermassive Black Hole
My Chemical Romance - The Sharpest Lives
Nonpoint - In The Air Tonight
Offspring - Gone Away
Panic at The Disco - Nine In The Afternoon
Pink Floyd - Brain Damage
Queen - Fat Bottomed Girls
Rehab - Last Tattoo
Seether - Fake It
Shades Apart - Stranger By The Day
Sixx : A.m. - Life Is Beautiful
The Smashing Pumpkins - Bullets With Butterfly Wings
Stone Temple Pilots - Creep
Tenacious D - Tribute
Thrice - Digital Sea
Tom Petty and The Heartbreakers - Runnin' Down A Dream
Van Halen - Right Now
The White Stripes - Seven Nation Army
The Who - Love, Reign O'er Me
3 - Alien Angel
+44 - When Your Heart Stops Beating

[WingsOfSteel]

Kansas - Dust In The Wind

You're a ****ing idiot.

[a21schizoidman]

You're a ****ing idiot.

ROTFPMP OMG, i cant stop laughing at this, seriously

[WingsOfSteel]

Seriously, that song has not a single damn drum beat, would it kill people to listen to a song?

Maybe I should request Beethoven's Ninth Symphony! It would come as a huge shock to me if it turned out to have no guitar, too bad I can't be arsed to listen to it before deciding what a perfect Rock Band song it would be!

[Adam Norris]

Care to tell me why? I know that it wouldn't happen and 90% of the **** on here will not happen. These are all songs I would like to see on Rock Band. Why does this make me an idiot? Just wondering?

[Adam Norris]

You are correct I am an Idiot. I didn't even think about it for a second it probably doesn't help that I am a lil' tipsy right now. Lets cancel out the dust in the wind and say everything else!

[HeavyMetalKing]

Why cancel it out? So what if there's no drums. GG&HT hardly has any vocals...by the "there's no drums!" argument, GG&HT shouldn't have been included because there's not much for a vocalist to do. If HMX decides to add a few instrumental songs, the vocalist will have nothing to do. Why can't the drummer take a back seat for a song as well? Not being able to drum in one song isn't going to kill you, not to mention it would be DLC. If you're primarily a drummer, don't download it, but us guitarists and vocalists might enjoy it.

[a21schizoidman]

AC/DC - Hell's Bells (What's Next to the Moon)
Billy Joel - We Didn't Start The Fire (The Stranger)
The Cure - Love Song (Killing An Arab)
Def Leppard - Love Bites (Rock Rock Till You Drop)
Dream Theater - Strange Deja Vu
Elton John - Rocket Man (Crocodile Rock)
Eric Clapton - Layla (Bell Bottom Blues)
Incubus - Pardon Me
Iron Maiden - The Trooper (Aces High)
Jimi Hendrix - Fire (Manic Depression)
Johnny Cash - Folsom Prison
Kansas - Dust In The Wind (The Wall)
The Killers - All These Things That I've Done
Live - Lakini's Juice
Lynyrd Skynyrd - The Ballad Of Curtis Lowe (Saturday Night Special)
The Mars Volta - Aberinkula
Meat Loaf - Paradise By the Dashboard Light
Micheal Jackson - Smooth Criminal (Beat It)
Muse - Supermassive Black Hole
My Chemical Romance - The Sharpest Lives
Panic at The Disco - Nine In The Afternoon
Pink Floyd - Brain Damage (Echoes)
Queen - Fat Bottomed Girls
The Smashing Pumpkins - Bullet With Butterfly Wings (Hummer)
Stone Temple Pilots - Creep (Plush)
Tenacious D - Tribute
Tom Petty and The Heartbreakers - Runnin' Down A Dream (American Girl)
Van Halen - Right Now (Panama)
The Who - Love, Reign O'er Me (Acid Queen)

those (these songs are my suggestions)

[Nickzilla]

I would buy it, because variety is awesome, but I would purge the following tracks from my hard drive so I wouldn't have to deal with the truly poor decisions:

Angel's and Airwaves - Everything Is Magic
Bloodhound Gang - Along Comes Mary
BobaFlex - Bullseye
Citizen Cope - Bullet and A Target
DethKlok - Duncan Hills Coffee Jingle (good band, awful song choice)
Dragonforce - Revolution Deathsquad (good band, bad for rock band)
Dream Theater - Strange Deja Vu
Dropkick Murphy's - Shipping Up To Boston (good band, really awful song choice)
Lynyrd Skynyrd - The Ballad Of Curtis Lowe (ok song, I just hate bigots)
Panic at The Disco - Nine In The Afternoon (their lead singers voice annoys me, I'm sure it;s a fine song)

I'm sure there's more I would delete if I was familiar with all of those songs, but I'm not, so I won't.

My only advice would be next time you make a list, only put songs that you know well, by bands whose full range of material you're familiar.

[Rock_Starman]

I think you'd have to pay me especially not being able to pick singles.

[Chase.Mianless]

I only like about 4 of those songs. So no.

~Chase

[TakeABow]

I wouldn't pay much. You represent a few bands I want to see, and of the bands I think really need to get in, not really my favorites.

[David2380]

I'd buy about 30 of the 75

[TheKrazyKatzzz]

I'd get 8ish and would be dissappointed with more b-sides from popular artists (just like the past week's dlc...)

However:

The Smashing Pumpkins - Bullets With Butterfly Wings

Made this list win.

[WhiffleBallTony]

You get a cookie for getting Citizen Cope in there. "Son's Gonna Rise" would probably work better, though.

[xerichx07]

I'd buy a grand total of
... 0

EDIT: YES i've listened to all of them

[supersickie]

You've got HURT, but not enough. No Pearl Jam or Nine Inch Nails means no purchase from me.

[DethByAudio]

Alice In Chains - Man In The Box
Chevelle - I Get It - Much better songs by them
The Darkness - I Believe In A Thing Called Love
Deftones - Root - Much better songs by them
DethKlok - Duncan Hills Coffee Jingle
Dream Theater - Strange Deja Vu - Much better songs by them
Dry Kill Logic - Paper Tiger - Much better songs by them
Earshot - Someone - Much better songs by them
Five Finger Death Punch - The Bleeding - Much better songs by them, and over played on the radio
Fuel - Shimmer
Hurt - Rapture
Incubus - Pardon Me
Jimmi Hendrix - Fire
Korn - Coming Undone - out of all korn songs you picked this one?!?!?! Why!?!?!?!
Led Zepplin - Stairway To Heaven
Mindless Self Indulgence - Straight to Video - Much better songs by them
Mudvayne - Death Blooms
Muse - Supermassive Black Hole
Nonpoint - In The Air Tonight This would be a cover song
Pink Floyd - Brain Damage
Seether - Fake It
Sixx : A.m. - Life Is Beautiful
The Smashing Pumpkins - Bullets With Butterfly Wings
Stone Temple Pilots - Creep
Tenacious D - Tribute - no bass or drum part
The White Stripes - Seven Nation Army - Much better songs by them


7$ for these

[supersonic1414]

about 2/3 is pretty good

[TheCheckeredDemon]

The best song on this list was "Dope - Take Your Best Shot" and that's not the best song by that band... :\

[teh_roc]

I would only purchase 5 or 6 of those songs.

[WingsOfSteel]

Why cancel it out? So what if there's no drums. GG&HT hardly has any vocals...by the "there's no drums!" argument, GG&HT shouldn't have been included because there's not much for a vocalist to do. Why can't the drummer take a back seat for a song as well?

It's not the same thing, because:

a) The vocalist still has something to do during the song. (25 phrases, as opposed to absolutely nothing.) The drummer has nothing to do during Dust in the Wind.

b) Even during the parts where he's not singing, the vocalist has something to do (the tambourine parts). The drummer has no such thing.


If HMX decides to add a few instrumental songs, the vocalist will have nothing to do.

Golly, I wonder if that's the reason they haven't added any instrumental songs.