RockBand.com


View Full Version : Rate All the Rock Band Songs



Runa216
05-21-2008, 01:32 AM
Okay, I admit this makes me pathetic, but I had nothing better to do at 8 PM, since nobody would be taking Resumes, so I went on Wikipedia, Wrote down every available DLC song, then all the Bonus songs, then the main setlist, sorted them alphabetically, then gave them a grade.

You can grade them based on how fun they are to play, how difficult, how much you like the song, or however you like. I personally just did it by how much I liked the song overall. Sometimes I'd give a song a great rating becuase I LOVE to play it on Guitar (Working Man) or give it a low mark for just plain sucking (Sabotage)

I personally used an '/100' scale, but if anyone wishes to do the same, they may do it in grades (A, B-, C+...ect) stars, or our of 10.

Oh, and I did most of the work for you by writing them all down, all except the new european ones, becuase I've not picked them up yet (I'm on Playstation.)

So without further ado, here's my hugeass list....

(I bolded the main setlist and underlined the bonus songs...but apparently it doesn't like that.)

29 fingers - 43

3’s & 7’s - 70

Action - 65

All the small things - 62

And Justice for All - 88

Are you Gonna be my Girl - 71

Attack - 62

Ballroom Blitz - 60

Bang a Gong - 57

Beethoven’s **** - 70

Black Hole Sun - 61

Blackened - 90

Blinded by fear - 72

Blitzkrieg Bop - 40

Blood doll - 68

Bloodstone - 73

Brainpower - 74

Brass In Pocket - 71

Buddy Holly - 64

Call me - 67

Calling dr love - 58

Can’t let go - 62

Can’t Stand Losing You – 62

Casey Jones - 76

Celebrity Skin - 78

Cherry Bomb - 21

Cherub Rock - 88

China cat sunflower - 89

Complete control - 50

Creep - 42

Crushcrushcrush - 77

Dani California - 86

Date with the night - 48

Day late, dollar short - 56

Dead on Arrival - 35

Detroit Rock City - 52

Devil’s child - 80

Die all right - 69

Dirty little Secret - 83

DOA - 71

Don’t Fear the Reaper - 60

Don’t look back in anger - 67

El scorcho - 39

Electric Version - 48

Enter Sandman - 84

Epic - 67

Ever Fallen in Love - 45

Flirtin with Disaster - 90

Fever - 60

Foreplay/Long Time - 94

Fortunate Son – 86

Franklins tower - 81

Gimme Shelter - 74

Gimme three steps - 72

Go with the Flow - 70

Green Grass and High Tides - 88

Hand that Feeds - 70

Hanging on the telephone - 64

Hard to handle - 62

Here it goes again - 80

Heroes - 40

Highway Star - 87

Hitch a ride - 73

I fought the Law - 60

I get by- 50

I need a miracle - 70

I think I’m Paranoid - 72

I’m so sick - 64

In Bloom - 38

Interstate love song - 75

It hurts - 72

Joker and the Thief - 85

Juke Box Hero - 68

Kool Thing - 62

Last train to Clarksville - 83

Learn to Fly - 80

Limelight - 84

Little Sister - 70

Live forever - 62

Main Offender - 61

Maps - 78

March of the pigs - 58

Message in a bottle - 76

Mississippi Queen - 69

Moonage Daydream - 33

More than a Feeling - 75

Move Along - 81

My Iron Lung - 54

My Sharona - 83

Next to You - 80

NIB - 66

Nightmare - 72

Orange Crush - 77

Outside - 86

Pain and Pleasure - 77

Paranoid - 68

Peace of Mind - 72

Pleasure Pleasure - 89

Queen ***** - 41

Red tandy - 28

Reptillia - 80

Ride the Lightning - 87

Riding on the wind - 84

Roam - 82

Rock and roll band - 84

Rock rebellion - 88

Rockaway Beach - 49

Roxanne - 47

Run to the Hills - 85

Sabotage - 19

Saints of los angeles - 80

Say it Aint So - 67

Screaming for Vengeance - 88

Seven - 74

Sex type thing - 73

Shake - 36

Shockwave - 83

Should I Stay or Should I go - 65

Sick Sick Sick - 65

Simple man - 63

Siva - 72

Smokin - 83

Something about you - 76

Song with a mission - 84

Sprode - 77

Still alive - 80

Suffragate City - 55

Sugar magnolia - 71

Sweet Leaf - 60

Synchonicity II - 79

Take these chains - 75

Teenage lobotomy - 40

Ten speed of god’s blood & burial - 86

The collector - 67

The hellion/electric eye - 81

The Kill - 73

The number of the beast - 87

The perfect drug - 84

This aint a scene, it’s an arms race - 58

Thrasher - 70

Time sick son of a grizzly bear - 32

Time we had - 70

Timmy and the lords of the underworld - 68

Tom Sawyer - 82

Train in vain - 73

Train Kept A Rollin - 88

Truckin - 76

Truth hits everybody - 70

Vasoline - 71

Wanted Dear or Alive - 78

War Pigs - 75

Wave of Mutilation - 60

We care a lot - 55

Welcome Home - 83

When you were Young - 77

Why do you love me - 71

Won’t get Fooled again - 78

Wonderwall - 70

Working man - 90

You’ve got another thing coming - 72

Zero - 75

Runa216
05-21-2008, 03:33 AM
too much work?

toMsons1987
05-21-2008, 03:39 AM
To make it short, 1/5th of the songs blow. Either bad songs or annoying to play - AKA Strum Fest 2K8!

trg007
05-21-2008, 04:05 AM
Still alive - 80

You're kidding with this one, right?

hankchill
05-21-2008, 07:46 AM
Way to go, you rated most of the good songs crappy, and most of the crappy songs good. Just goes to show people's taste can be a$$-backwards from your own :P

Runa216
05-21-2008, 10:46 AM
You're kidding with this one, right?


nope, the song is not difficult, but it's fun to play

Runa216
05-21-2008, 10:48 AM
Way to go, you rated most of the good songs crappy, and most of the crappy songs good. Just goes to show people's taste can be a$$-backwards from your own :P

what good songs did I rate crappy? angry becuase I didn't like "in bloom"?

on the contrast, what bad songs did I rate high?

MooTrain
05-21-2008, 11:11 AM
I've always felt x/100 rating scales are stupid. It's not a test, it's a review. As far as individual songs go, I'm rating it out of five. Zero = Hatred, One = Dislike, 2 = Average, 3 = Decent, 4 = Good, 5 = Great (and I want more like it), X = I haven't got the DLC / no opinion.


29 fingers - 0
3’s & 7’s - 2
Action - 3
All the small things - 1
And Justice for All - 4
Are you Gonna be my Girl - 2
Attack - 2
Ballroom Blitz - 0
Bang a Gong - 1
Beethoven’s **** - 2
Black Hole Sun - 2
Blackened - 4
Blinded by fear - XX
Blitzkrieg Bop - 1
Blood doll - 1
Bloodstone - 2
Brainpower - 3
Brass In Pocket - 4
Buddy Holly - 3
Call me - 3
Calling dr love - 1
Can’t let go - 0
Can’t Stand Losing You – 4
Casey Jones - 4
Celebrity Skin - 3
Cherry Bomb - 3
Cherub Rock - 4
China cat sunflower - 4
Complete control - 2
Creep - 5
Crushcrushcrush - 4
Dani California - 3
Date with the night - 5 (Love this song)
Day late, dollar short - 2
Dead on Arrival - 0
Detroit Rock City - 1
Devil’s child - 2
Die all right - 2
Dirty little Secret - 3
DOA - XX
Don’t Fear the Reaper - 4
Don’t look back in anger - 4
El scorcho - 1
Electric Version - 2
Enter Sandman - 4
Epic - 2
Ever Fallen in Love - 4
Flirtin with Disaster - 4
Fever - 2
Foreplay/Long Time - 5
Fortunate Son – 4
Franklins tower - 4
Gimme Shelter - 4
Gimme three steps - 3
Go with the Flow - 3
Green Grass and High Tides - 4
Hand that Feeds - 4
Hanging on the telephone - 3
Hard to handle - 3
Here it goes again - 5 (Love Ok Go)
Heroes - 4 (I could do without the last two minutes that just seem to go on forever, but otherwise love this song)
Highway Star - 5
Hitch a ride - 4
I fought the Law - 2
I get by - 2
I need a miracle - 3
I think I’m Paranoid - 3
I’m so sick - 5
In Bloom - 3
Interstate love song - 4
It hurts - 1
Joker and the Thief - 4
Juke Box Hero - 4
Kool Thing - 2
Last train to Clarksville - 3
Learn to Fly - 4
Limelight - 5
Little Sister - 3
Live forever - 4
Main Offender - 3
Maps - 4
March of the pigs - 1
Message in a bottle - 4
Mississippi Queen - 1
Moonage Daydream - 4
More than a Feeling - 5
Move Along - 4
My Iron Lung - 5
My Sharona - 2
Next to You - 3
NIB - 3
Nightmare - 4
Orange Crush - 5
Outside - 5
Pain and Pleasure - 2
Paranoid - 3
Peace of Mind - 4
Pleasure Pleasure - 4
Queen ***** - 3
Red tandy - X
Reptillia - 5
Ride the Lightning - 5
Riding on the wind - 4
Roam - 5
Rock and roll band - 4
Rock rebellion - 3
Rockaway Beach - 3
Roxanne - 1
Run to the Hills - 4
Sabotage - 2
Saints of los angeles - 4
Say it Aint So - 1
Screaming for Vengeance - 3
Seven - 3
Sex type thing - 5
Shake - 1
Shockwave - 4
Should I Stay or Should I go - 2
Sick Sick Sick - 2
Simple man - 3
Siva - 2
Smokin - 4
Something about you - X (I Can't even remember this song...)
Song with a mission - 5
Sprode - 4
Still alive - 4 (I like it, what can I say?)
Suffragate City - 2
Sugar magnolia - 4
Sweet Leaf - 3
Synchonicity II - 5
Take these chains - 2
Teenage lobotomy - 1
Ten speed of god’s blood & burial - 5
The collector - 2
The hellion/electric eye - 4
The Kill - 3
The number of the beast - 1 (Not a fan. *shrug*)
The perfect drug - 3
This aint a scene, it’s an arms race - 2 (It's better than Dead on Arrival, but it's not great)
Thrasher - X
Time sick son of a grizzly bear - X
Time we had - 3
Timmy and the lords of the underworld - 0
Tom Sawyer - 5
Train in vain - 5
Train Kept A Rollin - 2
Truckin - 3
Truth hits everybody - 1
Vasoline - 4
Wanted Dear or Alive - 2
War Pigs - 2
Wave of Mutilation - 2
We care a lot - 0 (It's fun the first couple of times. Then everyone hates it)
Welcome Home - 5
When you were Young - 5
Why do you love me - 4
Won’t get Fooled again - 5
Wonderwall - 4
Working man - 3
You’ve got another thing coming - 3
Zero - 3

As for the songs I grabbed last night:

Blur - Beetlebum - 4
Muse - Hysteria - 4
Oasis - Rock and Roll Star - 4
Tokio Hotel - Through the Monsoon - 3

Again, all of these are just my opinion and are based on 1. Like of Song, 2. Like of Chart, 3. Fun at Parties. You mileage may of course vary.

Runa216
05-21-2008, 11:53 AM
Cool, most people hate Still Alive, and only a few seem to like the Grateful Dead, in spite of how much fun they are to play.

o1skinneej
05-21-2008, 12:01 PM
too much work?

Yes. Not to mention, these are completely subjective ratings. Nobody has the SAME taste in music. For example: You gave Crushcrushcrush a 77 (i think) and Complete Control a 50, or something. To me that is just crazy.

JMcQ77
05-21-2008, 12:12 PM
29 fingers - 3
3’s & 7’s - 5
Action - 1
All the small things - X
And Justice for All - 4
Are you Gonna be my Girl - 4
Attack - X
Ballroom Blitz - 3
Bang a Gong - X
Beethoven’s **** - X
Black Hole Sun - 4
Blackened - 4
Blinded by fear - XX
Blitzkrieg Bop - 2
Blood doll - X
Bloodstone - X
Brainpower - 4
Brass In Pocket - X
Buddy Holly - 3
Call me - 4
Calling dr love - X
Can’t let go - 3
Can’t Stand Losing You – 4
Casey Jones - 4
Celebrity Skin - 4
Cherry Bomb - X
Cherub Rock - 5
China cat sunflower - X
Complete control - X
Creep - 5
Crushcrushcrush - X
Dani California - 5
Date with the night - X
Day late, dollar short - 3
Dead on Arrival - 2
Detroit Rock City - 3
Devil’s child - X
Die all right - X
Dirty little Secret - X
DOA - XX
Don’t Fear the Reaper - 4
Don’t look back in anger - X
El scorcho - X
Electric Version - 2
Enter Sandman - 4
Epic - 4
Ever Fallen in Love - X
Flirtin with Disaster - 2
Fever - X
Foreplay/Long Time - 3
Fortunate Son – X
Franklin's tower - 4
Gimme Shelter - 5
Gimme three steps - X
Go with the Flow - 4
Green Grass and High Tides - 2
Hand that Feeds - 5
Hanging on the telephone - X
Hard to handle - 3
Here it goes again - 1
Heroes - 4
Highway Star - 3
Hitch a ride - X
I fought the Law - X
I get by - 3
I need a miracle - X
I think I’m Paranoid - 5
I’m so sick - 5
In Bloom - 4
Interstate love song - 5
It hurts - X
Joker and the Thief - 5
Juke Box Hero - 4
Kool Thing - X
Last train to Clarksville - X
Learn to Fly - 5
Limelight - 5
Little Sister - 5
Live forever - X
Main Offender - 3
Maps - 4
March of the pigs - 4
Message in a bottle - 5
Mississippi Queen - 1
Moonage Daydream - X
More than a Feeling - 4
Move Along - 3
My Iron Lung - 5
My Sharona - X
Next to You - 4
NIB - 3
Nightmare - 2
Orange Crush - 4
Outside - 5
Pain and Pleasure - X
Paranoid - 3
Peace of Mind - X
Pleasure Pleasure - X
Queen ***** - X
Red tandy - X
Reptillia - 3
Ride the Lightning - 5
Riding on the wind - X
Roam - X
Rock and roll band - X
Rock rebellion - X
Rockaway Beach - X
Roxanne - 5
Run to the Hills - 4
Sabotage - 4
Saints of los angeles - 4
Say it Aint So - 4
Screaming for Vengeance - X
Seven - X
Sex type thing - 4
Shake - X
Shockwave - 4
Should I Stay or Should I go - 4
Sick Sick Sick - 4
Simple man - 3
Siva - 5
Smokin - X
Something about you - X
Song with a mission - X
Sprode - X
Still alive - X
Suffragate City - 4
Sugar magnolia - 4
Sweet Leaf - 3
Synchonicity II - 5
Take these chains - X
Teenage lobotomy - X
Ten speed of god’s blood & burial - X
The collector - 5
The hellion/electric eye - X
The Kill - 4
The number of the beast - 4
The perfect drug - 4
This aint a scene, it’s an arms race - X
Thrasher - X
Time sick son of a grizzly bear - X
Time we had - 3
Timmy and the lords of the underworld - 2
Tom Sawyer - 5
Train in vain - X
Train Kept A Rollin - 2
Truckin - 3
Truth hits everybody - 4
Vasoline - X
Wanted Dear or Alive - 4
War Pigs - 3
Wave of Mutilation - 4
We care a lot - X
Welcome Home - 3
When you were Young - 4
Why do you love me - 4
Won’t get Fooled again - 5
Wonderwall - X
Working man - 5
You’ve got another thing coming - X
Zero - X

Runa216
05-21-2008, 12:15 PM
Yes. Not to mention, these are completely subjective ratings. Nobody has the SAME taste in music. For example: You gave Crushcrushcrush a 77 (i think) and Complete Control a 50, or something. To me that is just crazy.


well, the whole point was that it was subjective, I even said in the first post "you can rate them according to whatever you like, quality, difficulty, playtimes, ect."