Battle of the Bands: Led Zeppelin vs. Pink Floyd

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

LED ZEPPELIN

Led Zeppelin were an English rock band that formed in August 1968. Led Zeppelin consisted of Jimmy Page (guitar and Theramin), Robert Plant (vocals, harmonica and occasionally tambourine), John Paul Jones (bass guitar, keyboards) and John Bonham (drums, percussion). With their heavy, guitar-driven sound, Led Zeppelin are regarded as one of the first heavy metal bands.[1][2] However, the band's individualistic style draws from many sources and transcends any one genre.[3] Their rock-infused interpretation of the blues and folk genres[4] also incorporated rockabilly,[5] reggae,[6] soul,[7] funk,[8] classical, Celtic, Indian, Arabic, pop, Latin and country. The band did not release the popular songs from their albums as singles in the UK, as they preferred to develop the concept of album-oriented rock.[9]

Close to 30 years after disbanding following Bonham's death in 1980, Led Zeppelin continue to be held in high regard for their artistic achievements, commercial success and broad influence. The band have sold more than 300 million albums worldwide,[10][11][12][13][14] including 111.5 million sales in the United States[15] and they have had all their non-compilation studio albums reach the U.S. Billboard Top 10.[16] Led Zeppelin are ranked No. 1 on VH1's 100 Greatest Artists of Hard Rock.[17] Rolling Stone magazine has described Led Zeppelin as "the heaviest band of all time" and "the biggest band of the 70s".[18]


PINK FLOYD

Pink Floyd are an English progressive rock band that initially earned recognition for their psychedelic or space rock music, and, as they evolved, for their progressive rock music. They are known for philosophical lyrics, sonic experimentation, innovative cover art, and elaborate live shows. One of rock music's most successful acts, the group have sold over 200 million albums worldwide[6][7] including 74.5 million albums in the United States alone.[8]

Pink Floyd had moderate mainstream success and were one of the most popular bands in the London underground music scene in the late 1960s as a psychedelic band led by Syd Barrett; however, Barrett's erratic behaviour eventually forced his colleagues to replace him with guitarist and singer David Gilmour. After Barrett's departure, singer and bass player Roger Waters gradually became the dominant and driving force in the mid-1970s, until his eventual departure from the group in 1985. The band recorded several albums, achieving worldwide success with The Dark Side of the Moon (1973), Wish You Were Here (1975), Animals (1977), and The Wall (1979). In 1985, Waters declared Pink Floyd "a spent force", but the remaining members, led by Gilmour, continued recording and touring under the name Pink Floyd. Although they were unsuccessfully sued by Waters for rights to the name, they again enjoyed worldwide success with A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987) and The Division Bell (1994). Eventually they reached a settlement out of court with Waters allowing them use of the name.

Videos:
"The Ocean" - Led Zeppelin
<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/XaMzgA2V7Gk&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/XaMzgA2V7Gk&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>
"Over the Hills and Far Away" - Led Zeppelin
<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/_swFHp-0_sY&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/_swFHp-0_sY&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

"Time" - Pink Floyd
<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/ntm1YfehK7U&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/ntm1YfehK7U&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>
"Hey You" - Pink Floyd
<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/lRcQZ2tnWeg&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/lRcQZ2tnWeg&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>


Vote now!

[frizzy_bj]

Aw man... I am going to have to think about this one...:(

[Tender-Surrender]

I voted Pink Floyd. Both are great bands, but the fact that Led Zeppelin ripped off a ton of other bands work in their early days and gave no credit makes me go with Pink Floyd. 2 of the greatest bands ever, though!

[Mimglow]

I voted Led Zep. Hands down. I never really got into Pink Floyd, although I do like a lot of their stuff.

[Rockbandfan23467]

This match is both perfect and a mismatch. Both are different, but many like both.

Floyd for Sympathy.

If Zeppelin win, they better not go againt the The Beatles next round! The final battle must be you know what.

[lawrence1103]

I love both of these bands, i gotta go with Led Zeppelin

[TheCrimsonSaint]

Mmmm. Once again we find ourselves with two very overrated bands. I'll say Pink Floyd, because they revolutionized what a rock concert should be. They were possibly the best live band ever. And I don't even like them that much. Compare that to Zep, who couldn't do much of anything live because Plant was barely coherent more than half of the time. While it's true that JPJ and Bonham make up one of the best rhythm sections in history, that just isn't enough for me. A band needs a vocalist that can cut it live, and for the most part Robert Plant just didn't cut it.

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

I voted for Pink Floyd. Zep are great but they have a small library that gets old after a while.

[Sayburr]

Very hard choice... The styles are so different its hard to compare. I have to choose Zep, their blues based rock just makes me happy.

[idiotec]

Man, this one is surprising me. Zeppelin is great, but come on, Pink Floyd hands down!

[The_Little_Buster]

I vote for Floyd, your life isn't complete unless you've listened to The Dark Side of The Moon all the way through in one sitting.

[next jimmy page]

well who do u think im voting for? led zeppelin hands down. in my opinion, zep is the best band ever. no wait ,2nd bhind the beatles. total mismatch, zep all the way:p

[m00p]

Hey guyz! I'm back.. :D


Well yeah, kinda. I'm grounded =[. But i guess since it is 11-11 i'll have to break the tie. While led zeppelin is major pwnage, the majority of their songs get old after a while. Playing the same thing, over and over and over again gets BORING. Pink Floyd has a wide variety of songs I like, and i enjoy Gilmour's voice more then Plants.


Pink Floyd!

[JBDazzle]

:mad: First niether of these bands where overrated.....lets just get that out of the way. Now as to who should win. Its close but I got to go with Zepplin. Pink floyd had the acid rock down and there shows where the best but led zepplin where influential and rocked out. They where a rare bread that we didn't last as long as some of us wanted but they still rock....its close but Zepplin wins for enspiring some of rocks future stars..:eek:

[Rockbandfan23467]

A tie!

Next Round Prediction:
Led Zeppelin vs. Pink Floyd vs. Iron Maiden
Rush vs. The Beatles

[m00p]

Rush vs. The Beatles?


That should be one hell of a fight :rolleyes:

[Alright_Computer]

Pink Floyd for me.

Ooh, it's tied? This one should be good. *gets popcorn*

[KingofQUEEN92]

I love Led Zeppelin. I hate Pink Floyd.

[DSOTM]

op you are a gigantic douche
frowny face

Playing the same thing, over and over and over again gets BORING.
im guessing youve only heard a greatest hits album, because albums like Led Zeppelin II and Led Zeppelin IV are full of diversity
honestly, i love led zeppelin and floyd, but pink floyd just appeals to me more
also i dont care who wins
theyre both two absolutely amazing bands that revolutionized rock and were both amazing live

[m00p]

op you are a gigantic douche
frowny face

im guessing youve only heard a greatest hits album, because albums like Led Zeppelin II and Led Zeppelin IV are full of diversity
honestly, i love led zeppelin and floyd, but pink floyd just appeals to me more
also i dont care who wins
theyre both two absolutely amazing bands that revolutionized rock and were both amazing live

Actually, i have all the zeppelin songs on my iPod. I've listened to em all. And the songs I used to enjoy the most, are all boring and repetitive..

Stairway to Heaven?
Immigrant Song?
Heartbreaker?


B O R I N G

And who are you calling a douche? Me or Julio??

[TheCrimsonSaint]

Actually, i have all the zeppelin songs on my iPod. I've listened to em all. And the songs I used to enjoy the most, are all boring and repetitive..

Stairway to Heaven?
Immigrant Song?
Heartbreaker?


B O R I N G

And who are you calling a douche? Me or Julio??

This man is correct.

[Insane3]

I voted Pink Floyd. Both are great bands, but the fact that Led Zeppelin ripped off a ton of other bands work in their early days and gave no credit makes me go with Pink Floyd. 2 of the greatest bands ever, though!

EXACTLY what I believe.

[DSOTM]

Actually, i have all the zeppelin songs on my iPod. I've listened to em all. And the songs I used to enjoy the most, are all boring and repetitive..

Stairway to Heaven?
Immigrant Song?
Heartbreaker?


B O R I N G

i would like to say that pink floyds music is way more dragged out and "repetitive" than any of those songs
and while its a statement that led zeppelin plays the first thing over and over again, youre using your opinion and personal preference to back up a forced fact

And who are you calling a douche? Me or Julio??

its a joke goddamn
its really hard to choose between two of my most favorite bands

[Insane3]

Mmmm. Once again we find ourselves with two very overrated bands. I'll say Pink Floyd, because they revolutionized what a rock concert should be. They were possibly the best live band ever. And I don't even like them that much. Compare that to Zep, who couldn't do much of anything live because Plant was barely coherent more than half of the time. While it's true that JPJ and Bonham make up one of the best rhythm sections in history, that just isn't enough for me. A band needs a vocalist that can cut it live, and for the most part Robert Plant just didn't cut it.

Please be more precise about the word overrated. For exemple, I do believe that certain people love the song Money only because everyone likes it. Others only like Another Brick in The Wall (pt 2) only because it sais "We don't need no education". But this is my all time fav band. I'm not telling you it's the best band ever but I can tell you I'm not overrating them. If you felt what I feel when I listen to Atom Earth Mother, you wouldn't call it overrating. It's just people don't feel the same about the same songs. I don't like AC/DC, I'm convinced it's boring and it always sounds the same, but if you like their sound, well you don't mind it repeats. I don't like the whole overrated wave of threads out there and the trend to use that word everywhere. Few bands or people are overrated, many don't touch everyone. I think Celine Dion is overrated only because I hate her voice, but maybe she's not, I can't say, I don't understand why people like her so I don't have to drag her down with all the pop music. Anyway. I've done that kind of thing a couple of time and I'll do it again, but I still know I'm often wrong when I judge a person's talent.

[frizzy_bj]

After thinking this over a bit, I have decided on Pink Floyd...:cool:

[m00p]

i would like to say that pink floyds music is way more dragged out and "repetitive" than any of those songs
and while its a statement that led zeppelin plays the first thing over and over again, youre using your opinion and personal preference to back up a forced fact


its a joke goddamn
its really hard to choose between two of my most favorite bands

Definitley not just my opinion. I know countless others that think some of zeppelin's songs are repetitive and stupid. The thing that bothers me is their are about 4/5 zeppelin songs that sound completely alike. While when you buy a pink floyd album, you actually get your money's worth.

[AxlVanHagar]

I went back and forth a bit before voting. Not a huge fan of either. I like some stuff from both but find the majority of either a bit much. Ultimately I cast my vote for the thieves. Page was one of my first influences in playing guitar and genreally speaking I like a bit more of Zep than Floyd.

[TakeABow]

Pink Floyd wins in my book.

[Insane3]

A tie!

Next Round Prediction:
Led Zeppelin vs. Pink Floyd vs. Iron Maiden
Rush vs. The Beatles

Rush VS Bealtes? This would be quite weird. You can't compare those bands. I know for who I would vote (Beatles) but I don't know wich of these 2 is the best band (not only talking about instrumental talent)....

[DSOTM]

Definitley not just my opinion. I know countless others that think some of zeppelin's songs are repetitive and stupid. The thing that bothers me is their are about 4/5 zeppelin songs that sound completely alike. While when you buy a pink floyd album, you actually get your money's worth.

tons of people think pink floyd is boring
therefore, pink floyd is boring
also i wouldnt go so far as to say that 4/5 led zep songs sound the same
id say that at least half of their songs follow their "hard rock" style

[m00p]

tons of people think pink floyd is boring
therefore, pink floyd is boring
also i wouldnt go so far as to say that 4/5 led zep songs sound the same
id say that at least half of their songs follow their "hard rock" style

Well if your into your songs sounding the same and that "hard rock" style, then fine, whatever. Zeppelin was a huge influence because of Page and Bonham.


You should obviously change your name if you hate the band THAT much.

[Insane3]

i would like to say that pink floyds music is way more dragged out and "repetitive" than any of those songs
and while its a statement that led zeppelin plays the first thing over and over again, youre using your opinion and personal preference to back up a forced fact


its a joke goddamn
its really hard to choose between two of my most favorite bands

Pink Floyd more repititive?! Ok, that's funny. Seriously, listen to their whole musicography. I'm not saying Led Zeppelin is repetitive, just saying that Pink Floyd has got threw blues, "pop", acid, "techno", hard rock, orchestral ...and all in the same song lol.

[OldFogey]

Just not big into Floyd. Tried. Nice solos from Gilmour. But did anyone actually show them a metronome? And that it has three digit numbers? :D

Voted for Zepp

[DSOTM]

You should obviously change your name if you hate the band THAT much.

because if i like one band, then i have to hate all other bands
i dont care if pink floyd is repetitive, because i actually enjoy the things that they repeat. just because im trying to defend led zeppelin doesnt mean that i hate pink floyd, douche bag. pink floyd is my favorite band. ive heard and enjoyed more songs by pink floyd than any other band ive ever heard

Pink Floyd more repititive?! Ok, that's funny. Seriously, listen to their whole musicography. I'm not saying Led Zeppelin is repetitive, just saying that Pink Floyd has got threw blues, "pop", acid, "techno", hard rock, orchestral ...and all in the same song lol.

im not talking about their whole discography
im talking about during the songs, such as the intro to time

[m00p]

because if i like one band, then i have to hate all other bands
i dont care if pink floyd is repetitive, because i actually enjoy the things that they repeat. just because im trying to defend led zeppelin doesnt mean that i hate pink floyd, douche bag. pink floyd is my favorite band. ive heard and enjoyed more songs by pink floyd than any other band ive ever heard


im not talking about their whole discography
im talking about during the songs, such as the intro to time


ummm.. you said pink floyd was boring??

The intro to time is just a sh1tload of clocks ticking. How is that "repetitive?"

[Insane3]

tons of people think pink floyd is boring
therefore, pink floyd is boring
also i wouldnt go so far as to say that 4/5 led zep songs sound the same
id say that at least half of their songs follow their "hard rock" style

Yeah, some people believe that Pink Floyd is boring. Some people believe that we should kill all black people, jews, gays, ect. Are they right? Sure. Tons of people think rap owns everything. Does it? Probably, because many people think so. I believe I can stop time? Is it true? Of course, because I believe I can.

[DSOTM]

ummm.. you said pink floyd was boring??

The intro to time is just a sh1tload of clocks ticking. How is that "repetitive?"

i never said pink floyd was boring
i was being sarcastic, using your own logic to justify the statement that pink floyd is boring. i never said i agreed with it, i was just saying that to make a point.
also im not talking about the clocks. the part after that.

Yeah, some people believe that Pink Floyd is boring. Some people believe that we should kill all black people, jews, gays, ect. Are they right? Sure. Tons of people think rap owns everything. Does it? Probably, because many people think so. I believe I can stop time? Is it true? Of course, because I believe I can.

hey dumb****, im being sarcastic. see above.
edit: i am so getting banned again
see you guys in three days

[Insane3]

im not talking about their whole discography
im talking about during the songs, such as the intro to time

Yeah intro is long. I wouldn't say repetitive but I agree most of them are long.

[m00p]

Yeah, you are. I just reported all your posts you've made today for your language and flaming. Hopefully you can get your attitude straight when you come back.

[Insane3]

LOL! Ok. I didn't know you were sarcastic, that must be because i'm stupid. Not because I have to use a french/english dictionary to understand what people say in this forum and to write (slowly) every of my post.

[DSOTM]

Yeah intro is long. I wouldn't say repetitive but I agree most of them are long.

yeah, this is what i mean by "pink floyd gets repetitive". they sort of drag out their intros, it takes them a long time to get to the really good parts

[Rockbandfan23467]

I regret voting for Floyd, as they are winning.


Go Zepp! Or Tie and Face Floyd and Maiden at the same time!

[m00p]

Just cause a song doesn't have solo's lasting 7 minutes long from beginning to end doesn't mean its repetitive. At least try and act like you know what your talking about....

[DSOTM]

I regret voting for Floyd, as they are winning.


Go Zepp! Or Tie and Face Floyd and Maiden at the same time!

nonconformist is nonconforming

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

tons of people think pink floyd is boring
therefore, pink floyd is boring
also i wouldnt go so far as to say that 4/5 led zep songs sound the same
id say that at least half of their songs follow their "hard rock" style
Zep have about as much musical variety as Floyd, but when you're a diehard Zep fan you start to think you've heard it all; and when the only radio station you listen to plays Stairway and Black Dog every other song it starts to drive you crazy.

Zep are really good, but Floyd are good and a breath of fresh air, so to speak.

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

Yeah, you are. I just reported all your posts you've made today for your language and flaming. Hopefully you can get your attitude straight when you come back.

lol wtf

Yeah debates get heated but don't just report someone when you're losing. :|

[JukeBoxHero]

I vote Pink Floyd this time around. Led Zeppelin is great as a studio band to me but the live vocals performances brings it down a notch for me. :) Also, considering progressive rock is my favorite genre and I like Pink Floyd's clean instrumentals.

[TheCrimsonSaint]

lol wtf

Yeah debates get heated but don't just report someone when you're losing. :|

PWNED.0989756

[Samuel346]

I picked Led Zeppelin.

Pink Floyd has some good songs, but not that many.

[Shredder87]

My good chums.

My decision.

Testicles....that is all....

I went with Floyd. Great music, great musicians, great albums. I mean how long was Dark Side on the charts for?! That must mean something!!!
As for Zeppelin, they're good, but Floyd as just a bit more zazz.

[Rockbandfan23467]

I guess Queen and Jimi fans are the voters.

[Samuel346]

My good chums.

My decision.

Testicles....that is all....

I went with Floyd. Great music, great musicians, great albums. I mean how long was Dark Side on the charts for?! That must mean something!!!
As for Zeppelin, they're good, but Floyd as just a bit more zazz.

You decide on testicles?

Not vagina?

:eek:

[BhindBluEyes430]

I voted Pink Floyd. I just like their music better

on a side note "Dark side of the moon" and "Led zeppelin II" are in my top 10 Greatest albums of all time

"The Wall" And "Led Zeppelin IV and III" are overrated IMO

so Im kinda split. I Like Floyd's stuff just because its a lot smoother sound. And their lyrics kill led zeps. Although led Zeppelin have a more energetic sound sometimes

[a21schizoidman]

Pink Floyd - prog/psychadelic to blues-space rock band, almost underrated to what they did for music

Led Zeppelin - overrated band with 2 very overrated musicians, and one underrated singer


I vote Floyd

[a21schizoidman]

"The Wall" And "Led Zeppelin IV and III" are overrated IMO



thank you, I agree

[Shredder87]

You decide on testicles?

Not vagina?

:eek:
Well, it was a Family Guy reference.

If you want me to make it up, I was drunk last thursday, and I was talking about eating Poon so passionately(I mean WITH A PASSION!!! I can't mention what I said. There are kids out and about in these forums.) I apparenlty inspired my cousins BF to "attempt" with her. He apparenlty failed miserably.(Yes, she told me that like I wanted to know, but it's nice to know my skills apparenlty inspire others, hahaha)

[Hamsterhitman]

I voted Pink Floyd. I just like their music better

on a side note "Dark side of the moon" and "Led zeppelin II" are in my top 10 Greatest albums of all time

"The Wall" And "Led Zeppelin IV and III" are overrated IMO

so Im kinda split. I Like Floyd's stuff just because its a lot smoother sound. And their lyrics kill led zeps. Although led Zeppelin have a more energetic sound sometimes

Led Zep III is overrated? Isn't that one like, cited as one of their worst albums? I mean yeah, it has Immigrant Song, but apart from that...

[Samuel346]

Well, it was a Family Guy reference.

If you want me to make it up, I was drunk last thursday, and I was talking about eating Poon so passionately(I mean WITH A PASSION!!! I can't mention what I said. There are kids out and about in these forums.) I apparenlty inspired my cousins BF to "attempt" with her. He apparenlty failed miserably.(Yes, she told me that like I wanted to know, but it's nice to know my skills apparenlty inspire others, hahaha)

I don't know if you can make up for voting testicles, even if it is a family guy reference. :p

[BhindBluEyes430]

Led Zep III is overrated? Isn't that one like, cited as one of their worst albums? I mean yeah, it has Immigrant Song, but apart from that...

Well i always see good reviews off it and The artwork is pretty popular.

but mostly it was just to even out the number of songs to the walls 2 disks


The Wall, is very overrated it was no way near as good as Dark side or Wish you where hear. It get too much praise especially for that movie which just confused me. I dident find anything special about it. It was alot less musically innovative than their earlier works and The lyrics had a very negative, cynical view with almost no change. Was every song in minor?

Led Zeppelin IV only had two good songs "Black Dog" one of their ORIGINAL Blues-Rock songs. and "when The Levee breaks" Because it had a kick ass beat and sick slide guitar and harmonica. Stairway is the most overrated song of all time. And rock and roll was overrated because the Drum intro its pretty much know for was a direct copy of a song called "Something Else" by Eddie Cochran. I listend to it its the exact same thing.

[DSOTM]

Just cause a song doesn't have solo's lasting 7 minutes long from beginning to end doesn't mean its repetitive. At least try and act like you know what your talking about....

because i totally said a song has to have a long solo to not be repetitive


Yeah, you are. I just reported all your posts you've made today for your language and flaming. Hopefully you can get your attitude straight when you come back.

lol


LOL! Ok. I didn't know you were sarcastic, that must be because i'm stupid. Not because I have to use a french/english dictionary to understand what people say in this forum and to write (slowly) every of my post.

im sorry but if youre speaking english i automatically assume that english is your first language
but can you really blame me :/
edit: id also like to say sorry again, i mean i have to use a filipino to english dictionary to read and write everything on here LOL!

[idiotec]

"The Wall" And "Led Zeppelin IV and III" are overrated IMO
You can have Zep III. However, saying the Wall is overrated? Are you a Mormon? Take a little mind change and try it again. One of the most epic albums of all time.

Led Zeppelin IV is a fantastic album. Tough for it to be "overrated."

[Shredder87]

You can have Zep III. However, saying the Wall is overrated? Are you a Mormon? Take a little mind change and try it again. One of the most epic albums of all time.

Led Zeppelin IV is a fantastic album. Tough for it to be "overrated."
I dunno man. I think I'm going to back Blu with this one and say that The Wall is a tad "overrated". It definately doesn't stand a chance next to Floyds other albums.

[Quinarvy]

Led Zeppelin is one of my favorite bands, and songs like Achilles Last Stand are just amazing. LZ gets my vote.

[frostywolf]

Very tough call for me. I'm not too big on either band but I like them both and I like them about equally. I'm thinking I'm going to vote Pink Floyd on the basis of how much I like "Shine On You Crazy Diamond".

[a21schizoidman]

You can have Zep III. However, saying the Wall is overrated? Are you a Mormon? Take a little mind change and try it again. One of the most epic albums of all time.

Led Zeppelin IV is a fantastic album. Tough for it to be "overrated."

the Wall is good, but not as good as everyone claims it to be, the movie is good, but it is prolly the reason (and ABITW Pt2) its so popular

DSOTM is tied for their best album with Meddle
WYWH and Animals tied for 3
PATGOD is amazing too, but most ppl hate Barrett for no apparent reason
and MLOR and Division Bell are better than ppl make them out to be

[idiotec]

the Wall is good, but not as good as everyone claims it to be, the movie is good, but it is prolly the reason (and ABITW Pt2) its so popular

DSOTM is tied for their best album with Meddle
WYWH and Animals tied for 3
PATGOD is amazing too, but most ppl hate Barrett for no apparent reason
and MLOR and Division Bell are better than ppl make them out to be
Well, it always comes down to opinion anyways, so arguing it is futile. What is interesting is though, I completely agree with you on DSOTM and Meddle, however, I also add the Wall to that and all three make my top Pink Floyd albums, with the winner just depending on the mood I am in at the time.

[l-o-t]

huh... I'm a little surprised that PF is in the lead. Just cuz I thought Zeppelin had a larger fan base... myself included. I do really like Pink Floyd but Led Zeppelin just hits the spot a lot better for me than most other bands... well depends on my mood.

[polishdog90]

Pink Floyd was way more creative imo.

[next jimmy page]

if zeppelin loses i will be devastated
john bonham will be turning in his grave

[AxlVanHagar]

Yeah, you are. I just reported all your posts you've made today for your language and flaming. Hopefully you can get your attitude straight when you come back.


http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n300/axlvanhagar/potkettle.gif

[DSOTM]

The Wall, is very overrated it was no way near as good as Dark side or Wish you where hear.

i agree with you
the wall was a good album, but its nowhere near as good as any other post-meddle albums by floyd
except for final cut
edit: oh hey im not banned what

[Rockbandfan23467]

Zeppelin was diverse too, they did folk, blues, metal, funk, straight-up-rock-and-roll, pop-ish metal, and more! Sometimes all in the same song!

[Hungryfreak]

Gah, very tough choice. I choose Zeppelin just because of the influence they had on my musical taste(they're who got me craving heavier stuff, along with Hendrix and Cream. I guess it's appropriate, haha).

[gorillawarfare]

In a weaker discography The Wall wouldn't be so overrated, but because Pink Floyd created so many great concept albums, The Wall doesn't deserve the place its given in Pink Floyd's catalog.

[next jimmy page]

are you joking my big hawaiian coconuts?!?!?!?! Led Freakin Zeppelin is LOSING!?????!!!!???!!!
*immediately decides to boycott thread*

[TheCrimsonSaint]

I hope Zep loses. I just want them out of the tournament. As DickieV would say:
"I didn't see this coming babyyyyyyyyy!"
http://http://wittybanter.files.wordpress.com/2008/01/p1_vitale.jpg

[Rockbandfan23467]

^Well still have a day left. I guess Queen and Jimi fans are voting...


I want Zeppelin to win so the final battle can be Led Zeppelin vs. The Beatles, but unless Zepplin get 8 more votes, it will not happen.

Does Anyone from HMX vote on these?

[DColtsfan1819]

Led Zeppelin is way better. A better Drummer and better Guitarist than Pink Floyd. And you don't have to be on drugs to enjoy Led Zeppelin.

[lawrence1103]

i don't understand why Led Zep is losing, i mean they are both great bands but the edge goes to Led Zep IMO. i think a lot of people just hate them and think are way too overrated. sad, just sad

[idiotec]

i think a lot of people just hate them and think are way too overrated. sad, just sad
I don't think so. I think many of the people who voted for PF really enjoy Zeppelin as well. It is just we like PF more, not that we hate Zeppelin.

[a21schizoidman]

Led Zeppelin is way better. A better Drummer and better Guitarist than Pink Floyd. And you don't have to be on drugs to enjoy Led Zeppelin.

your opinion, Mason is at least equal if not better than John Sloppy Bonham, and Gilmour >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> page

and Zeppelin was stoned every time they wrote songs and performed

[next jimmy page]

your opinion, Mason is at least equal if not better than John Sloppy Bonham, and Gilmour >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> page

and Zeppelin was stoned every time they wrote songs and performed

...
r u calling david gilmour better than jimmy page?

[TuesdaysGone]

Zeppelin is actually losing? Wow.

[TuesdaysGone]

your opinion, Mason is at least equal if not better than John Sloppy Bonham, and Gilmour >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> page

and Zeppelin was stoned every time they wrote songs and performed

And I'm sober every time I rock out to it.

[DSOTM]

your opinion, Mason is at least equal if not better than John Sloppy Bonham, and Gilmour >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> page

and Zeppelin was stoned every time they wrote songs and performed

really, i wouldnt say anything like that
i see led zeppelin as having more talent instrument-wise, but i like pink floyds style better

Zeppelin is actually losing? Wow.

there are a ton of led zep haters on this board, i first figured this out in the "most overrated guitarist" thread

[lawrence1103]

I don't think so. I think many of the people who voted for PF really enjoy Zeppelin as well. It is just we like PF more, not that we hate Zeppelin.

Well i've heard people on this thread calling them overrated. Pink Floyd is a great band, i love them as well and i'm not knocking them but Led Zep gets my vote.

[a21schizoidman]

...
r u calling david gilmour better than jimmy page?

yep

(10 char.)

[Shredder87]

...
r u calling david gilmour better than jimmy page?
I am too.......

[Rockbandfan23467]

If Gilmour is better than Page, then Queen is Jazz Fusion, The Beatles are Emo, and Metallica is Christian Rap.

[Shredder87]

If Gilmour is better than Page, then Queen is Jazz Fusion, The Beatles are Emo, and Metallica is Christian Rap.
Wait. Are you being sarcastic or serious?! hahaah

[BhindBluEyes430]

I am too.......

Me three...

I find Gilmores solos way more interesting. How do you think "Shine On you Crazy dimond" Part 1 is so amazing. the solo is perfect. just because its not fast dosent mean its not good. Pages solos get boring quick and he is ver repeditive. I always hear the same licks when he improvises.

once again I have to point out another reason I feel "the Wall" is overrated
Confortably numb is often regarded as having an amazing guitar solo.

But Gilmore has so many other songs that are much better than that performance.

"TIME" "money" "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part One) " "have a Cigar" "Any color you like" "Free Four"

[Rockbandfan23467]

Wait. Are you being sarcastic or serious?! hahaah
Ok, saying Gilmour is better than Page is like saying Sid Vicious is better than John Entwhistle.

[a21schizoidman]

Ok, saying Gilmour is better than Page is like saying Sid Vicious is better than John Entwhistle.

no, saying Gilmour is better than Page is like saying Steven Hawking is smarter than a mentally challenged person

[DSOTM]

once again I have to point out another reason I feel "the Wall" is overrated
Confortably numb is often regarded as having an amazing guitar solo.

But Gilmore has so many other songs that are much better than that performance.

"TIME" "money" "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part One) " "have a Cigar" "Any color you like" "Free Four"

whoa wait what
edit: i am now fully convinced that this board is crazy
brb in a few days guys, somebody pm me when this whole thing is over

[Shredder87]

Ok, saying Gilmour is better than Page is like saying Sid Vicious is better than John Entwhistle.
1) Sid Vicious didn't even know what he had was called a bass. 2) David's solo's are well thought out without having too much repetition. 3) I love poon. 4) David has a way more appealing tone and technique than that Jimmy.

Jimmy is good, just not great IMO. Each to their own I guess.

[BhindBluEyes430]

whoa wait what

yes Im saying Comfortably numbs solo is a little overrated
The lyrics are good tho I dont see the sence in the story exept the fact that hes a drug addict or something along those lines


3) I love poon.
Each to their own I guess.

HAHAHa I might put that in my sig

[Shredder87]

yes Im saying Comfortably numbs solo is a little overrated
The lyrics are good tho I dont see the sence in the story exept the fact that hes a drug addict or something along those lines



HAHAHa I might put that in my sig
Whoa, wait a minute there killer. I might agree with you that there are better performances that Comfortably Numb, but to even give it a thought of it being overrated. I dunno man, nothing overrated about that solo.

And I give you permission. hahahah

[DSOTM]

The lyrics are good tho I dont see the sence in the story exept the fact that hes a drug addict or something along those lines

heres the story
guy goes through a lot of ****
gets all crazy
blocks out world with mental wall
tears down wall
shoots himself probably according to the final cut

i agreed with you about the whole "the wall is overrated", but i really liked the album, i just think that there are a few songs on there that werent really that good while pink floyd has other albums that were just perfect
edit: i am now brbing

[Rockbandfan23467]

Shreeder, ok, but A21, he's and idiot beyond repair, like Gerald Ford.

[a21schizoidman]

3) I love poon.

who doesnt?

[Rockbandfan23467]

who doesnt?
Poon? What the funk is poon?

[m00p]

lol wtf

Yeah debates get heated but don't just report someone when you're losing. :|

First of all i wasn't "losing". I'm just tired of seeing his posts....

they always generalize around "that band fcking sucks, how could you like them!!"

or

" That band is stupid and overrated"

Just tired of it julio..

[DSOTM]

First of all i wasn't "losing". I'm just tired of seeing his posts....

they always generalize around "that band fcking sucks, how could you like them!!"

or

" That band is stupid and overrated"

Just tired of it julio..

i never said that pink floyd sucks or that theyre overrated, theyre my favorite band, why would i say that
also i guess its gotten a little less crazy so im back

[Rockbandfan23467]

5 more votes for Zeppelin to win!

[TuesdaysGone]

Yay, the Zeppelin faithful has arrived.

We come from the land of the ice and snow,
>from the midnight sun where the hot springs blow.
The hammer of the gods
Will drive our ships to new lands,
To fight the horde, singing and crying:
Valhalla, I am coming!
On we sweep with threshing oar,
Our only goal will be the western shore.
Ah, ah,
We come from the land of the ice and snow,
>from the midnight sun where the hot springs blow.
How soft your fields so green,
Can whisper tales of gore,
Of how we calmed the tides of war.
We are your overlords.
On we sweep with threshing oar,
Our only goal will be the western shore.
So now youd better stop and rebuild all your ruins,
For peace and trust can win the day
Despite of all your losing.

*CHARGES YELLING: Valhalla, I am coming!*

[Shredder87]

Poon? What the funk is poon?
Then you're too young to know what it is. I'm sorry.

[Rockbandfan23467]

led zeplin was the first grunge band
doesnt balck dog and immigrant song sound kind of grunge
does ne one agree with me?

[Fatal_T]

I'll take Zeppelin - I love Floyd, don't get me wrong, but Zeppelin is definitely #1 of all time for me.

[SteelersFreak1]

led zeplin was the first grunge band
doesnt balck dog and immigrant song sound kind of grunge
does ne one agree with me?

No, Black Dog is pure hard rock and Immigrant Song is practically metal.

[Zildjian77]

I love both Zep and Floyd, but I voted for Pink Floyd b/c DSOTM is prolly my all-time favorite album. :p

[TheCrimsonSaint]

I predict that the winner of this battle will win the competition and thus the crown of best band ever. Hey, why didn't Metallica make the bracket?

[Quinarvy]

I predict that the winner of this battle will win the competition and thus the crown of best band ever. Hey, why didn't Metallica make the bracket?

Alot of bands didn't...perhaps a second bracket and the champion of that goes up against this ones?

[DSOTM]

once again I have to point out another reason I feel "the Wall" is overrated
Confortably numb is often regarded as having an amazing guitar solo.

But Gilmore has so many other songs that are much better than that performance.

"TIME" "money" "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part One) " "have a Cigar" "Any color you like" "Free Four"

honestly though, i want to know what you find in a good guitar solo
because for me, its feeling, pure feeling, and there is no other solo thats ever come close to the amount of feeling that can be sensed in comfortably numb
i mean, it has no fancy effects, no speed, its pure feeling, and because of this, comfortably numb became the archetypal guitar solo; the example of what a good guitar solo should be

[OldFogey]

honestly though, i want to know what you find in a good guitar solo
because for me, its feeling, pure feeling, and there is no other solo thats ever come close to the amount of feeling that can be sensed in comfortably numb
i mean, it has no fancy effects, no speed, its pure feeling, and because of this, comfortably numb became the archetypal guitar solo; the example of what a good guitar solo should be

I like those things, too. And I probably enjoy more Gilmour than Page solos. But for the record, there are a lot of players who have those same characteristics as Glimour but can really let it rip when the time is right. There are times when I listen to Gilmour I want him to just let one fly.

[TuesdaysGone]

Pink Floyd is more popular than I realized... I knew they were big, but BIGGER THAN ZEPPELIN!?!?

[TuesdaysGone]

I predict that the winner of this battle will win the competition and thus the crown of best band ever. Hey, why didn't Metallica make the bracket?

For selling out?

[DSOTM]

Pink Floyd is more popular than I realized... I knew they were big, but BIGGER THAN ZEPPELIN!?!?

floyd's really popular on this board

[a21schizoidman]

I like those things, too. And I probably enjoy more Gilmour than Page solos. But for the record, there are a lot of players who have those same characteristics as Glimour but can really let it rip when the time is right. There are times when I listen to Gilmour I want him to just let one fly.

he was rippin it up on this Les Paul special from 1988 I have seen, he even blew Les away (his own words) [i cannot find a clip tho]
so, Gilmour solo: Theres No Way Outta Here
<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/ZaSSK09_mBc&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/ZaSSK09_mBc&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

[OldFogey]

he was rippin it up on this Les Paul special from 1988 I have seen, he even blew Les away (his own words) [i cannot find a clip tho]
so, Gilmour solo: Theres No Way Outta Here
<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/ZaSSK09_mBc&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/ZaSSK09_mBc&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

Have to take your word for it on the Les Paul special. Didn't catch it myself.

Was that clip supposed to show his fast work? Guess it went by really fast -- I missed it.

[Loucifel]

I voted Floyd, after much consideration. In the end it boiled down to Floyd having (IMHO) a greater diversity in their songs than Zep. And I like them better live.

[Julio_Strikes_Back]

Wow this is the biggest voter turnout ever! F*cking epic!

[WhiffleBallTony]

I have to go with Led Zeppelin.

[Rockbandfan23467]

I voted Floyd, after much consideration. In the end it boiled down to Floyd having (IMHO) a greater diversity in their songs than Zep. And I like them better live.
Zep was diverse to. Combining folk, blues, and metal in the same song on When The Leevee Breaks, for example

[OldFogey]

Wow this is the biggest voter turnout ever! F*cking epic!

I wondered about that. Pretty cool how people are getting into this one.

[next jimmy page]

^^ im also surprised at all the votes... what also intrigues me is the lack of LED ZEPPELIN VOTES!!!!

i understand how people think they're overrated, but i think they're better than floyd. Pink floyd, amazing musicians, awesome album in dark side, but IMO not led zeppelin

[Insane3]

...
r u calling david gilmour better than jimmy page?

You can't compare these guitarists. I prefer Gilmour but I know that he's not a better guitarist. Their styles are completely different. This is not a talent face off cause no one will win. It's an emotion face off. Which do you prefer. Not which is the best.

[dome420]

got to put my vote in for PINK FLOYD

[TheCrimsonSaint]

^^Maybe people have just realised that Zep isn't as great as some people seem to think.

[DSOTM]

You can't compare these guitarists. I prefer Gilmour but I know that he's not a better guitarist. Their styles are completely different. This is not a talent face off cause no one will win. It's an emotion face off. Which do you prefer. Not which is the best.

this man is completely right

^^Maybe people have just realised that Zep isn't as great as some people seem to think.

^^Maybe people are basing their votes on their opinion instead of acting like arrogant bastards that think that everything they say is right.

[Insane3]

i agree with you
the wall was a good album, but its nowhere near as good as any other post-meddle albums by floyd
except for final cut
edit: oh hey im not banned what

I don't agree. Wish you were here is great, but Dark Side of The Moon is far from being my fav PF album. The Wall is my favourite because of the themes, the hard rock/prog/orchestral mix and because it's the best concept album of all time in my opinion. Maybe it's not the best album at all, but every song is meant to follow the one before. You can't listen to only one song from this album. You have to listen to it from the very beginning to the ending.

[Insane3]

Led Zeppelin is way better. A better Drummer and better Guitarist than Pink Floyd. And you don't have to be on drugs to enjoy Led Zeppelin.

Ok, seriously, I don't know who started saying Bonham is so exceptional, but he's not. I'm not saying PF's drumer is better (I don't even remember his name lol) but Bonham had nothing exceptional. He was indeed good, but Moby Dick is not good at all. The solo is boring and repetitive. Same thing for Jones (bassist). He was good, he did the job perfectly, but he's far from being in the range of Chris Squire or Jack Bruce!

[Insane3]

heres the story
guy goes through a lot of ****
gets all crazy
blocks out world with mental wall
tears down wall
shoots himself probably according to the final cut

i agreed with you about the whole "the wall is overrated", but i really liked the album, i just think that there are a few songs on there that werent really that good while pink floyd has other albums that were just perfect
edit: i am now brbing

He doesn't shoots himself!!! Impossible. I never saw it that way lol. i guess it's possible... I actually thought this album (and movie) have a Happy-end.

[TheCrimsonSaint]

^^Maybe people are basing their votes on their opinion instead of acting like arrogant bastards that think that everything they say is right.

Your doucheness is showing.

[DSOTM]

He doesn't shoots himself!!! Impossible. I never saw it that way lol. i guess it's possible... I actually thought this album (and movie) have a Happy-end.

ha yeah, during the song "the final cut", during the line "And if I'm in I'll tell you what's behind the wall." the word "wall" is overdubbed by a shotgun firing
not really solid proof, but theres a possibility :/

[Insane3]

Yay, the Zeppelin faithful has arrived.

We come from the land of the ice and snow,
>from the midnight sun where the hot springs blow.
The hammer of the gods
Will drive our ships to new lands,
To fight the horde, singing and crying:
Valhalla, I am coming!
On we sweep with threshing oar,
Our only goal will be the western shore.
Ah, ah,
We come from the land of the ice and snow,
>from the midnight sun where the hot springs blow.
How soft your fields so green,
Can whisper tales of gore,
Of how we calmed the tides of war.
We are your overlords.
On we sweep with threshing oar,
Our only goal will be the western shore.
So now youd better stop and rebuild all your ruins,
For peace and trust can win the day
Despite of all your losing.

*CHARGES YELLING: Valhalla, I am coming!*

PINK FLOYD WINS!

We came down from
Carson and Springfield
We came down from
Phoenix enthralled
And I can tell you
The names of the Kingdom
I can tell you
The things that you know
Listening for a fistful of silence
Climbing valleys into the shade

for seven years, i dwelt
in the loose palace of exile
playing strange games with the girls of the island
now, i have come again
to the land of the fair, and the strong, and the wise
brothers and sisters of the pale forest
children of night
who among you will run with the hunt?
now night arives with her purple legion
Retire now to your tents and to your dreams
Tomorrow we enter the town of my birth
I want to be ready'
Jim Morrison

[TheCrimsonSaint]

Ok, seriously, I don't know who started saying Bonham is so exceptional, but he's not. I'm not saying PF's drumer is better (I don't even remember his name lol) but Bonham had nothing exceptional. He was indeed good, but Moby Dick is not good at all. The solo is boring and repetitive. Same thing for Jones (bassist). He was good, he did the job perfectly, but he's far from being in the range of Chris Squire or Jack Bruce!

Bonham was nigh-perfect in-studio. He couldn't do **** live. JPJ was nigh-perfect all of the time.

[DSOTM]

Your doucheness is showing.

im sorry, lol, i guess your rightr and im wrong
i must admit, led eppelin is overated at all, i mean ther not good because i dont like tehm!!

[Insane3]

Did anybody listen to the accoustic version of Shine On You Crazy Diamond? It's kinda extremely good. Here's the link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pAkTC6EpSmQ

[Insane3]

ha yeah, during the song "the final cut", during the line "And if I'm in I'll tell you what's behind the wall." the word "wall" is overdubbed by a shotgun firing
not really solid proof, but theres a possibility :/

Ok, never heard it, I have the live version of The Wall so i didn't listen to final cut (probably the less interesting song of the album in my idea). I prefer live a lot.

[DSOTM]

Did anybody listen to the accoustic version of Shine On You Crazy Diamond? It's kinda extremely good. Here's the link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pAkTC6EpSmQ

original was great, but this is really cool too

[TheCrimsonSaint]

im sorry, lol, i guess your rightr and im wrong
i must admit, led eppelin is overated at all, i mean ther not good because i dont like tehm!!

Ah, it's all good. Any band that is commonly claimed as "best band ever" is going to draw claims of "overrated".

[Jhero123]

Pink Floyd is awesome. While I listen to both bands, I think that Floyd is amazing, both live (known due to my library of DVDS :P) and on their albums. I like Led Zeppelins Albums but floyd got me.

[Joe-D-Stortion]

I've not read the thread, but for most people I'd imagine that's like asking if you prefer Chocolate or Beer. Or cheeseburgers vs. pizza. Or even Kit Kats vs Reese's Cups.

Both are awesome. My favorite Floyd would include "Money", "Wish You Were Here", and most of the radio stuff, but I also enjoy "See Emily Play" and a bit of the Syd Barrett stuff. With Zep I also absolutely love what they play on the classic rock radio stations, but my favorites are "Over the Hills and Far Away" or "Thank You" from Led Zep II.

I voted for Floyd in the poll, but would buy either as DLC gladly.

-Joe

[CML207]

Looks like Floyds gonna take it...
Biggest shocker of the BOTB IMO...If Zeppeling pulls through, I say they win it all...If Floyd wins, my money is on The Beatles to win it all

[Insane3]

Pink Floyd VS The Beatles? I won't vote on that one. Or maybe. Anyway this would be very, very hard. Much harder than PF VS LZ

[Rockbandfan23467]

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooo!

[TheCrimsonSaint]

HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!

Victory is mine!

[TheCrimsonSaint]

Next battle!

[m00p]

Yessssss!!!!

Floyd vs. Beatles?

Beatles are going all teh way

[TheCrimsonSaint]

The next battle will actually be Iron Maiden vs. AC/DC.

[BrainDamaged]

Ack! The poll is closed!

I agree that making any comparison between these two A-List bands is almost impossible, or totally ridiculous.

I consider Led Zeppelin to be the ultimate 'rockers' though. Living the rock and roll lifestyle loud and proud. Carefree and wild, and definitely one of the strongest rock influences of the 70's.

I would have cast my vote for Pink Floyd though, because I think their works have actually done more for Music(not just Rock and Roll),art, humanity and philosophy.

Floyd's Live shows are the stuff of legend (I wish I was there :( ).

The Wall is genius on so many different levels, and in so many different ways. If you haven't seen it yet, or haven't watched it in years, I urge you to see it again soon. I watched it earlier in the week, and it's one of those films that gets better year after year.


Wish You Were Here

So, so you think you can tell Heaven from Hell,
blue skies from pain.
Can you tell a green field from a cold steel rail? A smile from a veil?
Do you think you can tell?

And did they get you trade your heroes for ghosts?
Hot ashes for trees? Hot air for a cool breeze?
Cold comfort for change? And did you exchange
a walk on part in the war for a lead role in a cage?

How I wish, how I wish you were here.
We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl,
year after year,
running over the same old ground. What have we found?
The same old fears,
wish you were here.

[BaneOfIcarus]

The Wall, is very overrated it was no way near as good as Dark side or Wish you where hear. It get too much praise especially for that movie which just confused me. I dident find anything special about it. It was alot less musically innovative than their earlier works and The lyrics had a very negative, cynical view with almost no change. Was every song in minor?

Syd just rolled over in his grave...

[Insane3]

The next battle will actually be Iron Maiden vs. AC/DC.

Choice has never been easier. Iron Maiden. I'm even a metal fan and I prefer them a lot. Except for the singer, I find AC/DC very, very boring.

[onitag]

****, led zep hadn't got so much time to create music, because john ****ing bonham died, and he was the best drummer in the whole ****ing world.they really mastered rock music, and more, they played with the its simplicity and roots.pink floyd are not just some ****ing hippies, but they aren't as good as led ****ing zeppelin.

[Insane3]

****, led zep hadn't got so much time to create music, because john ****ing bonham died, and he was the best drummer in the whole ****ing world.they really mastered rock music, and more, they played with the its simplicity and roots.pink floyd are not just some ****ing hippies, but they aren't as good as led ****ing zeppelin.

... Led Zepp are hippies...

Hey but ****, you're so ****. PF ***** owns man****. What the **** is your ****** problem....

[m00p]

... Led Zepp are hippies...

Hey but ****, you're so ****. PF ***** owns man****. What the **** is your ****** problem....

I'm guessing you both have issues...

[ImHotterThanYou]

Led zeppelin, how did they lose =(

[HeIsEdrid]

Seeing as I have listened to all original (LZI-Coda) 85 Zeppelin songs and enjoyed all of them, I'll go with Zeppelin.

I do not dislike Pink Floyd, but I am more of a mainstream Floyd fan, liking WYWH, DSOTM and The Wall.

[Rockbandfan23467]

Led zeppelin, how did they lose =(

I'm not sure, but you are necro-posting.

[msaunpuleilco]

fudge.
I was gonna vote Led Zeppelin in a poll that finally included Led Zeppelin till someone had to close it.

[Rockbandfan23467]

fudge.
I was gonna vote Led Zeppelin in a poll that finally included Led Zeppelin till someone had to close it.

It's old.

[gmarsh]

Zeppelin lost? I am sad now.

[Quinarvy]

I'm not sure, but you are necro-posting.

That's more then Necro-Posting.

Thats SUPER necro-posting.

[Blinkerz]

Man, this one is surprising me. Zeppelin is great, but come on, Pink Floyd hands down!

Agreed.

[Fizzeler]

That's more then Necro-Posting.

Thats SUPER necro-posting.

Zombie posting

[DarkSideOfTheMoon]

With Out A Single Thought It Would Easly Have To Be Pink Floyd. Hands Down Hardly A Compotion There. Dont Get Me Wrong I Think Led Zepplin Are Great But It's Just Pink Floyd Are In A Diffrent League. Would Be More Fair If It Was Pink Floyd And The Beatles Then I Would Have A Tough Time Deciding.

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

With Out A Single Thought It Would Easly Have To Be Pink Floyd. Hands Down Hardly A Compotion There. Dont Get Me Wrong I Think Led Zepplin Are Great But It's Just Pink Floyd Are In A Diffrent League. Would Be More Fair If It Was Pink Floyd And The Beatles Then I Would Have A Tough Time Deciding.

/facepalm (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WXP6nXQ75Ek)

[Meatwad555]

/facepalm (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WXP6nXQ75Ek)

I didn't think spelling errors would deserve a facepalm.

[Lithuanian_Boy]

I didn't think spelling errors would deserve a facepalm.

No but the necro-posting... Oh dear god the necro-posting...

Can we get a lock or something? Please :D

[ROCKBANDFANATIC7526]

I didn't think spelling errors would deserve a facepalm.

It was part of it!

[polishdog90]

With Out A Single Thought It Would Easly Have To Be Pink Floyd. Hands Down Hardly A Compotion There. Dont Get Me Wrong I Think Led Zepplin Are Great But It's Just Pink Floyd Are In A Diffrent League. Would Be More Fair If It Was Pink Floyd And The Beatles Then I Would Have A Tough Time Deciding.

Why Are You Writing Like This?

[Lithuanian_Boy]

Why Are You Writing Like This?

Better question! Why is he necro-posting a 6 month old thread?