Bands most agree on(Alter bridge , Black tide , Coheed , Classic crime , Motley crue)

[Snitsky]

I think these 5 bands could be agreed on by most people

Since they don't scream and they don't have "emo" style singing and they do actually play their instruments well and all include at least 1 guitar solo per song usually I think most people would agree on these bands

Alter bridge (Ties that bind) :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XhnOXAjSHEM

Black tide (Warriors of time) :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rA7m6m7IbH8

Coheed and cambria (The telling truth) :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5WUXjOMOIk

Motley crue (Same ol situation) :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXG0q0qesRw

Most people probably don't know who The classic crime is but they play all instruments well have good guitar solos and their singer sounds like David Cook (American idol winner)

The classic crime (Gravedigging) :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3Xlt-i_hOs


If they could all have a 3 pack I'd say :

Black tide pack :
Warriors of time
Enterprise
Light from above

Motley crue pack :
Same ol situation
Dr feelgood
Kickstart my heart

Coheed and cambria pack :
The telling truth
The final cut
Gravemakers and gunslingers

Alter bridge pack :
Ties that bind
Metalingus
Rise today

The classic crime pack :
Gravedigging
Abra cadavers
The way that you are

[Plan B]

Coheed & Cambria and The Classic Crime please.

[Snitsky]

Oh yeah but for Coheed they need to get master tracks cause the cover of "Ten speed" is so bad that I didn't even buy it lol

I'd buy a master track version of "Ten speed" for RB though

[instantdeath999]

While I'm not the biggest fan of Black Tide, Shockwave was kinda fun.

The others I would buy, too.

[illgreen]

I agree with the Motley Crue pack. RB needs more old Crue.

[BuRn7 CaK3]

Coheed, Motley, and Alter.

[back_blows]

Just Crue for me. I can't stand the others, especially Coheed.

[traneman27]

This may surprise you, but I'd go with "None of the above."

[sitbooboosit]

With the exception of Alter Bridge, Black Tide, Classic Crime, and Motley Crue, I'd be all for it.

[Transbrak]

coheed and cambria

[GNFfhqwhgads]

Oh yeah but for Coheed they need to get master tracks cause the cover of "Ten speed" is so bad that I didn't even buy it lol

I'd buy a master track version of "Ten speed" for RB though
They can't use the master, it's not recorded properly. And I doubt they wanna do a rerecording for a song that's already on the Music Store.

[My name is Fez]

Coheed and Black Tide for me

I'd consider Crue depending on the song/chart

[Weeping Guitar]

I only know Motley Crue and Coheed

[Snitsky]

Wow @ Coheed beating motley crue on the poll O_O

Also people if you don't know all 5 you're supposed to listen to the songs I put in the 1st post to see what you think of them

[Gaiad]

I voted for all of them, never heard of Classic Crime and never listened to Coheed, Classic Crime was surely the best out of all the songs posted there.

But as much as I love Motley Crue(them being my favorite band), that's the first song I thought was iffy and didn't like all too much. :/

[TimeSplitter]

This may surprise you, but I'd go with "None of the above."

I agree. (10 char)

[Crooked Carrot]

I like Coheed, I don't like the pack you made though. It only has songs from their last two albums and I personally think that the first two were just as strong, if not more.

So I love Coheed, I would love a Six Pack for them, maybe:
Three Evils (Embodied in Love and Shadow)
Time Consumer
The Final Cut
In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth:3
No World For Tomorrow
Crossing The Frame

That way there are different kind of songs, heavier songs, more poppy songs, and just really epic songs. :)

[TakeABow]

I like the occasional Coheed song, but the rest of that list doesn't appeal to me much at all.

[Pickle_Czar]

I, too, am going to have to go with "None of the above."

[Chief Stubbs]

I, too, am going to have to go with "None of the above."
Same here. Looks like not everyone agrees.

[HeavyMetalKing]

Coheed and Crue for me.

[fatalvendetta]

I wish I was optimistic enough to think most people agree on ANYTHING on this forum, much less wanting more Coheed and Cambria, or ANY Alter Bridge. I'd pick up any more Coheed and would download Crue, but this poll seriously needs a "none of the above" option.

[Dr. Wagner]

I don't think "most agree" on Alter Bridge. Eeewwwwww, Alter Bridge.

[DreAdAwaKeNinG]

I'd pretty much buy from all four of the known bands. Not really sure about Classic Crime, guess it would depend on the song(s).

[Whosyodaddeh]

Coheed, replace the other 4 bands with more songs from Coheed instead. By the way, nice song choice for coheed.... The Telling Truth is freaking awesome.

[ErikSchierboom]

Alter Bridge and Coheed and Cambria for the win!

[Oscar-Rio]

i agree on none of those bands.

[Fr0dus Maximus]

Coheed and Black Tide plox.

[princeofcups777]

I think these 5 bands could be agreed on by most people


Sorry, but your tastes are not my own.

[HeavyMetalKing]

I don't think he was saying his tastes were yours, I think he was saying that given the demand for these bands on the forums, then most people would want at least one of them. Statistically speaking, if you look at the size and/or number of threads for these bands, it's a sound assumption.

[njdevils327]

i would buy all but probably alter bridge and black tide. i would really like the classic crime. if you havent heard of them guys seriously liten to the song. theyre really good. actually i might buy black tide too. idk something about the singer just doesnt sit well with me.

[PatsFan103082]

Most would agree that those bands all suck...

[MGSolidSnake]

I'd go with Alter Bridge and Coheed, but I wouldn't call these artists the "most agreed upon." I've got my Alter Bridge topic going (in my profile) and there's some people talking smack about them, but people seem to still judge them by their connection with Creed. As for Black Tide, I've never heard of them till their stuff in Rock Band, and I've never heard of Classic Crime till now. And Motley Crue... Well, we've all heard of them.

[a28ozSlurpee]

Classic Crime hands down, love em to death.

Although they're a bit too small to get into RB :(

[Cubecubed]

Most would agree that those bands all suck...

most would be wrong. Along with Muse, Coheed and Cambria is THE most requested band on this forum. so it looks like most dont agree with your thinking.

[HeavyMetalKing]

Most would agree that those bands all suck...

www.cobaltandcalcium.com/message-board disagrees with you. Seriously, keep your ignorant, closed-minded, WRONG comments to yourself.

[TheClashTheClashTheClash]

Motley Crue would be the only one i like, coheed is decent and the others i have never heard of(cept of Black Tide b/c of shockwave)

[PatsFan103082]

Ignorant=Anyone who likes Co and Ca. They are probably the worst band I've ever heard.

PS Im not exagerrating or joking. Im dead serious, they blow.

[Crooked Carrot]

Ignorant=Anyone who likes Co and Ca. They are probably the worst band I've ever heard.

PS Im not exagerrating or joking. Im dead serious, they blow.

Um, why exactly do you say that? I mean, you must have a reason for not liking them. Is it the singer? And also, I don't think I'm "ignorant" for listening to them. I don't even understand what you mean by that. Ignorant about music? Or just life in general? I'd like to think I'm neither and I think that' a dumb statement. And yes, I realize someone said that anyone who doesn't like them is ignorant which doesn't make sense, but did you really have to repeat what he said and sound JUST as dumb? OK, my rant is over. :)

[Cubecubed]

Ignorant=Anyone who likes Co and Ca. They are probably the worst band I've ever heard.

PS Im not exagerrating or joking. Im dead serious, they blow.

yeah you said that Slipknot and Korn Would be good in Rock band, You've officially lost the right to have an opinion. im sorry sir, you fail.

[Gaiad]

Um, why exactly do you say that? I mean, you must have a reason for not liking them. Is it the singer? And also, I don't think I'm "ignorant" for listening to them. I don't even understand what you mean by that. Ignorant about music? Or just life in general? I'd like to think I'm neither and I think that' a dumb statement. And yes, I realize someone said that anyone who doesn't like them is ignorant which doesn't make sense, but did you really have to repeat what he said and sound JUST as dumb? OK, my rant is over. :)

Not to butt in or anything, but their singer sounds pretty much the same as Fallout Boy's which is funny, but I still like them quite a bit.

And he's probably saying ignorant, mostly out of context, it's just that band seems to be the most requested and most popular around Rock Band, he was probably aiming for overpopular or something. Wouldn't mind them on Rock Band, but there is a lot better stuff to put on Rock Band.

[Crooked Carrot]

^ Well considering they are my favourite band, I have to disagree with you that there is a lot better stuff to put on Rock Band. But that's just my opinion and I really love Coheed, there isn't a band I'd rather see in RB. I also disagree that Claudio Sanchez (the lead singer of Coheed) sounds like the lead singer of Fall Out Boy. That's not my opinion, more of a fact. Maybe he sounds like Geddy Lee, or slightly like the lead singer of The Mars Volta, but Fall Out Boy? No, not really. :)

[GNRrockslife]

Crue 3 pack:
Toast Of The Town
Wild Side
Kickstart My Heart

[ULS_980]

Not to butt in or anything, but their singer sounds pretty much the same as Fallout Boy's which is funny, but I still like them quite a bit.

And he's probably saying ignorant, mostly out of context, it's just that band seems to be the most requested and most popular around Rock Band, he was probably aiming for overpopular or something. Wouldn't mind them on Rock Band, but there is a lot better stuff to put on Rock Band.
:confused:
Claudio Sanchez sounds NOTHING like Patrick Stump.
Patrick Stump has a really "nasally" voice (For lack of a better description, It's tough to describe his voice). Either way, I find it annoying. :P

Claudio sounds more like Geddy Lee than anyone else. Even then, he sounds nothing like Geddy Lee.

[PatsFan103082]

yeah you said that Slipknot and Korn Would be good in Rock band, You've officially lost the right to have an opinion. im sorry sir, you fail.
You're right, you're opinion counts more than mine. By the way, Coheed and Cambria cant hold a candle to Korn or Slipknot...That's pretty sad since Slipknot is pretty untalented and Korn peaked over 10 years ago.

Also I said Slipknot would be good in RB if they picked the right songs. Im not a slipknot fan but there are some songs of theirs that would be fun to play. Co and Ca absolutely suck balls but Welcome Home is fun to play.

Just so everyone knows, this is what I meant by ignorant. People who know nothing about music and because they listen to a certain band they think they're above other people. Coldplay fans are the same way. You do realize they had a song called Yellow in which they ended practically every line with the word yellow right? What a friggen joke. Yeah you people know so much more about music than us uncultured slobs,right?

[PatsFan103082]

most would be wrong. Along with Muse, Coheed and Cambria is THE most requested band on this forum. so it looks like most dont agree with your thinking.

Good point. I should have said "Most people who know anything about rock music would agree they suck." I apologize for the mix up.

[HeavyMetalKing]

Good point. I should have said "Most people who know anything about rock music would agree they suck." I apologize for the mix up.

Right, because a band that clearly has a sound akin to that of Led Zeppelin and Iron Maiden, two of the greatest bands to ever exist, is horrible [/sarcasm]. You, sir, are the one who lacks any true knowledge of rock music, and I'm going to assume you've never touched a guitar, because if you have you'd know that Coheed and Cambria's guitar work is excellent from any standpoint. Go study some music theory before you start claiming other people know nothing about music. The fact that they have the largest vote out of the five bands mentioned says something... And Slipknot is more talented? Please! The singer sounds like he's constipated, and their guitar work is weak. But sure, keep telling yourself you're the one with the true knowledge of rock music.

You want to sit here and call people who like Coheed ignorant and preach your OPINION as truth, yet you are clearly in the minority. That, my friend, is ignorance. Perhaps you should have gone to college (or if you have gone to college, perhaps you should have paid attention in your English courses) so that you'd actually be able to apply the English vocabulary appropriately.

The fact that you're 25 and have nothing better to do than sit on the computer and bash people's musical tastes also says something to me....and I'm sure you could probably come up with some smartass comment about how I'm only four years younger than you (as of tomorrow) and I'm sitting here defending a band, except for the fact that I'm only on now because I'm killing the few minutes that exist between two of my classes.

[Crooked Carrot]

You're right, you're opinion counts more than mine. By the way, Coheed and Cambria cant hold a candle to Korn or Slipknot...That's pretty sad since Slipknot is pretty untalented and Korn peaked over 10 years ago.

Also I said Slipknot would be good in RB if they picked the right songs. Im not a slipknot fan but there are some songs of theirs that would be fun to play. Co and Ca absolutely suck balls but Welcome Home is fun to play.

Just so everyone knows, this is what I meant by ignorant. People who know nothing about music and because they listen to a certain band they think they're above other people. Coldplay fans are the same way. You do realize they had a song called Yellow in which they ended practically every line with the word yellow right? What a friggen joke. Yeah you people know so much more about music than us uncultured slobs,right?

Please don't generalize and say that every Coldplay fan and every Coheed fan think they are above others. Now, I'm not a large Coldplay fan, so I can't speak for them, but Coheed is my favourite band. And I still say "Yes" to most bands requested in RB (besides Jonas Brothers and stuff like that). I'm not ignorant about music, I try to educate myself on it on a daily basis (I'm a teenager, so I still have a ton to learn) and I really don't appreciate you saying that I, a Coheed fan, know nothing about music. I do know quite a bit, maybe not as much as you because you seem to be an expert on everything, that's why you're opinion counts more, right? But I still know quite a bit and I know what I like and what I don't like and I'm not rude enough to go around generalizing fans and saying incredibly ignorant things about them. Thank you for your time, come back when you learn not to be a dick. :)