Quote:

---

Originally Posted by supernova1324

Technically, Linkin Par and The Who are both rock, does that make them comparable?

---

Yes.

"The Who is a much better band than Linkin Park is," is a comparison, hence they are comparable. QED.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Quinarvy

Aerosmith because nothing beats Sweet Emotion built into a ****ing Roller Coaster.

---

Sweet Emotion's riff makes Jimmy Page jealous.

hate em both with a passion, but I have to go with Aerosmith.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WingsOfSteel

Yes.

"The Who is a much better band than Linkin Park is," is a comparison, hence they are comparable. QED.

---

And comparing like that is nonsense. I'd take Linkin Park over The Who any day. Are they better? Specifics are needed. Better at their instruments? Better at producing the sound they go for?

People seem to think that the simplicity of some bands is bad, which is bull ****. Visions or Eye of the Tiger? Anyone?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gowienczyk

Aerosmith always came off as a bad Rolling Stones clone to me.

---

I always lol when people ***** about screamo and then praise Aerosmith.

I could stand them if Tyler didn't ruin EVERY ****ING SONG with his incomprehensible screeching.

Journey >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Aerosmith

easy one, Journey. They're just more melodic to me.

wheres the poll?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Quinarvy

Aerosmith because nothing beats Sweet Emotion built into a ****ing Roller Coaster.

---

what about roundabout?

I would like to politely ask what's the interest in Aerosmith? What did they do that nobody did before? It's a true question, not rhetorical.

They didn't really; they just did it "best". Led Zeppelin was not even close to innovating the genre in any way, either.

I happen to adore both bands, but I prefer Aerosmith.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ArmsAreLoud

They didn't really; they just did it "best". Led Zeppelin was not even close to innovating the genre in any way, either.

I happen to adore both bands, but I prefer Aerosmith.

---

I don't agree about Led Zeppelin. I don't like LZ, I actually irationally hate them, but they did things in a way nobody did before, like Kashmir. But in a sense, I have to agree, what they did best was not the create genres but to try to make them better.