It's not great, but if the original was never written then it'd be a good song (I'm not wild about GTGYIML)
i hate it.
It's good. It provides a new twist to GTGYIML, but maybe the band could have been a little cleaner on it. It's a neutral for me.
Not my thing. I agree with the "clean" comment. That's a characteristic of most Beatles songs that I think is at odds with punk music. For me that's why it doesn't work.
i prefer the Soviet version of Yellow Submarine
It's all right, but I really don't see what makes it so special as to have its own topic.