Originally Posted by
jeronemitchell
Now for the real fun:
Let's Predict How These Will Sell!
Here's my prediction on the sales order:
* Nine Inch Nails – “Closer” O
* The Allman Brothers Band – “Jessica” O X
* Modern English – “I Melt With You” O
* Crossfade – “Cold”
* The Band – “The Weight (live)” O X
* Dragonforce – “Cry Thunder” O
I swapped out the #1 spot a number of times, but finally ended on Nine Inch Nails for two reasons: it is arguably the biggest hit by the artist in question, and it is actually the highest charting song of this list having made it up to #41 on Billboard's Hot 100. Interestingly, these are not necessarily "big hits" by Billboard standards. I went back and forth on Allman Brothers, as I have found it to be folly as a whole to bet against 80s one hit wonders, and it is arguably a bigger "hit". However, Billboard charts, to my understanding, weren't quite as big back then, and I think "Jessica" is the bigger song. I think people on these forums tend to underestimate the sales of modern music, hence I placed "Cold" next. For all of its historical significance, I think "The Weight" is one of those songs that is clamored for by the forums, but not as much as a whole (or, to rephrase, take my explanation for "Cold", and go in the opposite direction for "The Weight"). Finally, whereas I do think modern hits sell more than the forums like to admit, I don't know if anything DragonForce has put out could be considered a "hit", and "Operation Ground and Pound" didn't sell enough to make me expect a surprise.
This'll definitely make next week's "Top 25" thread interesting...