Well whatever. I am so not interested in talking about whether objectivity even exists in the first place. This is not Philosophy 101.

Today, I was playing Rock Band, and I was playing Call Me Maybe. My father said that, by adding Call Me Maybe and all those pop songs to Rock Band, that I could sue Harmonix for creating false advertisement by including music that isn't rock in Rock Band.

It was the best "I thought this was ROCK Band" argument I've heard. It's still a stupid argument, but it was entertaining to listen to.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SheSaidSheSaid

Do you also say that Christmas morning can't be objectively said to be better than being shot in the face?

If so, fine. Like I said before, that area of conversation makes me yawn just thinking about it. If not, I'm not sure how the argument holds water.

---

Those two things are completely unrelated, so it's an invalid comparison. The problem I'd have is what is your definition of "better" when comparing 2 things of the same category... And when it comes to music and/or bands, "better" is defined by the listener.

And we can build the dream together. Standing strong forever. Nothings gonna stop us now.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BachiG

And when it comes to music and/or bands, "better" is defined by the listener.

---

No, "favorite" is defined by the listener. Whole different balla wax.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hogan2000

And we can build the dream together. Standing strong forever. Nothings gonna stop us now.

---

We Built This City. Right?

"I like Nickelback more than the Beatles" - acceptable statement.

"Nickelback are better than the Beatles" - utter nonsense.

See what I mean?

I'm curious, does your mindset extend to other art forms? Would you balk at me saying The Godfather is a better movie than Manos: The Hands of Fate ? Yes, there certainly is a gulf between the two in my personal enjoyment, but that's not the statement I'm making here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SheSaidSheSaid

Would you balk at me saying The Godfather is a better movie than Manos: The Hands of Fate ?

---

If you could explain yourself and have good points I wouldn't.

You guys tried your best, about a page in ~2 hours. Thats all I ask of you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Witticus

Sounds like a party.

---

It was one hell of a party!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SheSaidSheSaid

Meh, nobody's talking. I don't really know why I still have it open.

---

Because its a non-stop party!