Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bront20

People enjoy playing charts on songs they like. News at 11.

---

Not always true. I like Parallel Universe musically, but the chart is annoying as all h3ll. On the opposite, the Black Veil Brides songs that I have suck, but the charts are pretty fun. Save for In Waves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nascargo19

Not always true. I like Parallel Universe musically, but the chart is annoying as all h3ll. On the opposite, the Black Veil Brides songs that I have suck, but the charts are pretty fun. Save for In Waves.

---

In Waves is by Trivium.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jibjqrkl

yup, but again. if any of you people would learn to read what I was saying. he says he LIKES THE CHART, but HATES AN IDENTICAL CHART.

keyword here being chart. you know, that thing you SEE! not the one you HEAR!

---

On pro would they be 100% identical though? I'm guessing not.

There's also supporting the artists/songs you like thing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nascargo19

Not always true. I like Parallel Universe musically, but the chart is annoying as all h3ll. On the opposite, the Black Veil Brides songs that I have suck, but the charts are pretty fun. Save for In Waves.

---

Follow up to our lead, generalizations have exceptions.

Also, folks who play "Chart Band" (Songs just for the chart, some folks even turn off the music) are definitely more of an outlier than a rule.

The general rule of thumb if people are less likely to like the charts for songs they don't like than songs they do, even if they songs have identical or nearly identical charting. People are weird like that. You see a lot of that in DLC Quickplay reviews (A lot of the Nickleback charts aren't nearly as bad as they're rated for example)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bront20

On pro would they be 100% identical though? I'm guessing not.

---

yup, it's not the exact same chord. it's still the same pattern, and if you were to put him in front of both those songs without telling which is which and having sound off. he wouldn't know which he'd like better.

as for supporting artists/songs you like, again, we're talking
purely
only
ONLY
about the charts.
the thing you see.

we're not talking about artists
songs
how it sounds

we are
only
talking
about
charts.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by grumblevolcano

In Waves is by Trivium.

---

Meant to say "Same for In Waves" Not sure how I hit the V instead of the M

I'll be getting the upgrade of "The Wicker Man" and DEFINITELY getting "St. Elmo's Fire." I've been waiting for that to come to PS3 again. For the main HMX DLC? I already have Blitz so they already have my money for those songs.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nascargo19

That explains it, you aren't on expert.

---

I don't think that not being able to play Expert Pro Guitar should impact my desire to learn how to play a song in any way.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jibjqrkl

also, where normal people mean the actual chart when we're talking about charts. he is talking about how the song sounds.

---

What? I'm talking about my desire to learn how to play a song.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nascargo19

I guess it makes sense, his 2 favorite bands have his two favorite charts.

---

???
Dragonforce isn't even my favorite Metal band...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by David2380

sure it could be that also..not everyone has good taste...I encourage and welcome your horrible taste

---

Likewise.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bront20

Not a bad Blitz week. Great RBN week for PS3.
Wow, I agree with Cypher on something.

---

I aim to please :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bront20

People enjoy playing charts on songs they like. News at 11.

---

Exactly. I've been saying that for a long long time, but it falls on deaf ears.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jibjqrkl

yup, but again. if any of you people would learn to read what I was saying. he says he LIKES THE CHART, but HATES AN IDENTICAL CHART.

keyword here being chart. you know, that thing you SEE! not the one you HEAR!

---

I /play/ charts. And playing charts are a combination of seeing and hearing. If I dislike what comes out of a note that I play, that negatively impacts my opinion on the chart. I dislike playing songs on guitar which have a guitar part that I don't like listening to. Which leads me back to my point on The Wicker Man. If I'm not dying to play the song on Pro Guitar, then I would rather a song which has a guitar part that I enjoy listening to and would like to learn how to play to have a pro upgrade over it. It's common sense. And subjective.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jibjqrkl

yup, it's not the exact same chord. it's still the same pattern, and if you were to put him in front of both those songs without telling which is which and having sound off. he wouldn't know which he'd like better.

as for supporting artists/songs you like, again, we're talking
purely
only
ONLY
about the charts.
the thing you see.

we're not talking about artists
songs
how it sounds

we are
only
talking
about
charts.

---

The issue is that charts don't exist in vacuums. A lot of things impact PLAYING the charts. I'm going to assume that you mean how I would enjoy them if the volume was muted and the backgrounds were erased. Then I'll say that they are equal. Equal in how terrible they are and equal in how boring they would be. Every chart in Rock Band would be tied for me in how awful they would be to play.

nope, a lot of things impact playing the song

the chart = only WHAT YOU SEE

playing a song in rockband = 2 things.
the music. and the chart.

1 is sound. other is sight
(not counting background animations in this.)

getting wicker man upgrade (though it's the least exciting of the 6 blitz upgrades we are getting/have gotten) and mannequin and st elmos fire from ps3 rbn.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tnevaker

getting wicker man upgrade (though it's the least exciting of the 6 blitz upgrades we are getting/have gotten) and mannequin and st elmos fire from ps3 rbn.

---

Nah, Jungle Boogie will be the most boring for sure (bass should be alright).
Give it Away will be great fun.

Henry said something about HMX having something extra prepared for pro players besides blitz upgrades, I wonder what that is? ^^