Possibly, but there are alot of little things that have been changed, tweaked, or improved, and I could see how patching that into an existing game would be more difficult than just reissuing a new...

Could be calibration. The first time I calibrated the game, I used the two tests it has you do where you press X at certain times, and it was way off, so I just used the settings listed in the...

I'd have less of a problem with the charting if it didn't seem like the "life bar" drops alot quicker for missed notes than other songs.

The other problem is this is one of several songs in the...

I don't understand how anything could really regain trust for anyone, PS3 or 360 owners. The cat's out of the bag - Rock Band features are for sale to the highest bidder. 360 owners shouldn't kid...

This is so ridiculous. Given that GH:WT is coming out, I have no need to twist HMX's arm to support the PS3. **** them.

It's "dirty" because the franchise is 7 months old. I think most people were surprised that a Rock Band 2 would even be coming in 2008, as I think the general impression was that game updates would...

I don't care whether Xbox Live provides voice chat or not. Plenty of PS3 games offer voice chat. It's possible. Just because HMX might have to program it into the PS3 version, rather than the PSN...

Well, the loss in business is what MS's payment is supposed to offset. But I don't really see how any sort of payment could offset delaying the PS3 version past the holidays, because you're going to...

I honestly hadn't even really paid much attention to GH:WT until this thing blew up, but reading about it has made a switch a definite possibility in my mind. I need to hear more about how they've...

I agree with most of what you wrote, but I'm just concerned that HMX is going to keep it vague to help MS, rather than be upfront out of respect for their total user base.

But really, if this...

I would have less of a problem with this if it was the initial launch of the game, and/or not less than a year after the initial release. People have barely settled into the platform, and HMX is...

I like that this thread was created, because timing is a big part of this issue. HMXsean described the window as "a few weeks," and "scant weeks," but when people interpreted that as less than a...

Nah, if I was Sony I'd just get in bed with GH:WT.

That's what I don't understand. If they bought RB1 as an exclusive, I would get it, but the lines are set in terms of people that actually would make their console decision based on immediate...

But can someone answer why HMX decided to do this? Of course, money, but come on. Obviously, there are alot of paid exclusives on every console, but Rock Band's been out less than a year. This has...

Well, and also, if HMX and Sean are so against the console war, why feed it with a misleading press release? While technically true, the only reason to phrase it the way it was, rather than as the...

If it's just a few weeks, then yeah, who cares? But the IGN interview says 360 version in September, and then PS3 "later in the year." Now, obviously, a few weeks later IS technically "later in the...

Exactly. This is a backwards move. HMX has a bigger hill to climb with Playstation users, because they've been buying the GH franchise for longer than xbox users, and have built up more loyalty to...

That's the thing. With two brands, there's no reason to show any loyalty to a company that can't at least stay neutral.

PS3 owners should all jump to GH:WT. To me, this HAS to be an EA/HMX decision, rather than a MS payoff, because RB2 is not a system-seller. RB1 may have been, but by this point, everyone's chosen...