I mean, it's no surprise at all that the other years are winning, I just found it mildly surprising that I was the first person to vote for 2012. And for the record, Toadies and My Chemical Romance...

I can't believe I'm the first person to vote for 2012. Sure the other years supplied more content, but Toadies, My Chemical Romance, AND Andrew W.K.? Those are three winners in my book. Wish the...

Some people held off on buying it (myself included) because they only like a few Green Day tracks. So having them all available to download as singles allows for cherry-picking favorites.

Built to Spill - A great band that's been around since the early ninties. Currently signed to a major label; however, the tracks I've listed below are from their first two albums (okay, mostly from...

Well for me, it's because it was on a mix CD my friend gave me when I was in 6th grade. Its the only Linkin Park song I know all the lyrics to. It's by no means a good song, but it would sure as hell...

I hate to be that guy, but honestly the only Linkin Park song I would buy is Faint. I expected it to be included in a second pack bawww

This is the first time since the Men at Work week where we got a song that's on my iPod. It's also the first time in over a year, I believe, where they release a song I genuinely wanted and...

*bashes*

Nah. Kind of hate this band. But they're popular so whatever.

Artist? Elton John? Please?

Well both "Back on the Chain Gang" and "Don't Get Me Wrong" are top 10 hits in the US, and those kind of tracks seem to be what Harmonix goes for nowadays. "Tattooed Love Boys" was the odd track out...

• Pretenders – “Tattooed Love Boys” X
• Pretenders – “Back on the Chain Gang”
• Pretenders – “Don't Get Me Wrong”

Would buy.

Me too. I was really hoping for a Rock Band 4 purely for that reason.

I would like a LOT of Built to Spill songs. Pretty much anything off There's Nothing Wrong with Love, Perfect From Now On, or Keep it Like a Secret would do, as well as many other songs from their...

My list remains unchanged. All great bands.

Dinosaur Jr. - Little Fury Things
Built to Spill - Car
Modest Mouse - Doin' the ****roach

All from albums released on independent labels. Really I'd take anything from all three of these...

Welp, that IS disappointing.

Also, do mods happen to have those statistics available directly or did you just hear that from a reliable source?

No. The number one song hasn't been and probably won't ever be released. This is just a RickRoll.

Every link featured in Henry's post leads to a RickRoll.

Well done.

What makes people think that it can't be "Never Gonna Give You Up"? I agree that there's no way it's the single most requested song, sure. That's why it makes sense.

It wouldn't be a Rick Roll if...