Should (list of bands) Be In The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?

[Rockbandfan23467]

Bumping because of the recent induction ceremony, and Metallica was removed from the orignal list, as they just got in.

*Thinks that the new direction this board has gone won't respond as well to this*

[Demenise]

RHCP - Yes
Deep Purple - Yes
Alice Cooper - Yes
Megadeth - No
Anthrax - No
Slayer - No
Iron Maiden - No
Judas Priest - Yes
Radiohead - No
Rush - Yes
Yes - Yes
Genesis - Yes
King Crimson - No
Blind Faith - No
Bluesbreakers - No
Alice In Chains - No
Pearl Jam - Yes
Soundgarden - No
Nirvana - Yes
Television - No
Guns N Roses - Yes
KISS - Yes
Captian Beefheart - No
Beck - No
The Smiths - Yes
The Cure - Yes
Small Faces/The Faces - No
New York Dolls - No
Nine Inch Nails - No
The Pixies - No
The Replacements - No
Stevie Ray Vaughn - Yes
T. Rex - No
Weezer - No
The White Stripes - No
Boston - Yes
Heart - Yes
Journey - Yes
Bon Jovi - No
Dire Straits - Yes
Blink-182 - No
Green Day - No
Limp Bizkit - No
Def Leppard - Yes
Stone Temple Pilots - No
Beastie Boys - No
Linkin Park - No
Live - No
Nickelback - No
Smashing Pumpkins - No
Backstreet Boys - No
Meat Loaf - Yes
Motley Crue - No
Poison - Yes
Blue Oyster Cult - Yes
Foo Fighters - No
Devo - No
Spinal Tap - No
"Wierd" Al Yankovic - No

[Zidane]

RHCP-Soon, but not now
Deep Purple-YES
Alice Cooper-YES
Megadeth-Eventually, I'd like to see Lars induct them (Dave would love it)
Anthrax-Eventually
Slayer-YES
Iron Maiden-YES
Judas Priest-YES
Radiohead-Someday, 25 years is a long time
Rush-Yes
Yes-Uh, yes
Genesis-Sure
King Crimson-I need to brush up on them
Blind Faith-Need to brush up
Bluesbreakers-Brush up
Alice In Chains-Maybe
Pearl Jam-Someday
Soundgarden-Maybe
Nirvana-2014 will be the 25th year of Bleach, get ready for them that year
Television-Don't know who they are
Guns N Roses-Uhm, yeah ok
KISS-Most definitely
Captian Beefheart-Don't know who that is.
Beck-Eventually
The Smiths-Yes
The Cure-NO
Small Faces/The Faces-Don't know
New York Dolls-Yes
Nine Inch Nails-Someday
The Pixies-YES
The Replacements-Yes
Stevie Ray Vaughn-Yes
T. Rex-Yes
Weezer-Maybe someday
The White Stripes-They really haven't done much to wow me, but maybe some day?
Boston-Yes
Heart-Yes
Journey-Yes
Bon Jovi-Maybe, Yes
Dire Straits-Maybe
Blink-182-No
Green Day-Maybe
Limp Bizkit-Nope
Def Leppard-Yeeeeeeeeaaaaaamaybe
Stone Temple Pilots-Maybe
Beastie Boys-Mos Def
Linkin Park-No
Live-No
Nickelback-No
Smashing Pumpkins-Yes
Backstreet Boys-Well, they did change the face of music...
Meat Loaf-Maybe, I don't think he gets enough respect.
Motley Crue-YES
Poison-Maybe
Blue Oyster Cult-YES
Foo Fighters-SOMEDAY, BUT YES!
Devo-Maybe
Spinal Tap-YES
"Wierd" Al Yankovic-He deserves to be in for sure.

[gmarsh]

YES
Deep Purple
Alice Cooper
Iron Maiden
Rush
Yes
Pearl Jam
Guns N' Roses
KISS
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Boston
Judas Priest
Def Leppard
Motley Crue
Poison
Blue Oyster Cult
Meat Loaf

Maybe
Megadeth
Anthrax
Slayer
Alice In Chains
Soundgarden
Nirvana(Who said that )
Heart
Journey
Bon Jovi
The Pixies
Smashing Pumpkins
Devo
New York Dolls

NO
The Cure
RHCP
Radiohead
Genesis
King Crimson
Blind Faith
Bluesbreakers
Television
Captian Beefheart
Beck
The Smiths
Small Faces/The Faces
Nine Inch Nails
The Replacements
T. Rex
Weezer
The White Stripes
Dire Straits
Blink-182
Green Day
Limp Bizkit
Stone Temple Pilots
Beastie Boys
Linkin Park
Live
Nickelback
Backstreet Boys
Foo Fighters
Spinal Tap
"Wierd" Al Yankovic

[Lolicat]

The Pixies - No

Although I disagree with a lot of your picks, this stands out. Explain exactly why the Pixies, probably the most influential artists in the birth of an 'alternative' rock identity, don't deserve to be in the Rock 'n' Roll HoF, but a band like Nirvana do?

[Gowienczyk]

I love stupid people.

[Zidane]

Although I disagree with a lot of your picks, this stands out. Explain exactly why the Pixies, probably the most influential artists in the birth of an 'alternative' rock identity, don't deserve to be in the Rock 'n' Roll HoF, but a band like Nirvana do?

You mean Nirvana, that one band that influenced a ton of other bands and was a voice of a generation? That Nirvana?

Listen, the Pixies def. deserve to be in the HoF, no question. Just don't go around saying something that sounds so ignorant.

[HyeJinx1984]

Just because one band gets in doesn't mean another shouldn't. Nirvana should be in the HoF fame, and so should The Pixies. No point in arguing one over the other.

[Zidane]

Just because one band gets in doesn't mean another shouldn't. Nirvana should be in the HoF fame, and so should The Pixies. No point in arguing one over the other.

The Pixies should be in now though. If 2014 is the year Nirvana is allowed to get in, then the Pixies should be ready now. (When did their first album come out?)

[Gowienczyk]

The Pixies should be in now though. If 2014 is the year Nirvana is allowed to get in, then the Pixies should be ready now. (When did their first album come out?)

Surfer Rosa & Come On Pilgrim was 1987 if I recall, but they had EPs and watnot before then....