GandWuser's Tiering Thread

[GandWuser]

Karn Evil 9 SOUNDED like it was going to be devils on Drums and Keys (and likely be the hardest keys song ever if it were released), but it always bothered me that Animal As Leader gave bass a 5-dot when tiering it as I thought it should be a devil. I thought his 5-dot on vocals was good though, and I don't understand why it is a devil on vox. Care to explain?

However, I am not sure that guitar is that prominent to be a 5-dot. I can see it being a four dot as the parts you do play sound a bit busy, but I think there is about three minutes worth of guitar in a nearly 30 minute long song. Care to explain this one, too?

Well, there were a lot of vocals, and they seemed to be kind of scattered in range. That, and you're going to have a sore throat singing a song that's over 20 minutes long. As for the guitar, I did think of putting it as a four-dot, but I felt that seemed a little too lenient.

Starting today's update now.

[GandWuser]

And finished.

NOTES: There was somethign that sounded like it could have been Keys in Hold On, but I think it was just pick up from something so I didn't chart it.

FUN FACT: Somehow "America, F*ck YEah" is the most viewed tier on this thread, with over 150 views. Not sure why though.

Schedule Update:

Tomorrow:

Blood Ocean
Divisions
Lay It Down
Multi-Man Melee 1
Stars

Wednesday:

Black Sheep
Death
In Memory Of Elizabeth Reed (Live At Filmore East)
Orgasmatron (WHAT AN INCREDIBLY SUBTLE NAME)
A Surprise for hitting 200 songs

[Munnchy]

I thought survival was going to be really tough, especially on vocals. Cheers for that

[tinman22897]

And now some Muse songs from me:
"Resistance" - Muse
I'm predicting a high tier for drums.

[Relauby]

NOTES: There was somethign that sounded like it could have been Keys in Hold On, but I think it was just pick up from something so I didn't chart it.

Do you remember where it was? I was listening to the song quite a bit before I requested it and was looking for keys and never found anything.

Anyway, next request is actually another Crack the Sky, Rangers at Midnight

[GandWuser]

Do you remember where it was? I was listening to the song quite a bit before I requested it and was looking for keys and never found anything.

Anyway, next request is actually another Crack the Sky, Rangers at Midnight

The transition between Hold On and Surf City had some kind of beepy noises. As I said, I think it was just pick up from like a microphone or something.

[Relauby]

The transition between Hold On and Surf City had some kind of beepy noises. As I said, I think it was just pick up from like a microphone or something.

Oh yeah, I hear it now. Yeah, it just sounds like some kind of feedback.

[generalbane]

Thanks!

Metropolis Pt 1: The Miracle and the Sleeper- Dream Theater

[tinman22897]

Quite a few people have already tiered that song.

[TheBonobo4]

Orgasmatron (WHAT AN INCREDIBLY SUBTLE NAME)

I know what you mean, but the song actually has no innuendos in it at all. It's about religion, politics and war and how they are used and manipulated in horrible ways.