In Need of Tiers

[Radiohead97]

Hm, interesting tiers. They seem good to me.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Silversun Pickups - "The Royal We"

A bit hard to tier, but I tried my best. Drums are definitely the highest though, because the time signature is really awkward in some parts.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Gerry Rafferty - "Baker Street"

I barely heard much guitar (save for a few easy acoustic chords) until the solo, which didn't really affect the tier dramatically. Drums I figured would be an interesting combination of the congas and the actual drums, but it didn't sound too hard, in all honesty. I almost made keys devils, but they didn't sound complicated enough for devils. It would definitely be an odd combination of sax, piano, and other effects, though.

[Radiohead97]

Thanks for doing both!

For The Royal We, I always pictured that song to be a challenge on drums. Plus I think that the orchestra parts would be fun to play on keys.

As for Baker Street, I thought that it would be devil tiers for pro keys because of those weird transitions from piano to sax and other instruments.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

I probably should have put Baker Street devils on either legacy or pro, yeah.

Evanescence - "Snow White Queen"

This one was a tad hard to tier, actually. I had to re-listen to certain parts to make sure the tier looked okay.

Drums and keys were the toughest to place. Drums had a really complicated beat going on in the muffled, electronic parts, but other than that it's simple, so I think a 4 or 5 is suitable. Keys are mainly prominent in the beginning and end, and other than that it's mainly violin and other simple stuff. Bass I didn't hear much of, and when I did, it didn't sound hard. All in all, I tried my best, and I hope the next batch is good.

[Radiohead97]

"Atomic" - Blondie (Album: Eat to the Beat) (TIERED)

"Paradox" - Kansas (Album: Point of Know Return) (TIERED)

"Paperback Writer (Live)" - Paul McCartney (Album: Good Evening New York) (TIERED)

"Boss of Me" - They Might Be Giants (Album: Music from Malcolm in the Middle) (TIERED)

"Crash Into Me" - Dave Matthews Band (Album: Crash) (TIERED)

"Stillborn" - Black Label Society (Album: The Blessed Hellride) (TIERED)

Of this batch:
Shortest: Boss of Me (2:59)
Longest: Crash Into Me (5:17)

Also, a quick random note, I'm running out of songs I'm considering for the setlist, so I may do DLC packs and albums for some batches in the future.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Atomic's already in Rock Band, technically. It was in Rock Band Network 1 at one point, but was taken down, and now only Xbox users can play it via a special code. Do you still want me to tier it anyway? I'd assume not. I can just tell you what the HMX tiers are for it, if you'd like.

That's alright, btw. But in all honesty, if you're going to post full packs or albums, I will need some help from Sonicnerd, GameMaster, or whoever else wants to post here. I know people are viewing this thread (Over 6,000 views and only 166 replies? Really?), and I can't do full albums by myself unless you want me to do them really slow, since I only update with one, or two songs max, a day.

[Radiohead97]

If I can't find it in the RB database on here, it doesn't count.

So yeah, go ahead and tier Atomic. Besides, the version I found on YouTube was the shortened version and was pre-RB3.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

That sounds good. I'll title it Atomic (RB3 Version) then, since it was technically in Rock Band at one point. I'll give it the same tiers for legacy, but then tier keys, harmonies, and pro guitar/bass. Is that okay? That's probably what Harmonix would do if they were to re-release it, anyways.

[PanicAttack90]

But in all honesty, if you're going to post full packs or albums, I will need some help from Sonicnerd, GameMaster, or whoever else wants to post here. I know people are viewing this thread (Over 6,000 views and only 166 replies? Really?), and I can't do full albums by myself unless you want me to do them really slow, since I only update with one, or two songs max, a day.

I might have a go at tiering at some point. Is there a link to the template you use?