As some Beatles fans know, the Beatles recorded an almost 14 minute song titled "Carnival of Light". The song has never been released to the general public and very few own a copy of the song. In 1995, Paul mentioned finally releasing the song, but that plan eventually fizzled out. So with the unveiling of the Beatles Collection on 9/9/09 and the Beatles: Rock Band, could the song finally be released? Your thoughts?
RockBand.com
Forums
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 19
-
06-10-2009 03:01 AM #1
The Beatles: Rock Band...Could the Carnival of Light finally make an appearance?
Last edited by gooby07; 06-10-2009 at 03:12 AM.
-
06-10-2009 03:09 AM #2
Which John are you speaking of...cuz Lennon definitely wasn't around in 1995.
-
06-10-2009 03:11 AM #3
Oh, sorry. I meant Paul. Oops.
-
06-10-2009 04:19 AM #4Rising Star
- Join Date
- May 2009
- Location
- Nowhere, Man
- Posts
- 508
I can't see it happening on Rock Band. I think the best chance of it appearing would be in the documentary video accompanying the remastered Sgt. Pepper.
I think it will make Revolution 9 sound melodic though.
-
06-10-2009 04:38 AM #5
I really doubt it will be in TB:RB or even released at all for that matter. Paul had mentioned it again last year, but when they had first discussed releasing it during the Anthology era, George was in opposition. I don't think they would go against his wishes now.
-
06-10-2009 04:42 AM #6George MARTIN
Originally Posted by sporkthrumyheart
-
06-10-2009 05:13 AM #7Clever. But no, Harrison. Originally Posted by AndywinXp
George MARTIN
-
06-10-2009 05:16 AM #8Rising Star
- Join Date
- May 2009
- Location
- Nowhere, Man
- Posts
- 508
George H was in opposition of it coming out on the Anthology. He thought it was self indulgent, which it probably was to take up 14 minutes of a cd on avant garde experimentation. That doesn't necessarily mean he didn't want it to come out ever, anywhere. At least that's how I feel about it.
George Martin just thinks it's rubbish.
-
06-10-2009 05:23 AM #9Yeah, that makes sense. But I doubt Olivia would sign off on it if she knows that he was opposed to it, even if it was only in regards to its inclusion on Anthology. And I'm sure George Martin sees it as what happens when the boys get loose if you leave them alone for just one minute... Originally Posted by GloiGloi
George H was in opposition of it coming out on the Anthology. He thought it was self indulgent, which it probably was to take up 14 minutes of a cd on avant garde experimentation. That doesn't necessarily mean he didn't want it to come out ever, anywhere. At least that's how I feel about it.
George Martin just thinks it's rubbish.
-
06-10-2009 05:27 AM #10Rising Star
- Join Date
- May 2009
- Location
- Nowhere, Man
- Posts
- 508
Yeah, maybe. Who knows though. Olivia could use the knowledge that Paul wants to release it as bargaining power for something of George's she wants out. I'm sure it all comes down to politics in the end.
LOL at GM. Now then boys, settle down.
Reply With Quote
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
