Is this list good? All I did was swap everything from RB2s list w/ something similar

[Snitsky]

I'm trying to make a RB3 list by mirroring RB2 , and simply replacing every song in the game with something thats at least kind of similar

Refer to the RB2 list at this link to see what exactly replaced what
http://www.joystiq.com/2008/07/14/ro...over-80-songs/

I honestly do not even know some of the stuff I put in here , (Elvis costello , The replacements , Modest mouse , etcs song replacements)

Alot of this is the same bands replacing themselves actually

Rock Band 3 On-Disc Track List (and what RB2 song they replaced) :
1. Airbourne - Stand up for rock n roll
2. AFI - Dancing through sunday
3. Garbage - Only happy when it rains
4. Alice in chains Them bones
5. Lynyrd Skynyrd - Freebird
6. Avenged sevenfold - Bat country
7. Eagles - Hotel california
8. BrokeNCYDE - Skeet skeet
9. Radiohead - Paranoid android
10.Ramones - Bonzo goes to bitburg
11. The 69 eyes - Dead girls are easy
12. Tommy Tutone - Jenny/867-5309
13. The beatles - Hey jude
14. Bon Jovi - You give love a bad name
15. Cheap trick - I want you to want me
16. A-Ha - Take on me
17. Dinosaur Jr. - Pieces
18. Disturbed - The night
19. Dream theater - Metropolis part 1
20. Duran duran - Ordinary world
21. Elvis Costello - Allison
22. Fleetwood mac - Dreams
23. Foo fighters - The pretender
24. Guns N roses - Nightrain
25. Interpol - Obstacle 1
26. Janes addiction - Been caught stealing
27. Pink floyd - Money
28. Jimmy eat world - Always be
29. Joan Jett - I love rock n roll
30. Journey - Seperate ways (Worlds apart)
31. Iron maiden - Phantom of the opera
32. Kansas - Dust in the wind
33. Stone temple pilots - Trippin on a hole in a paper heart
34. Nightwish - Dark chest of wonders
35. Linkin park - Papercut
36. Sum 41 - We're all to blame
37. Lush - Ladykillers
38. Mastodon - Divinations
39. Megadeth - Holy wars... the punishment due
40. Metallica - Leper messiah
41. 311 - Beautiful disaster
42. Death cab for cutie - I will follow you into the dark
43. Motorhead - King of kings
44. Nirvana - All apologies
45. Jeremy Camp - There will be a day
46. Panic at the disco - That handsome green gentleman
47. Paramore - Ignorance
48. Pearl jam - Life wasted
49. Cake - The distance
50. Rage against the machine - Guerrilla radio
51. Ratt - Back for more
52. Red hot chilli peppers - Californication
53. Rise against - Ready to fall
54. Rush - Freewill
55. Silversun pickups - Panic switch
56. Smashing pumpkins - Bullet with butterfly wings
57. Misfits - Scream
58. Sonic youth - Incinerate
59. Soundgarden - Rusty cage
60. Squeeze - Pulling Mussels (From the Shell)
61. Steely dan - Do it again
62. Styx - Come sail away
63. Steve Perry - Oh Sherrie
64. System of a down - Aerials
65. Talking heads - Once in a lifetime
66. Tenacious D - The metal
67. Testament - Face in the sky
68. The donnas - Take it off
69. The Veronicas - 4ever
70. The grateful dead - Touch of grey
71. The doors - Break on through (to the other side)
72. Miley Cyrus - Rockstar
73. The offspring - You're gonna go far kid
74. The replacements - I will dare
75. Derek & the dominoes - Layla

Bonus Songs
76.Abnormality - Question?
77.Bang Camaro - Revolution
78.Some song you've never heard of by a HMX band
79.Some song you've never heard of by a HMX band
80.Some song you've never heard of by a HMX band
81.Some song you've never heard of by a HMX band
82.Some song you've never heard of by a HMX band
83.Some song you've never heard of by a HMX band
84.Some song you've never heard of by a HMX band

Well what do you all think? Is this good enough? I don't see how it would be too bad to buy it if its a direct mirror of RB2 with every song replaced by something similar

[Mystlyfe77]

A handful of good bands sandwiched between crap, some poor song choices by a few of those good bands, and a lie about me never hearing of HMX bands. And why would "Heartwork" be a bonus track?

I voted I'd buy it but complain. It's the truth. Instead of arbitrarily selecting semi-random songs from the bands you don't listen to (see Sonic Youth, Testament), why don't you pick some of their excellent songs not yet in the game?

[timmay9]

Tempted is already DLC...

[Snitsky]

Tempted is already DLC...

I did say I don't even know some of what I put in this list lol

What should I replace it with?

why would "Heartwork" be a bonus track?

Was just throwing something somewhat similar in "Visions" old place

[Mystlyfe77]

Was just throwing something somewhat similar in "Visions" old place

Except Abnormality is a HMX band. And absolutely nothing like Carcass, particularly Heartwork-era Carcass.

[timmay9]

"Pulling Mussels (From the Shell)"

[Snitsky]

Except Abnormality is a HMX band. And absolutely nothing like Carcass, particularly Heartwork-era Carcass.

I didn't know they were a harmonix band I guess I'll fix it then

[cherokeesam]

*sigh*

Enough already.

You are NOT going to prove your point, Snitsky, because you, sir, fail at marketing.

No, you're *not* going to get people to buy a disc full of crap even if it contains a few "hidden" gems. Marketing failure = marketing failure = marketing failure, no matter how you slice it.

Jesus, this is tiresome.

[Maghook]

Only if you had the option to erase songs from the RB3 disc... that is:

8. BrokeNCYDE - Skeet skeet
69. The Veronicas - 4ever
72. Miley Cyrus - Rockstar

What the hell is this doing on here? Seriously.

I also like how obnoxious your poll options are... you either love it or you're full of ****, eh? Well, I guess I'm full of ****.
Some of this is old GH fodder, surely there are better songs out there that you know of that aren't from GH1/2/3? And I had no idea The Beatles and Pink Floyd were in RB2, is there some magical unlock code I missed?

But, I would love me some Cake, preferably their I Will Survive cover.

[Snitsky]

Only if you had the option to erase songs from the RB3 disc... that is:

What the hell is this doing on here? Seriously.

What they are doing there? They are there to replace respectivley , other stuff from RB2 that was "WHAT THE HELL" too

BrokeNCYDE = Beastie boys replacement (Appropriate stupid rap rock replacement)
The Veronicas = "We got the beat" replacement (Appropriate super poppy replacement)
Miley Cyrus = "Kids in america" replacement (Appropriate super poppy and kid friendly replacement)

If you ask me , the stuff they replaced are far far FAR bigger "WTF!?" songs than they could ever be