Chart Preview Videos

[Yoshipupdude]

oh and can you add the genres of each band if possible?

qft i was thinking the same thing. seeing the genre of the songs so i know which videos to watch would be awesome. even if you just copy the genres from this thread

http://www.rockband.com/forums/showthread.php?t=157235

[Day_0f_Reckoning]

just like to point out that Adam Siegel's "burn" and Big Square's 'Burn" is actually link to the exactly same video since the video says its by big square i suggest removing the other to avoid confusion

[NSIYusuke]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2I2xgyZXK4

Do I get a prize for being the first person to chart killswitch scratching in a song on RBN? Anyhoo, Lost in the Dusk, hooray!

EDIT: hahaha, and Buckethead styled nubbing, too. xD

[Knucklesdude]

Removed:
Adam Siegel - "Burn" (see: Big Square - "Burn")

Updated:
Zack Wilson - "Another California Song", "Ox" (new videos)
Rhythm Authors - Preview 1 (back from the dead)

Added:
Brad Sucks - Preview Montage
Bluefusion - "Lost in the Dusk", "NS-1"
Glass Hammer - "Hypberbole"
The Fisticuffs - "Liverpool Judies"
Alias Unknown - "Top Back"
Songs to Wear Pants To - "Never (Extended)"

[S1ckH4nds]

Aw, looks like the first post just got updated earlier today, and we only just got our latest preview uploaded. Boo hoo! Ah well, our loss is your feast...

Circus Circus
** - "First We Feast, Then We Felony" | Full Band | from RockGamer Studios

This one's an awesome punk/screamo assault from this Lancaster, PA based band, and has some seriously fun charts for every instrument. Hope you enjoy!

[TheNobleRobot]

Thanks for maintaining this list! I've got two videos to add...

Bernard Allison
- "The Other Side" - | Full Band | from Noble Rhythm
- "The Other Side" - | Vocals Only | from Noble Rhythm

[Mushroom]

Noble Robot, I've left some comments on the guitar chart on your video, but I hope you don't mind if I repost them here:

GUITAR COMMENTS (small letters mean HOPOs):
0:05 feels like there's a missing note hidden in that long note, maybe R-g-R-Y
0:12 should be HO/PO chords
0:14 sounds more like G-r-R-y
0:37 needs a Blue just before the Orange, with the orange being a HOPO
0:39 Same as above
0:57 Same
0:59 Same
1:25 Yellow needs to HOPO into blue, and the first green sounds like a different note to the second
1:50 Needs a Blue before the Orange
2:03 Same
2:10 Same

I didn't have enough space to talk about the whole song on YT comments, but many of these problems are recurring when the musical pattern recurs. Sorry to be so harsh, but if I were playing that, I'd feel like I was missing out on some of the notes I was hearing.

This is coming from someone who enjoys playing blues on a real guitar, so I recognise some of the style elements that would make it fun to play, but are sadly missing.

[Knucklesdude]

Added:
Circus Circus - "First We Feast, Then We Felony" (sorry Sickhands. watch this video folks!)
Bernard Allison - "The Other Side" (two videos)

Updated:
All authoring groups and whatnot now have links. (except Ozone and Authority; let me know if you get/have a webpage and I'll add it)

Edit: Oh, and genres will likely come next update. Sorry for ignoring you.

[TheNobleRobot]

Sorry to be so harsh

Thanks for the feedback, for sure, I will take your notes into consideration during peer review, but you wrote them as if they were spelling errors and not your opinion.

For example, some of the "missing notes" you describe are smoothed over by choice, per the RBN spec. And the "first green sounds like a different note to the second" is because one is a muted note.

Again, thanks for taking the time to look it over, I'm sure you meant well. If you have other notes, feel free to PM me.

[JesusSilencio]

Thanks for maintaining this list! I've got two videos to add...

Bernard Allison
- "The Other Side" - | Full Band | from Noble Rhythm
- "The Other Side" - | Vocals Only | from Noble Rhythm

Some stuff with the drum chart:

-During the chorus and during the guitar solo, the drummer's keeping time on open hi-hat, not crash cymbal. It should be charted to either blue or yellow (and make sure you fix the drummer animation too).

-For some reason, you chart all of the crashes to two pads, even though as far as I can tell, the drummer is only hitting one crash cymbal each time. You should probably just chart them to green (unless I'm mistaken and he is hitting two crashes at some spots).

-You always chart snare flams as red+blue, when they should be charted as red+yellow.

-At about 1:04, there should be another hi-hat hit (on the + of 1).

-At about 1:21, I think that red+blue should just be a red. I'm not hearing a tom or anything else there, and it doesn't sound like a flam. It's possible that I just can't hear it though. As I said before though, the red+blue at about 1:22 should be red+yellow, since that's how HMX charts snare flams.

-That second yellow+green at 1:24 is just an open hi-hat hit, so it should be charted to blue. That first yellow+green should probably just be green, as I explained earlier.

-At about 1:55, that first blue after the red+green is a closed hi-hat hit, so it should just be yellow.

-That second green at about 1:56 is open hi-hat, so it should be blue. Then, the red+blue after it should be red+yellow, since it's closed hi-hat there.

-At 2:31, the rhythm in the fill seems slightly off. It seems like you added swing there, when the drummer isn't actually putting any swing in the fill. I'm not sure though.

-At 2:34, same thing as at 1:24.

-At 3:04, that first red is a flam, so it should be red+yellow.

-At about 3:06, that green is a open hi-hat, so it should be blue (or possibly yellow).

~

Also, listening to the guitar, I think I agree with Mushroom that those oranges would work better as blue to orange HOs. It sounds like the guitarist is doing hammer on or a bend, and I can't remember any song that HMX didn't chart HOs like that.

Sorry if this comes off as harsh, or it looks like I'm spell checking you, but these are the things I would say if I saw this song for peer review. Just trying to make it easier for once the open beta comes .