Controversial Subject: 4'33" and others like it.

[afterstasis]

while 4'33 is obviously not suited for the game anyone who disses john cage gets a knuckle-sandwich, ya' hear?

[Squaretriangles]

They can put this in the section of the RBN store with "You Suffer".

[k-mac]

Give it to Activion - they'll chart the h3ll out of it. Three-chords to the max!!!!

[DanB91]

And that's assuming that it would get past peer review.

There's no reason why it shouldn't. I remember you saying we were supposed to pass a song based on if the notes match up and nothing else.

[HavveK]

You will need to author at least one note per playable instrument and have at least one playable instrument.

4'33" consists of only rests so It'd not be possible to chart... only possible to overchart

Is there a length time limit? I hope not because we need John Cage's "As Slow as Possible."

[LuigiHann]

You will need to author at least one note per playable instrument and have at least one playable instrument.

4'33" consists of only rests so It'd not be possible to chart... only possible to overchart

So... we could chart a song with only one note? Gotta find one now

[woodwindpizza]

So... we could chart a song with only one note? Gotta find one now

I wonder if a 5-fret chord with only guitar for 30 seconds will be allowed as a song.

Note: I am a PS3 user so I'm not authoring or charting anything. I am purely interested in these topics in case I ever become a charter or RBN Peer Reviewer.

[afterstasis]

i suspect the main problem people wanting their one-note songs on RBN will encounter is the fact that the charting groups will likely have no interest in aiding them, so they'll have to pay the $99, get their asses on reaper, and do the work themselves.

in other news, 6 minutes of silence was just added to the middle of "such a never ending space".

[cherokeesam]

Well, this proves one man's art is another man's garbage.

Or was it the other way around? I get confused sometimes.

THIS man's garbage is a damn hot redhead named Shirley Manson with pipes that'll blow the doors off an armored car.

[timmay9]

Dissing John Cage is not cool, btw.