HMX dropped the ball

[PCTraitor]

You shouldn't post these things even in jest some reviewer is liable to see it and add it to his review knocking 2 points off for it.

[yaniv297]

As long as they keep George's hat, I'm happy.

[hmxhenry]

But in some cases you've got to at least acknowledge the history that's there as well.

I think we've more than succeeded in acknowledging the history of The Beatles in this game, and I think we still would have succeeded even if we didn't have them dancing at the end of Hello, Goodbye.

Different people will want different things. One person in this thread wants to see them dancing, one person wants George's hat, one person wants specific animations... if we included all the little things that Beatles fans wanted to see in the game then our art team wouldn't have had anything to do. The Beatles did it before and they did it better than anyone, and we're not trying to recreate that. We'll have those little nods in songs here and there, but we're trying to do something new.

[Lockheed]

Why are we knitpicking here? The Beatles have finally been allowed to be released in a media format that many can enjoy and interact with. The fact that they have had so much support from the remaining members should speak for itself. You cannot please everyone but there is something there for every fan and novice alike. So Come Together, Right Now!

[rayrox222]

Why are we knitpicking here? The Beatles have finally been allowed to be released in a media format that many can enjoy and interact with. The fact that they have had so much support from the remaining members should speak for itself. You cannot please everyone but there is something there for every fan and novice alike. So Come Together, Right Now!

I like how your sig clashes with your statement here :P

[Lockheed]

I like how your sig clashes with your statement here :P

I may be a walking contradiction but my logic is not, lol.

[wcarnation]

There's a weird notion people have about music that the only way to do any good is to endlessly replicate the successes of the past

Yet those successes were not made in that same fashion