Any particular reason why everyone hates I Want You (She's so Heavy)

[biglou114]

I've never particularly enjoyed the song in the first place (and I have excuses to like almost every other Beatles song). The song annoys me because it seems like very lazy songwriting; repetitive lyrics and melody. The other fact is that it is just too darn long. I also feel like the whole group was bored while performing it (i.e. lack of energy on the track)

[instantdeath999]

incredibly repetitive.....

I actually think the song is very varied, with the exception of the last minute or so.

[Parodygm]

I absolutely love the song, but it's not exactly lightning in a bottle for a rhythm game. I'm more than happy to play it any time it's selected myself though. Even on vocals... it gives me more excuse to hum the guitar parts, close my eyes and wobble around like an idiot.

[Emalythe]

I love the Santana-esque sound of the song, and I always have - but as a vocalist, it isn't the most interesting song on the disk to play. Still, I don't quit when someone picks it (I just take a break for the second half).

[TheBeatleHead]

To me, it goes into the "Epic 7+ minute songs with an awesome instrumental ending" list.

It's epic. However, I do agree that it's annoying to listen to the instrumental EVERY TIME. I normally skip it when I'm listening to Abbey Road when it starts the instrumental, because I want to get to the medley quickly. =3

[soup567]

I love I Want You (She's so Heavy). its awesome to play. i love playing long songs

[gershwin_27]

Today I played a very long sessions of online TBRB, with me on drums. I had a few very good sessions with four players, one that lasted well over an hour. I finally decide to pick I Want You (She's so Heavy)... and everyone leaves. That definitely doesn't seem very "sportsman" like, considering everyone gets a turn to pick a song.

Just a little rant, I just have no idea why this song seems to be so disliked. Almost the Visions of TBRB.

I'm very surprised that it took well over an hour for your group to pick I Want You (She's So Heavy).

I don't hate the song, but it's not my favorite. And although it might be my least favorite in the game, I still think it's a great song.

I've never quit because I didn't like the song that was chosen, but I do let out a sigh of disappointment to myself when someone chooses this paticular song.

The reason being, from my experience, it seems to be chosen more often than any other song. Which is why I am surprised by your experience.

Perhaps the three you were hooked up with have found the same thing to be true, and they are tired of having it chosen?

[RampantFrenzy]

people are in general.. pretty ignorant...

is the first thing that comes to mind....


I must admit tho.. I have not encountered this

[Always down to play bass]

I love it. Its a BLAST on drums

[mobhit101]

It really is a fantastic song, but it's just one of the many that should have been included with the upcoming album DLC rather on disc ::cough:: Octopus's Garden :: cough::