Tried it after reading this thread, got it first try.
Nowhere near as annoying as nailing all that crap on Dig a Pony. Well, not crap, but definitely not my preferred way to play some parts.
Also, I have butter cookies!
I've been playing since GHII, so I didn't have too much of a problem (I believe I got it my first time)... however, I totally feel your pain, because I have the same thing with the Helter Skelter drum achievement. I always get it, either screwing up near the middle or with the drum rolls at the end. I have never played it 15 times in a row, but I just might one of these days.
3 Harmonies (All The Children Sing) Achievement.
Pink Floyd Wishlist : http://www.rockband.com/forums/showthread.php?t=196856
I was under the impression that this was virtually impossible but apparently not, as the majority of posters here have done it without too much hassle it seems. I remember playing it online and the bass player got 100% which left me stunned. I've tried this about 8 or 9 times now and the best I can do is 94%.
To all the people that did it on their first try! **Pulls out rifle** I will chase you!
**Starts shooting to the people that thought that it would be safe to stay close** It's only the beginning.
Anyway, for me the hardest trophies are of the harmonies.
Ughh like I already got all the 350 note streak trophies, and emlmore james trophy. But I CANNOT get the full 100% on this -.- i've played it over 100 times yesterday, over and over nearly killing myself.
Your day breaks, your mind aches, You find that all her words of kindness linger on , When she no longer needs you...
Like most people, I got "I'll Never Dance with Another" quite easily (think it was my third try, but to be fair, my first try was in public and I almost got it there too). Like a couple of other people here "Pick a Moon Dog" took me FOREVER. I swear I played that song 20 times in a row before I finally got it (I think one of those times I choked on the outro trill, which I almost never miss).
Member of the Jerkfaces Who Got RB3 Early Club
Do any of you up strum on bass?
Its a lot harder doing it that way
Happiness... Is a Warm Gun