I expected that there would be people out there that would be great at charting and would certainly keep the HMX standard in that department.
My problem lies in the genre area. I see a lot of Rock/Rock or Alternative/Alternative or Metal/Metal flying around and while those tags can be understandable for their bands... when you have access to all of these subgenres, why not use them?
Also, one genre in particular I see being avoided is Emo. Certainly based on what HMX has established as the "Emo" genre for Rock Band, there are a TON of bands floating around in playtesting that could go into this genre but yet I think only one or two have used it.
Nu-Metal is usually avoided in favor of Metal/Alternative as well, which is technically okay but it will look very strange to have bands like Seether floating around in the Metal section.
I understand genres are all a matter of opinion, but when people are going to be able to search for tracks by genre I think it's important to be as specific as possible...