"Never Let You Go" guitar chart

[vedis]

No it isn't.

If GH charted this song there'll be 200 more notes because they always overchart. When you start charting string noise, amp feedback, etc. which aren't even real notes, you are overcharting. This chart is fine.

your trying to reason with someone who supports GH and is a scorehero fanatic, its not happening

dont forget, those types usualy want a song as hard as possible, and with as much scoring available as possible so that they can show off their high scores like it means something

[toymachineSH]

The song doesn't need to be "omg hard" but to say the way it's charted isn't odd is just plain denial :P

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jUk82Lghi4 - string muting etc

It's cool though I understand you'd never want to admit a Rock Band chart is incorrect.

[JoshVanHalen87]

hehe, nice to see they charted the song accurately, thats why i stopped playing the gh series, they overchart the hell out of any song.

[Mega-Tallica]

Yeah how dare a guitar chart simulate actually playing the song!

Why don't you take a look at some of the RB2 charts that do exactly what you accuse Guitar Hero of doing in such a douchebag QED fashion.

String noise and feedback is not playing and therefore should be charted. Get that through your thick skull.

The song doesn't need to be "omg hard" but to say the way it's charted isn't odd is just plain denial :P

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jUk82Lghi4 - string muting etc

It's cool though I understand you'd never want to admit a Rock Band chart is incorrect.

Covers =/= Original recording

Especially an acoustic version of a non-acoustic song.

And I will admit there are few RB songs that are inaccurately charted, but that number doesn't even touch the surface on how many inaccurately charted GH songs there are. 90% of GH's charts are overcharted.

[toymachineSH]

String noise and feedback is not playing and therefore should be charted. Get that through your thick skull.
.

Ramblin' Man and Lazy Eye are both guilty of what you complain about and I doubt you even batted an eyelash at it.

And I will admit there are few RB songs that are inaccurately charted, but that number doesn't even touch the surface on how many inaccurately charted GH songs there are. 90% of GH's charts are overcharted

rofl 90%

[Mega-Tallica]

Ramblin' Man and Lazy Eye are both guilty of what you complain about and I doubt you even batted an eyelash at it.


rofl 90%

There's a difference between string muting and string noise. String muting is you are hitting the string to create the desired muting effect. Therefore, both those charts are accurate. String noise is the sliding sound you get when your fingers slide on the strings when changing from chord to chord. This sound is usually edited out when recording, but if it does get in the final recording it is usually by accident. String noise is very rarely wanted and is usually caused by accident, therefore, string noise should not be charted.

And yes, every GH song with a solo is overcharted. So, that number is around 90% possibly even more.

[toymachineSH]

So does that mean that every RB song with a solo is undercharted?

[FrankieB]

lol How any of you could claim that 5 plastic buttons could be accurate to a real instrument is comical. Your fanboyism is shining as bright as the sun.

[Mega-Tallica]

Yeah, to the person who is so used to GH's overcharted charts that they think RB charts are too easy and therefore undercharted.

That person is you.

[Mega-Tallica]

lol How any of you could claim that 5 plastic buttons could be accurate to a real instrument is comical. Your fanboyism is shining as bright as the sun.

You act like your argument has never been stated before.

No **** I'm going to support any argument against RB in RB's favor since you know, you are on RB's official forums.