2 questions about the animation

[imagirl]

ok
on the animation
are they playing the right guitar notes?
like do they have correct finger postion?
i play real guitar but not that much
so i wouldnt of known
also
when Paul play bass
on the animation
he always strums down
dosent he sometimes strum up?
like how bass players do?

[robbiecon]

I'm pretty sure the animation is quite accurate for guitar chords, notes, etc.

As for Paul strumming down on the bass I can't confirm if that's what he did or not.

[Tego1in]

Paul has that signature way of strumming down with his wrist.
But heres some alt-strumming Paul : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Imb4tYOk8GE

[robbiecon]

I guess it's all a question of how someone is really comfortable playing, like personally I can't use a pick at all playing guitar so I just play with just fingers 99% of the time.

[BoomBoomBox]

I have a guitar playing friend who learnt the chorus to Come Together by copying what George does in the game, so I'm assuming from that that the game's pretty accurate when it comes to the finger movements on guitar chords.

And as for Paul, he did tend to use his fingers for up-strumming during slow songs, but he generally strummed down with his wrist, as the dude above me pointed out.

[joekooll]

Also
I think this is the ONLY music video game
That does guitar chords and drum beats correctly on animation

[robbiecon]

Also
I think this is the ONLY music video game
That does guitar chords and drum beats correctly on animation

I'm pretty sure that's right. They have a general idea of chord positions, but do not go to as much bother as was done for this.

[SirDavidTLynch]

Also
I think this is the ONLY music video game
That does guitar chords and drum beats correctly on animation

Rock Band 1 and 2
Generally get drums right
Guitar looks okay.

[robbiecon]

I don't even think LRB is right for which button is pressed. Lol. But decentish game nonetheless.

[BeatlesFan88]

Paul has that signature way of strumming down with his wrist.
But heres some alt-strumming Paul : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Imb4tYOk8GE

Was this actually live? and was it the only live concert after they stopped doing concerts? (besides roof top)