HEAVY RAIN or ALAN WAKE?

[ledbowman]

I'm considering getting one of these, but I can't decide which one. I'm leaning a little more toward HR as it seems fresher gameplay-wise and I'd probably appreciate the branching story concept, but AW seems relatively intriguing too. Anyone have an opinon?

[Fizzeler]

Alan Wake, better gameplay

or you could say heck to both and get Mass Effect 1+2

[AKGAMER]

Heaavy Raaain hawwwmie.

[ledbowman]

or you could say heck to both and get Mass Effect 1+2

I have both of those, though I haven't played either of them yet (my little brother bought the first about a year ago and I bought him the second one less than a week ago and he hasn't been able to play it yet for lack of HDD space for the install).

[instantdeath999]

Though of course Deadly Premonition is better than either of them and only $20 too. Isn't that right Zach!?

I'm actually one of the 7 individuals who bought Deadly Premonition and thoroughly enjoyed it, but I can't agree that it's a better horror game than Alan Wake. For the first time in years, Alan Wake totally nailed the atmosphere and progression needed for a horror game. I kinda liked the sim aspects in Deadly Premonition though.

Really can't say enough good things about Alan Wake. Buy it.

[CommonCriminal]

Heavy Rain
Alan Wake

[jonoo24]

Deadly premonition is NOT a horror game, it's a comedy.

Play ME1 and 2. Then Alan wake.

[instantdeath999]

Deadly premonition is NOT a horror game, it's a comedy.

Play ME1 and 2. Then Alan wake.

But terrible voice acting is a sacred past time in survival horror games, and Deadly Premonition nailed that aspect

[JoshVanHalen87]

Alan Wake over Heavy rain. but if you could get both of them would be great too.

[Buffdog18]

Alan Wake, good day.