Metallica mafia

[nickbrownsfan]

I doubt it's a mafia role. It would give them an unfair numerical advantage, especially if it could be done more than once.

I agree as well. The zombie role fits the best.
Vampire would have been a worthless town role. Which doc isnt.
In the beatles we had 5 mafia. With 19 people I can see the 4 mafia start then a zombie. It really adds to the game if you think about it.
However I really have no clue on that. It guess we will know when the game gets closer to end game.

[robbiecon]

@Riles, I've nothing against Banky, but I wouldn't personally have chosen him to be the one revived as mafia, I'd have gone for someone more experienced, like nick or YOU. Although he is the master of confusion, his vote for soup out of nowhere makes no sense.

Also, nothing was said about the SK not sending in a kill. And the update clearly talks about someone trying to attack one of the group. It sounds like SK territory. And the group is surely the mafia. so whoever the SK is clearly targeted mafia.

[robbiecon]

Actually looking at the other dead I'd have thought that if it's a mafia ability they'd have chosen Wave57, he did a good job as SK in the Beatles. And is the only one with some credentials and real experience.

But here's another theory, Banky himself was revived as a Jesus style role. However he's now independent. His role now is to survive the game. Possibly even has to have certain people lynched, hence the vote on soup.

[nickbrownsfan]

I just explained that they would have been caught red-handed as all four mafia members if they all voted for me at once, me turn up town, and the other three members be confirmed town. This is now the third time I've said this

As for today, it's possible that hiimSMAP was part of the mafia and tried to start a mob on me, which got to five votes. But once your vote was taken away, he took his away to look less suspicious. He wouldn't want to be the only member who's not confirmed mafia (aside from Kbeatle). I'm not sure about him. You may be correct in your assumption about him, but all I know is, you have to go first before we can get any mafia



Well...do you think it's possible that the game started out with three mafia members? Then they were allowed to bring from the dead to be a mafia member? That wouldn't be an unfair numerical advantage. Suddenly, two of Nick's suspicions are starting to make more sense...



Well which action did you use? Did anything happen? Something has to explain why the SK didn't send in a kill

You can say it as many times as you like, if you were town they would lynch you. It would kill a town, they would kill a town at night. Then start to look at the town that voted you. Esp with hans already saying he would vote himself.
They would call out soup on their coming forward with your lies.
No, it only adds up 1 way.

If you were town you would be lynched.
If you were mafia you wouldnt be lynched.

They would move in slowly. casting a vote here and there, acting townish. Not what has happed. The facts are right there. They are not voting and have given themselves by not voting.
Its the classic way we find mafia. Watch the votes.

Most of the votes on you yesterday are the same votes on you today.
Your telling me that for 2 straight days the mafia refuses to vote you because your town instead of mafia?

[HeyRiles]

Yes, exactly. In fact, hiimSMAP (whom you believe to be mafia) DID have a vote on me the day before. If he is mafia, then there would only be THREE mafia members left to vote me, no? Last I checked, three is less than four

There are plenty of ways how this could add up. The way I have mentioned countless times before that's just as legitimate as what you're saying, or what I said just now. You realize hiimSMAP or Kbeatle could be mafia as well, which would make three mafia members left to lynch, which is less than four. Or did you fail remedial math?

You're pushing so hard for one theory that you've completely blocked out any other possible explanation, and it's sending you to your downfall. Smarten up, Nick

Also you still haven't told people to lynch yourself to prove that I'm mafia weird, eh?

[KBeatle96]

Here is what I think the possible outcomes today are.
We lynch Riles, he is mafia, Nick could still be SK, but chances are slim to nil.
We lynch Riles, he is town, Nick is in a heap of trouble.
We lynch Nick, he is SK, Riles could still be mafia, but chances are slim to nil.
We lynch Nick, he is town, Riles is in a heap of trouble.
We lynch Riles, he is mafia, Nick is SK.
We lynch Riles, he is town, Nick is town
We lynch Nick, Nick is town, Riles is town
We lynch Nick, Nick is town, Riles is mafia

There are just so many outcomes and different possibilities.

[Hansanator]

Here is what I think the possible outcomes today are.
We lynch Riles, he is mafia, Nick could still be SK, but chances are slim to nil.
We lynch Riles, he is town, Nick is in a heap of trouble.
We lynch Nick, he is SK, Riles could still be mafia, but chances are slim to nil.
We lynch Nick, he is town, Riles is in a heap of trouble.
We lynch Riles, he is mafia, Nick is SK.
We lynch Riles, he is town, Nick is town
We lynch Nick, Nick is town, Riles is town
We lynch Nick, Nick is town, Riles is mafia
Hananator Saves the Day!!!!!

There are just so many outcomes and different possibilities.

There was one outcome that you forgot.

[HeyRiles]

Somebody back up and restate everything or bring something new to the table, because Nick and I have just been saying the same things over and over again for the past 20 hours and it's getting frustrating that nothing's happening

[nickbrownsfan]

Yes, exactly. In fact, hiimSMAP (whom you believe to be mafia) DID have a vote on me the day before. If he is mafia, then there would only be THREE mafia members left to vote me, no? Last I checked, three is less than four

There are plenty of ways how this could add up. The way I have mentioned countless times before that's just as legitimate as what you're saying, or what I said just now. You realize hiimSMAP or Kbeatle could be mafia as well, which would make three mafia members left to lynch, which is less than four. Or did you fail remedial math?

You're pushing so hard for one theory that you've completely blocked out any other possible explanation, and it's sending you to your downfall. Smarten up, Nick

Also you still haven't told people to lynch yourself to prove that I'm mafia weird, eh?

Today Smap dropped a vote on you early. Then when it got to about 4 votes backed off. Typical mafia style. We did that in the beatles mafia all the time.

Explain to me how you can have probably 5 town votes against you and 2 mafia wouldnt have voted for you?
Explain to me how you can have 3 known town voting for you yet the mafia wouldnt be jumping the bandwagon?
You cant because they wont vote a mafia off.

Your mafia and Im guessing everyone reading this knows it.
Your mafia freinds are in the list of non-voters.
Anyone with an ounce of game experience knows this.

Mafia list
HeyRiles
FatalFriend
HiimSmap
Ultimatespidey or SacredYuju possible both..
Robbie is moving up on my town list alot today.

[Hansanator]

Somebody back up and restate everything or bring something new to the table, because Nick and I have just been saying the same things over and over again for the past 20 hours and it's getting frustrating that nothing's happening

lol it has been pretty funny watching you guys say the some thing.

P.S. HeyRiles? Do you think you could vote yourself to help us out a little bit?