RB3 Request a Feature, Bug Report and Suggestion Thread (no song requests)

[lvmathemagician]

Date sorting works great on the PS3.

[raynebc]

Date sorting works great on the PS3.

Rub it in why don't you. It's almost worthless on Xbox. It's just about good enough to bump all the stuff you just barely bought to the top of the list, and everything else lumped in the same group sorted by alphabetical order.

[TheHundredDollarHeadache]

People like the feature, I get it. But for the love of god what's the next step? No-rytyhm, mono-color mode? "Hey at least you're trying! *X 10000 multiplier*"

That reminds me - Super Easy should be brought back from Lego.

But as I said earlier, the tour I want to see would make it possible to crash and burn in the beginning - like the majority of real bands, and it would turn off no-fail.

Once you are big enough, you'd be able to turn no-fail on, but then you'd be scored by stars, and a 3-star would be a fail.

Oh yeah, suggestion, Dance Central 2 costumes and/or Guest Characters in the next game please. Hopefully the two design teams don't have beef and can make this happen. Otherwise they can settle it with a danceoff, and make it happen.

Dance Central seems like a good source for more "street" clothes. That, and the bodies were so much more realistic.

As for the dance-off, I would gladly pay to see the Rock Band 3 Session Musicians tear themselves apart trying to move like Dance Central characters.

[mikeyts]

They didn't just make no-fail the default--they made failing faster. If you start screwing up the crowd meter drops like a rock and you're out of there in the blink of an eye. It's the only reason I turned no-fail on.

[TheHundredDollarHeadache]

They didn't just make no-fail the default--they made failing faster. If you start screwing up the crowd meter drops like a rock and you're out of there in the blink of an eye. It's the only reason I turned no-fail on.

They made mistakes hurt more because they thought that solo unison bonuses would make up for it.

One mistake is enough of a blow to your crowd meter that when you get back up, the crowd will cheer again as you topped the meter. It's almost like they cheered for the mistake, not for the recovery.


And, applying this to your idea of a tour, I'm repeating what I said in post 3670.

I would make it really tough to break out of your hometown. Too many fail-outs in this stage and your band gets the Bad Ending: run out of your hometown. Mistake penalty on the crowd meter would be RB3 level, and you would start in the middle of the crowd meter instead of in the green. Attempt to play a bigger venue (maybe opening for a touring band) in this early stage and you will start in the red. When you get the van, you will start in the green. Once you get the Roadies in the tour, the mistake penalty on the crowd meter will lessen, to RB2 levels.

There is no penalty for playing lower difficulties until you get big, so if you fail out early on, it will encourage you to step down, and step back up when you progress in the tour. And instead of a hard fan cap, you will get a soft fan cap - a multiplier less than one for your fan and cred gain.

[lvmathemagician]

Rub it in why don't you. It's almost worthless on Xbox. It's just about good enough to bump all the stuff you just barely bought to the top of the list, and everything else lumped in the same group sorted by alphabetical order.

I rub it in because it's all we've got.

[lvmathemagician]

That reminds me - Super Easy should be brought back from Lego.

That and the optional bass drum. My wife has (hopefully) temporarily lost the use of her legs and would like to play drums.

[lvmathemagician]

I would make it really tough to break out of your hometown. Too many fail-outs in this stage and your band gets the Bad Ending: run out of your hometown.

Really, bands get run out of your hometown? It's never happened where I live. The worst that happens, is the band just modifies it's lineup. Negative endings like this will not sell more games.

[TheHundredDollarHeadache]

Really, bands get run out of your hometown? It's never happened where I live. The worst that happens, is the band just modifies it's lineup. Negative endings like this will not sell more games.

One of the T-shirts in Rock Band 2 (that got lost in the transition to Rock Band 3) was for a fictional band called Krieg (the title said Kreig but the shirt said Krieg). The description said that Krieg was run out of their hometown before bringing sludgecore to the masses.

Okay, how about this for a less negative ending: The band gets a nasty review saying "Stick to Rock Band!", calls it quits, and then go out to the store and pick up a bunch of instruments - the singer gets the Logitech mic, the guitarist gets the Squier and Mustang Pro Guitars, the bassist picks up the basic Strat and P-Bass controllers, the keyboardist gets the keyboard with the stand, and the drummer gets the ION Drum Rocker with all the cymbals. They then gather around the TV playing Rock Band happily, get a great score on all-Pro, and then decide they won't let another bad review get them this down. The career then restarts. You can't get this ending again afterwards.

This unlocks game controllers as available instruments for your characters, the alternative method being just playing once in Pro Mode (Harmonies) to get the associated controllers.

[SirDavidTLynch]

They made mistakes hurt more because they thought that solo unison bonuses would make up for it.

I've heard that, but I'm not sure I buy it. That wouldn't explain why they did that for vocals, or didn't adjust the star cutoffs.