I personally think it's a fantastic list.
"My name is Giovanni Giorgio but everybody calls me...Giorgio.
Uncharted 2. Good game, but I doubt I'll feel any strong desire to play it again, so it's going up on Half.com.
Glad Castle Crashers, KH2, Melee, TF2, Advance Wars, Earthbound, Rock Band 3, Silent Hill 2, Left 4 Dead 2, Twilight Princess, Super Mario 64, Pokemon B/W, Super Mario Galaxy 2, Bioshock, Windwaker, Super Mario Bros 3, and Portal are on there.
But the order of those games is kinda weird in my books (How is Black and White there when Platinum was the best Pokemon game?!?). Here's how I would order those games myself from best to less best:
Super Smash Bros Melee (favorite game of all time)
Kingdom Hearts 2
Silent Hill 2
Rock Band 3
Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Team Fortress 2
Left 4 Dead 2
Super Mario 64
Super Mario Bros 3
That's not a representation of my favorite games of all time, just those that I'm pleased to see in the list in the order of my preference towards them.
My tumblr page, yo: http://heyitsmario.tumblr.com/
To me, they got it right putting GTA IV ahead of San Andreas. I would have put III or Vice City on the list instead of San Andreas.