GandWuser's Tiering Thread

[GandWuser]

Thanks for tiering Animate but it feels Overtiered. You put bass as impossible when I'd have put it as a 4 or 5 since it's generally just same fret with little neck movement but it is quite fast. And keys as impossible? I don't remember keys so I shall have to relisten to it.

Ok admittedly I think I may have overtiered it too. I think some time I am just going to go through a bunch of older tiers (Happy Little Boozer's vocals, Bite the Finger's and Out on the Town's wrong harmonies, that Fadades song's drums, most of Gangnam Style, Animate, Pressure's pro guitar, Siberian Khatru, a typo on Long Cool Woman, the artist on RED ZONE, You Spin Me's keys, etc.) I don't necessarily agree with and fix them sometime though.

[KingsDimension]

Between the Buried and Me- Silent Fight Parliament

I couldn't find a real link, so here's a drum cover.

[Gamer1270]

Dethklok- Killstardo Abominate

[Anaconda]

Hey, thx for tiering Beneath The Violence.
I'm kinda suprised for how high the tiers are (except guitar, it got really fast sweeps on solo), but they feel right after a brief moment of thinking it over.
Although I'm almost 100% sure Harmonix would tier vocals much lower, it's sang with pretty high pitched voice, but hey, look what tier got Devil's Child by Judas Priest? Tier 2? On song considered one of hardest to sing properly from Screaming from Vengeance album(apart from title track)?
I still can't understand that.

So let's move on to another one:
Judas Priest - Beyond The Realms of Death

Sorry if you don't enjoy Judas Priest/Rob Halford involved/Dio songs.
If you say so I will stop coming back with them

[GandWuser]

OK, starting tonight's update. Also will rethink Animate.

EDIT: After rethinking Animate, I think it seems like I would not change it, or at least not much. The bass sounds pretty difficult to pull of, and the keys sound like a bunch of fast crescendos.

[jibjqrkl]

Toxik - WIr NJn8/In God

[TheBonobo4]

OK, starting tonight's update. Also will rethink Animate.

EDIT: After rethinking Animate, I think it seems like I would not change it, or at least not much. The bass sounds pretty difficult to pull of, and the keys sound like a bunch of fast crescendos.

If it helps, here's a custom video showing a FB track of the song. If I were tiering it based on thisand listening to it, I'd put Bass as 5 on Regular (since it's very fast, it's like Roxette's The Look), and 5 or Impossible on Pro, but purely due to speed and endurance, plus I imagine the changeovers being tough, like at the line "spirit in my psyche..." and so on. But keys is not Impossible. Unless he seriously undercharted, it's a 2 at most. The rest I agree with. 5 for Drums and Guitar and 4 on Vocals.



But it's your choice.

[GandWuser]

If it helps, here's a custom video showing a FB track of the song. If I were tiering it based on thisand listening to it, I'd put Bass as 5 on Regular (since it's very fast, it's like Roxette's The Look), and 5 or Impossible on Pro, but purely due to speed and endurance, plus I imagine the changeovers being tough, like at the line "spirit in my psyche..." and so on. But keys is not Impossible. Unless he seriously undercharted, it's a 2 at most. The rest I agree with. 5 for Drums and Guitar and 4 on Vocals.



But it's your choice.

Actually, I think I will take your suggestions.

Also, it's a great song, I agree.

[TheBonobo4]

Really? Huh. Wasn't expecting that. Though I do recommend you watch the charts on that video, since they allowed me to visualise unheard notes as well as potential difficulties.

[GandWuser]

Really? Huh. Wasn't expecting that. Though I do recommend you watch the charts on that video, since they allowed me to visualise unheard notes as well as potential difficulties.

You seem to have forgotten the link to the vid. Think I found it though.