GandWuser's Tiering Thread

[GandWuser]

And finished.

NOTES: Papa Was A Rodeo was a really hard song to accurately tier, considering the obscene amount of instruments used on the album in total. I'm not even sure if there is a thing that could be charted to bass. But nevertheless, there is a tier for it. Also, all the dots on Wild Honey Pie's Guitar belong to the solo.

SCHEDULE UPDATE:

FRIDAY:

Flamenco Sketches
The Hustle
My Little Pony Meets Metal
A Rite Of Passage
Self-Starter
(This should be an interesting update, with Jazz, something Funky, a metal cover of a cartoon theme, some Christian alternative, and prog metal)

SUNDAY:

Babs Seed
Ruled By Secrecy
So So Fresh
Under A Glass Moon

[SheSaidSheSaid]

Nice, I was pretty sure I heard keys in the "All Downhill From Here" chorus, but I wasn't sure you'd put them in. Or is that for the chimes?

Next song I'd like to submit is Question! by System of a Down. I wrote up tiers for it myself once. I'm curious if you'd give it the same that I did.

[hiimSMAP]

Oceanographer's Choice- The Mountain Goats

[SheSaidSheSaid]

Which version of "Let it Be" did you tier? There are several different versions.

[GandWuser]

Which version of "Let it Be" did you tier? There are several different versions.

I listened to the album cut first, then I realized the single version was different and listened to that (its the one I'm used to hearing more). So consider it a half-way of a sort.

[Radiohead97]

Next Song:
"Edge of the Blade" - Journey

[SheSaidSheSaid]

And then there's also the Let it Be.... Naked version. I thought there was yet a fourth version, but I think I was confusing it with "Across the Universe"

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Are you sure there's no keys in Wild Honey Pie? I thought I heard something that sounds like keys inbetween every guitar strum or two. It sounds kinda wobbly/bouncy.

EDIT: Next request is "Nobody Told You to Cry" by Solitary Confinement. Appears on his 2012 EP "Wall of Blindness". Cover art here.

If you didn't know, this is SoConfined's, a user here that had a tier thread once, band project. I got Bonobo to tier his other three songs that are released so far.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Well, would ya look at that! Yet another tier from this thread, "She Talks to Angels", getting released next week!

[TheBonobo4]

You are one forth correct. I'm going to give clues based on genres.

Day 1: Black Sabbath (heavy metal, already confirmed)
Day 2: BNWOHM
Day 3: Viking/Black Metal
Day 4: Goth
Day 5: Hard Rock/Heavy Metal
Day 6: Symphonic/Power
Day 7: Doom
Day 8: Unclassifiable?
Day 9: Hair
Day 10: Thrash
Day 11: Power
Day 12: Southern

And that's all can say.

My guesses, based upon no logic whatsoever. (You'll see a pattern):
Day 2 - Iron Maiden
Day 3 - No Idea
Day 4 - No Idea
Day 5 - Led Zeppelin?
Day 6 - No Idea
Day 7 - Candlemass/Witch Hunter General?
Day 8 - No Idea
Day 9 - Crazy Hair Band
Day 10 - I hope it's Megadeth, but could be any of the Big 4.
Day 11 - Dragonforce
Day 12 - Allman brothers Band or Lynyrd Skynyrd