GandWuser's Tiering Thread

[sonicnerd23]

Thank you, next track off of Marquee Moon is "Venus" (track 02 of 08).

[firedoom666]

thanks again!

Arjen Anthony Lucassen - "When I'm a Hundred Sixty-Four"

[GandWuser]

Done.

FRIDAY:

Down By The River
Heaven
Magic
Pity For A Dime
Valley Girl

SUNDAY:

Venus
When I'm a Hundred Sixty-Four

NOTES: Mr. Krinkle uses a string bass instead of a bass guitar. It is charted to Bass, not Keys. Blackout has really fast notes that make the song devil-tiered. Mudshuvel has a weird Pro part.

But most notably, Genius. After finishing my tier, I decided to look at yours, MCS. And hoo boy, what a difference. This makes me kind of unsure on who's right. This is yours. This is mine. I know you said you had trouble distinguishing parts, but I can't tell if I severely undertiered everything or you severely overtiered everything. Anyone want to give feedback on this?

[Pescaran Death Machine]

The Beatles -- I Want To Hold Your Hand(RB3 Version)

[Mileycyrussoulja]

But most notably, Genius. After finishing my tier, I decided to look at yours, MCS. And hoo boy, what a difference. This makes me kind of unsure on who's right. This is yours. This is mine. I know you said you had trouble distinguishing parts, but I can't tell if I severely undertiered everything or you severely overtiered everything. Anyone want to give feedback on this?

That's...really interesting. It all sounds really complicated and jumbled, and I figured drums and bass would be really difficult, because of bass's rapid strumming, and how the drums abruptly stop at some points. It would be better if some other people chipped in feedback.

[jibjqrkl]

But most notably, Genius. After finishing my tier, I decided to look at yours, MCS. And hoo boy, what a difference. This makes me kind of unsure on who's right. This is yours. This is mine. I know you said you had trouble distinguishing parts, but I can't tell if I severely undertiered everything or you severely overtiered everything. Anyone want to give feedback on this?

i'd go with yours, IMO drums should actually probably only be a 3. but in no way would that or bass be devils.

bass seems like an annoying fast rhythm, but nowhere near fast enough to go above 4.

[GandWuser]

Ok now that that's settled, another question:

Why am I like the only tierer that gets brony requests? Is there some kind if pony magic eminating from me or something?

[firedoom666]

Ok now that that's settled, another question:

Why am I like the only tierer that gets brony requests? Is there some kind if pony magic eminating from me or something?

well I only stick to one Tiering Thread so when I want to request a brony song I go to you... can't claim why other people do it

[GandWuser]

well I only stick to one Tiering Thread so when I want to request a brony song I go to you... can't claim why other people do it

Fair enough.

[wheatsquares33]

You're the only tiering thread I use, because you still use the old format, not the tier machine. (Nothing against those, it's just that I can do those myself. I'll end up using it when I finally get my thread up and running, which may take awhile because I have a good 200 songs left to tier before I post it.)

Loyalty looks great, by the way.

Inhaler- Foals