TheBonobo4's Tiering Thread

[Metalhead911]

This is a live version, and instrumental. I will listen to it, but I'm guessing it'll just end up being Impossible (Devils) on everything except Vocals? Am I right?


Also, I take it it's live at Fillmore East, 1971? And the album was released in 1972.

It is an instrumental. And it will definitely be devils on drums due to the LOOOOONG drum solo in the middle. Also, the rest of the instuments could be 5's or devils as there are plenty of slow and fast parts.

As for where it was recorded, it was recorded during the same concerts that would make up the 1971 album "Live At Fillmore East," but since they already had enough songs to make that a full double album, it would have to have been a triple vinyl to fit Mountain Jam on it, which wasn't going to happen, but it was too good of a performance to simply throw away. So, it was placed on their 1972 (otherwise) studio album "Eat A Peach," which made that release a double album.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Now for an interesting tier:

Whose Line Is It Anyway? Cast - "Howard"

This is from the comedy show "Whose Line Is It Anyway?". Good luck. I skipped you to the part where the song starts. The song ends at 2:57.

[TheBonobo4]

Now for an interesting tier:

Whose Line Is It Anyway? Cast - "Howard"

This is from the comedy show "Whose Line Is It Anyway?". Good luck. I skipped you to the part where the song starts. The song ends at 2:57.

What is this?! This isn't a song! How am I meant to tier this? It's just keys and Vocals, with no Harmonies?!

Do I count clapping and hitting legs as drums?

[sonicnerd23]

Alright, thank you for the re-tier. Next request is "Papercut" by Linkin Park.

[TheBonobo4]

What is this?! This isn't a song! How am I meant to tier this? It's just keys and Vocals, with no Harmonies?!

Do I count clapping and hitting legs as drums?

And what do I put as genre, year and album/artist?

[Mileycyrussoulja]

What is this?! This isn't a song! How am I meant to tier this? It's just keys and Vocals, with no Harmonies?!

Do I count clapping and hitting legs as drums?

What are you talking about? There is harmonies (the other guys saying "Hey! Hey! Hey!" and Ryan says "Horward" after the tempo speeds up) and there's digital drums programmed into Laura Hall's keyboard...

Also, find the year the episode aired and use that as the year. For the album, just put Whose Line is it Anyway? and use the show's logo. Genre is Novelty.

And I already said Whose Line Is it Anyway? Cast is the artist. Lrn2read.

[TheBonobo4]

Of course. Don't be mad now.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

I only acted mad because

1. You completely ignored what I said to put for artist when I first said it
2. You're acting like there's no drums in the song when there clearly is digital programmed drums in Laura Hall's keyboard

But I digress. Tier it when you're ready.

[TheBonobo4]

Tonight's update is done (sorry for only 2 songs, Art of Life is rather long):
Art of Life - X Japan
Howard - Whose Line is it Anyway?


Tomorrow will hopefully be:
Dream Theater - Pull Me Under
The Allman Brothers Band - Mountain Jam (Live at Fillmore East, 1971)
Sonseed - Jesus Is My Friend

[Mileycyrussoulja]

You forgot to tier bass on Howard. Listen to it again, it's there, also programmed into the keyboard, like the drums.

Also, I think drums should be bumped up a dot or two since the tempo suddenly changes in the middle of the song. And keys should probably be devils because of that too.