TheBonobo4's Tiering Thread

[TheBonobo4]

Starting on Tonight's update. Yeah, the entirety of The Whirlwind. At 2 o'clock in the morning, how bad can that end up?

[Mileycyrussoulja]

I'll inspect the Last Christmas tier this weekend. For now:

Brenda Lee - "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree"

[TheBonobo4]

Okay I've now done the first 3 of 12 parts of The Whirlwind. A few things I need to say:

1. I'm glad I did it this way. This song, being 78 minutes long, would be impossible and unfair to give it one tier. It deserves all of the 13 I'll give it.

2. It's absolutely epic. One of the best songs I've ever heard. Not sure I get the meaning, I can't think rationally at 2AM, but it is awesome. Thanks jibs. You couldn't have much done better than this!

3. The tiers may be wrong in places, but this is a very difficult song, with all instruments as well (Keys and Harmonies too). So the tiers I feel are justified.

4. I hope you enjoy the finished product, (when it is finished that is). This is easily the most effort I've put into one song for tiering, ever. Or likely will do for that matter, unless I get a song longer than this one with more movements.

5. I'm very tired, but I'm getting this done for you. And because I like the song. Not sure if I'll finish it tonight, but I'll try!

[TheBonobo4]

Okay I know I said I'd do it all tonight, but I'm really sorry, it's 3AM here right now and I'm stopping for the night. In my defence I did do 4 of the 12 parts and 29 minutes worth of it, with 4 individual tiers, all in 1 hour. Not bad.

[TheBonobo4]

Sorry no update tonight, I'm going out this evening and won't be available for tiering. Tomorrow will either be more of The Whirlwind, nothing or:
Fadadès - BlackWhite
"Miss America" by Styx
"Airbag" - Radiohead
Brenda Lee - "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree" (only if Fadades breaks the Death Metal rule)

[GandWuser]

Hey look, we're getting a song you tiered! (Possum Kingdom)

Now to see if you can stand up to the test...

[TheBonobo4]

Hey look, we're getting a song you tiered! (Possum Kingdom)

Now to see if you can stand up to the test...

I thought this would happen. It's a scary moment. I hope I got it reasonably accurate.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Welp, I'm checking out that Last Christmas tier. Everything looks okay, but where did you hear guitar in it? If it's a one dot, it should be pretty audible, but I don't hear any really.

[TheBonobo4]

okay since I can't finish The Whirlwind tonight, I'll do these instead:
Fadadès - BlackWhite (possibly Death Metal)
"Miss America" by Styx
"Airbag" - Radiohead


I'll do Rockin' Around The Christmas Tree tomorrow, so if Fadades breaks the Death Metal rule then only 2 songs tonight.


As for Last Christmas, I'll keep it as it is, but I must have put Guitar in by accident, or I thought I heard it, anyway I'll fix that as well tonight.

[TheBonobo4]

Just finished Fadades. To be honest, whilst it doesn't break the Death Metal rule, the Vocals are messed up. And I was disappointed. I thought it'd be Comedy Metal, but I actually didn't like the song. Perhaps because I can't speak French, I don't know. Also, it was very odd to tier.


So, in short, whilst it technically breaks no rules, I'd prefer it if you don't request him again.