TheBonobo4's Tiering Thread

[TheBonobo4]

I was just about to post saying I've finished tonight's update, and that for the first time ever (I believe), I have 0 outstanding requests. But then this came along.


As an aside when I finish entire albums by an artist, should I list the songs in alphabetical order as I have been doing or in album order?

[Radiohead97]

"In One Ear" - Cage the Elephant

[Gunsrock13]

As an aside when I finish entire albums by an artist, should I list the songs in alphabetical order as I have been doing or in album order?

I would say list the songs by album order. That's what I did with the Opeth albums Metalhead requested for me to tier.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Neat tier! I never thought of Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree as country, haha. Thanks!

Continuin' with the Christmas requests: "Frosty the Snowman" by Jimmy Durante.

[sonicnerd23]

4 dots for "Airbag" on guitar? Personally, I'd take it down just one dot, but otherwise, great tier! The next track is the famous "Paranoid Android" (Track 02 of 12).

[TheBonobo4]

I would say list the songs by album order. That's what I did with the Opeth albums Metalhead requested for me to tier.

Will do. I'll list the album name and artist, with a Wikipedia link as well, so we don't have white text that would look out of place.


Except for albums like The Whirlwind where the album is one song.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Alright, Bonobo, tier comparison time for Possum Kingdom!

http://oi48.tinypic.com/2v9ceg8.jpg

You didn't do too bad here. You only got legacy guitar spot-on, but everything else is off by only a dot. And you also marked harmonies when there actually isn't any, but other than that, nice job!

[TheBonobo4]

Do you want me to fix my tier to match HMX's or keep it as it is?

[Mileycyrussoulja]

I think you should keep it as it is. After all, Gunsrock, GandWuser, and LiveHomeVideo all had tiers from their thread be released, but they didn't change it. GandWuser however altered his tier for I Melt With You before it got released. You should probably take harmonies off your tier though, now that you know there isn't any, but other than that, you shouldn't change anything else.

[TheBonobo4]

In that case I'll consider leaving it. But I can see why I should change it. In fact I'm leaning more towards the changing side of things than keeping it.