TheBonobo4's Tiering Thread

[TheBonobo4]

Sorry but no update tonight. I'm not going to have any time at all.

[LiveHomeVideo]

I was just looking at your tiers, and I came across "Anti Procrastonation Song" by Stormtroopers of Death.

The hell? The song is six seconds long, two of which is instrumentation. With Rock Band's engine, it'd be literally impossible to fail the song if you were to try playing it. The guitar and bass is strumming for two seconds, and the drums is a two-second blast beat. The vocals are one phrase of yelling.

Does not deserve devils or five dots on anything.

[TheBonobo4]

Yeah when I tiered it, I wasn't sure how to tier it. The thing is, I felt that it'd be easy to play but very hard to 100%. I asked Jibs (who requested it) and she was fine with it. Though what would you put the tiers as?

[LiveHomeVideo]

Yeah when I tiered it, I wasn't sure how to tier it. The thing is, I felt that it'd be easy to play but very hard to 100%. I asked Jibs (who requested it) and she was fine with it. Though what would you put the tiers as?

Well, since it's one phrase of vocals, which would probably be talkies, vocals would be 0-dots. As I said, with the way the fail meter works on Rock Band, it'd be impossible to fail if you were to try to hit the notes. So if you're going for pass difficulty, warmup, since it's really hard to fail. FC? I don't know, maybe 3-4 dots on Guitar/Bass and somewhat higher on Drums. I go by passing difficulty, though.

I had the same thought process when tiering "You Suffer" by Napalm Death.

[Gunsrock13]

Eulogy does look overtiered to me. I can sort of see why you put no keys but I would put them as a one for legacy and a zero for pro. Thanks for the tier though.
Next Aenima track:
Tool - H.

[TheBonobo4]

Hmm. I can add the keys in if you want. And how would you put the Guitar/Bass/Drum tiers? The drums were pretty insane and so I think they should be Devils, but maybe Bass as 5, Guitar as 4? What do you think?


LHV, I can agree with you now. You suffer is 1 second so is obviously Warmup, but I think that's just a noise with no instruments, or am I wrong? And I reckon for Anti-Procrastination Song, Vocals as a zero, bass as 0 (if there is any, not even sure), guitar as a 1 (it's 2 seconds, but very fast), drums as a 1 (for the same reason as guitar). How does that sound?

[LiveHomeVideo]

LHV, I can agree with you now. You suffer is 1 second so is obviously Warmup, but I think that's just a noise with no instruments, or am I wrong? And I reckon for Anti-Procrastination Song, Vocals as a zero, bass as 0 (if there is any, not even sure), guitar as a 1 (it's 2 seconds, but very fast), drums as a 1 (for the same reason as guitar). How does that sound?

You Suffer is obviously using guitars and drums.

And those tiers sound fine by me. The Devil Tiers caught me off guard is all.

[Gunsrock13]

Hmm. I can add the keys in if you want. And how would you put the Guitar/Bass/Drum tiers? The drums were pretty insane and so I think they should be Devils, but maybe Bass as 5, Guitar as 4? What do you think?

If you want to keep the tier as is thats fine by me. If I tiered the song my self I would give four dots to everything except keys. For pro I'd probably bump up bass a dot. However this is your tier so do with it as you please.

[TheBonobo4]

Okay I think that tonight, since I'll have limited time for new tiers, I'll just fix song tiers.

[TheBonobo4]

Fixed Eulogy and Anti-Procrastination Song.