TheBonobo4's Tiering Thread

[TheBonobo4]

Starting on tonight's update.

[TheBonobo4]

And done.
Notes:

We're In this together has been listed as alternative, since I wasn't sure what to put it as, and INdustrial isn't there.
Saltwater Joys has no Bass or drums, but i charted the Violins and other instruments as Keys. Also Folk isn't a RB genre so it's Country since that seemed closest.
I Stay away has no keys, but I think I heard a violin or something similar so I put that as keys.

[Gunsrock13]

Thanks. Now for Tool's epic... Lateralus.

[TheBonobo4]

Just did Veil of Illumination by Andromeda, the full 17 minute version as it should be. Very easy to tier, since it's all devils.

[TheBonobo4]

Thanks. Now for Tool's epic... Lateralus.

9 and a half minutes isn't an epic. An epic is at least 10 minutes, and I'd even say epic is 15 or more minutes.


Think of the great Rush epics, 2112 (20:33), Hemispheres (18:07), Fountain of Lamneth (19:58). Or even songs by Yes, Dream Theater, Mars Volta or Pink Floyd that can be 30 minutes long.

[Gunsrock13]

9 and a half minutes isn't an epic. An epic is at least 10 minutes, and I'd even say epic is 15 or more minutes.


Think of the great Rush epics, 2112 (20:33), Hemispheres (18:07), Fountain of Lamneth (19:58). Or even songs by Yes, Dream Theater, Mars Volta or Pink Floyd that can be 30 minutes long.

Ya, but Lateralus is definetely one of Tool's most epic songs

[TheBonobo4]

Ya, but Lateralus is definetely one of Tool's most epic songs

So I shall have fun listening and tiering it?

[Gunsrock13]

So I shall have fun listening and tiering it?

You should

[jibjqrkl]

did someone say long songs?
X-Japan - "Art Of Life (live)"

(the drummer = the pianist, so you won't really hear those 2 at the same time during the song )

[TheBonobo4]

33 minutes. Is not amused. But I'll tier it anyway.