Should (list of bands) Be In The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?

[Rockbandfan23467]

Here's my list of bands. Some should be in the HoF, some should not. Some are old enough, some not. Do they deserve it? Which ones do? Which ones don't? BEWARE-List is long.
The list:
RHCP
Deep Purple (Possibly Member soon)
Megadeth
Anthrax
Slayer
Iron Maiden
Judas Priest
Radiohead
Rush (Possible Member soon)
Yes
King Crimson
Blind Faith
Bluesbreakers
Alice In Chains
Pearl Jam
Soundgarden
Nirvana
Television
KISS
Captian Beefheart
Beck
The Smiths
The Cure
New York Dolls
Nine Inch Nails
The Pixies
The Replacements
Stevie Ray Vaughn
T. Rex
Weezer
The White Stripes
Boston
Heart
Journey
Bon Jovi
Dire Straits
Blink-182
Green Day
Limp Bizkit
Def Leppard
Stone Temple Pilots
Beastie Boys
Linkin Park
Live
Nickelback
Smashing Pumpkins
Backstreet Boys
Meat Loaf
Motley Crue
Poison
Blue Oyster Cult
Foo Fighters
Devo
Spinal Tap
"Wierd" Al Yankovic

[a21schizoidman]

Here's my list of bands. Some should be in the HoF, some should not. Some are old enough, some not. Do they deserve it? Which ones do? Which ones don't? BBEWARE-List is long.

The list:
RHCP
Deep Purple
Alice Cooper
Iron Maiden
Judas Priest
Radiohead
Rush
Yes
Genesis
King Crimson
Bluesbreakers
Pearl Jam
Soundgarden
Television
KISS
Captian Beefheart
Beck
The Cure
Small Faces/The Faces
New York Dolls
The Pixies
The Replacements
Stevie Ray Vaughan
T. Rex
Boston
Heart
Journey
Bon Jovi
Dire Straits
Def Leppard
STP
Smashing Pumpkins
Blue Oyster Cult
Devo

those yes, the others no

[Cosma]

The list:

(No)
Weezer
Green Day
Limp Bizkit
Pearl Jam
Soundgarden
Def Leppard
Smashing Pumpkins
Foo Fighters

(iffy)
Yes
Motley Crue
Poison
Nine Inch Nails
T. Rex
The Pixies
The Cure

(Eventually)
RHCP
Megadth
Anthrax
Slayer
Alice In Chains

(Yes)
Deep Purple
Iron Maiden
Judas Priest
Genesis
Blind Faith
KISS
Boston
Journey
Bon Jovi
Dire Straits
Meat Loaf
Blue Oyster Cult
Stone Temple Pilots
Devo
Spinal Tap
"Weird" Al Yankovick (If I say yes to Spinal Tap I have to say yes for him, as well as letting him into the R&B HoF, Country HoF, etc...)

(begrudgingly yes)
Metallica
Nirvana
Guns n Roses

(HELL YES)
Alice Cooper
Rush
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Heart

Ok catagorization is as follows
No= Just that, I don't think they should be in
Iffy= There's no real reason for them NOT to be in, but no real reason they deserve it
Eventually= Yes they should be BUT not until other, better qualified artists are in
Yes= Induct them now
begrudgingly yes= As much as I don't like them, let them in
HELL YES= Personal bias, LET THEM IN........YEARS AGO

Anyone that I left off from the original list are bands I have either never heard of or have had limited or no exposure to

[TakeABow]

Here's my list of bands. Some should be in the HoF, some should not. Some are old enough, some not. Do they deserve it? Which ones do? Which ones don't? BBEWARE-List is long.

The list:
<list......>

Joy Division is missing. At least you included The Cure and Radiohead. I won't speak of newer stuff.

[Rockbandfan23467]

Joy Division is missing. At least you included The Cure and Radiohead. I won't speak of newer stuff.

Sorry about that.

[Rockbandfan23467]

We need more responses. Axl? Julio? BluEyes? Fogey? Jukebox? Anyone?

[schmeankman]

RHCP-yes
Deep Purple-yes
Alice Cooper-yes
Metallica-yes
Megadeth-yes
Anthrax-yes
Slayer-no
Iron Maiden-yes
Judas Priest-yes
Radiohead-no
Rush-yes
Yes-no
Genesis-no
King Crimson-no
Blind Faith-no
Bluesbreakers-no
Alice In Chains-yes
Pearl Jam-yes
Soundgarden-no
Nirvana-yes
Television-no
Guns N Roses-yes
KISS-yes
Captian Beefheart-no
Beck-no
The Smiths-no
The Cure-yes
Small Faces/The Faces-no
New York Dolls-yes
Nine Inch Nails-no
The Pixies-yes
The Replacements-no
Stevie Ray Vaughn-yes
T. Rex-no
Weezer-no
The White Stripes-no
Boston-yes
Heart-yes
Journey-yes
Bon Jovi-yes
Dire Straits-no
Blink-182-no
Green Day-yes
Limp Bizkit-no
Def Leppard-yes
Stone Temple Pilots-no
Beastie Boys-yes
Linkin Park-no
Live-no
Nickelback-no
Smashing Pumpkins-yes
Backstreet Boys-no
Meat Loaf-no
Motley Crue-yes
Poison-no
Blue Oyster Cult-yes
Foo Fighters-no
Devo-no
Spinal Tap-yes
"Wierd" Al YANKOVIC-yes

EDIT: John McCain thread! I've changed some opinions, I'm too lazy to edit though.

[lpunderground19]

Linkin Park and Nickelback? Bahaha. As big of an LP fan as I am, they definitely do not deserve it when bands like Rush and Deep Purple still wait entrance. And Weird Al is a damn musical genius, I don't care what anybody else says. He's been making successful, appealing, humorous music for twenty plus years, and is showing no signs of letting up (other than longer periods of time between albums)

[DarkSide247]

Here's my list of bands. Some should be in the HoF, some should not. Some are old enough, some not. Do they deserve it? Which ones do? Which ones don't? BBEWARE-List is long.

The list:
Deep Purple
Alice Cooper
Metallica
Megadeth
Anthrax
Slayer
Iron Maiden
Judas Priest
Rush
Yes
Genesis
King Crimson
Nirvana
Guns N Roses
KISS
The Cure
The Pixies
The Replacements
Stevie Ray Vaughn
T. Rex
Boston
Heart
Journey
Bon Jovi
Def Leppard
Motley Crue
Poison
Blue Oyster Cult
Devo

I think these should be in the HOF.

[next jimmy page]

wow there are so many bands that should be in
some bands i say no to are: poison, def leppard, the replacements, green day

a band i say yes to: THE PIXIES!!!! kurt cobain admits without the pixies, there would be no Nirvana