Henry Sardonicus' Tiering Thread 2.0

[Metalhead911]

And as usual, opinions on the Pull Me Under tier? I feel like that one was pretty accurate for the most part.

Well, I personally think An-Animal-As-Leader (ANCIENT TIERER) had one of the best tiers for Pull Me Under I've seen. It was before the new tiering method existed, too.

His tiers were 5-dots for legacy guitar, Vocals, pro Bass, and Drums, a 4-dot on legacy bass, and Devils for Pro Guitar, Keys, and Pro Keys.

Granted, I think the 4-dot may be a tad undertiered. However, I think his tiers were a little more on the money than yours. I doubt PMU would warrant a devil on legacy guitar (although I think if it is a 5-dot, it is towards the bottom of its tier). Drums would be at the bottom of 5-dot. Not quite a devil because it wouldn't be as challenging as the other DT songs. Panic Attack, OtBoA, and Constant Motion are all more difficult songs than PMU on drums.

[Henry_Sardonicus]

Ah yes, back in the wild days, before people posted pictures of tiers, and used colored circles. I'll do hese tomorrow, while also hopefully finishing up Empires.

[Henry_Sardonicus]

I like horses.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

You accidentally posted that twice.

[Henry_Sardonicus]

Fixed.

[Henry_Sardonicus]

Songs are tiered. I wonder if tiering threads will stop soon.

[Mileycyrussoulja]

Songs are tiered. I wonder if tiering threads will stop soon.

Why would you think that? Just because Rock Band's ending in April doesn't mean tier threads will cease to exist.

[GandWuser]

Why would you think that? Just because Rock Band's ending in April doesn't mean tier threads will cease to exist.

To be totally honest, I may be ending mine some time soon. I've been getting way fewer requests lately, which is probably due to declining popularity and he fact that there are other, quicker threads. I probably won't end it, but I may cut back on updates.

[Metalhead911]

I find it odd that you didn't put Keys on Sabbra Caddabra whenever there are keys on that track. Rick Wakeman (of Yes) played on that track because his bandmates in Yes were dominating control over the album they were recording in the same lot (Tales From Topographic Oceans). It got to the point where Wakeman was so bored that he was playing darts (and recording) with Ozzy and company. So I found it odd that there are no keys listed on Sabbra Caddabra.

Anyways, the rest of the tiers are great. Here are the next songs......

Black Sabbath - Hole In The Sky
Black Sabbath - Symptom Of The Universe
Cream - Toad
Eric Clapton - Tears In Heaven (Unplugged)
Dream Theater - Under A Glass Moon
Dream Theater - Metropolis Part I: The Miracle and the Sleeper

[Henry_Sardonicus]

There are keys? Well I feel stupid. I'll fix that when I do the next batch. I'm spending the rest of today on Empires over on the albums thread.