Do Guitar Hero fanboys still think Guitar Hero > Rock Band?

[OrdealByFire]

after the atrocity that is World Tour? I don't want to seem tedious with my threads, but what do they think? [Can't tell at school. ]

[afterstasis]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0TQNp5MIO0

[OrdealByFire]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0TQNp5MIO0

I can't see YouTube videos at school, silly. -_-

Still, I will watch whatever it's about later at home. =D

[jeccaneko]

Good question Ordeal. I haven't seen the Guitar Hero fans actually say what they think. I'm just hearing complaints about the instruments being faulty.

I seriously want to hear what they have to say. While I disagreed with their GH3 > Rock Band 1 assessment, I thought some of their points were fair, based on particular preferences (ie some of the song arguements and the fact that overall GH3 was harder, for those people who like a challenge). I want to see a good GHWT > Rock Band 2 arguement. Not that I want to argue back with it, I just want to see something well thought out that will show me why some people might think that way even if I don't.

[killer_roach]

Fanboys are fanboys because they are impervious to facts... you should know that by now

[jeccaneko]

Fanboys are fanboys because they are impervious to facts... you should know that by now

Hey, I'm a Rock Band fangirl. I'll admit it. But, like I said, I understood how the GH fans might like GH3 versus RB1 based on what they like and dislike. So not all fans of something are completely blind to it.

[RealMessiah]

after the atrocity that is World Tour? I don't want to seem tedious with my threads, but what do they think? [Can't tell at school. ]

Which atrocity is that? I spent my Sunday playing through GH:WT just like I did when RB2 came out. Was no less satisfied yesterday than I was the day RB2 came out. Both games are top of the line IMO.

There can be two.

People need to get over it.

I know there have been instrument complaints, as if RB has never had that issue? If you were going to toss a game due to bad instruments being prevailant...what are you doing playing RB to this day?

[TheGreatKtulu]

Well I had a really long post written up and foolishly wasn't logged in to post it.


Anyways... depending what reasons you play, yeah, some people might think that GH:WT is the better game.

I play both. In a few hours when the UPS guy shows up, I'll be playing Rock Revolution too. There's no reason to be blindly loyal to any of these game companies. Let's not forget our basic math skills either, $2/song to download vs $60 for 70 non-RB-disc songs if you buy just the GHWT stand alone game. Let's see... $140 if all those songs came out as DLC for RB2... or pay $60 and switch discs. Hmm. Hmmm. Yeah.... no reason not to buy both games if you just like playing the songs.

[afterstasis]

Let's not forget our basic math skills either, $2/song to download vs $60 for 70 non-RB-disc songs if you buy just the GHWT stand alone game. Let's see... $140 if all those songs came out as DLC for RB2... or pay $60 and switch discs. Hmm. Hmmm. Yeah.... no reason not to buy both games if you just like playing the songs.

this is the approach i was taking, but after i considered songs i would actually buy i came up way short.
if the GH:WT setlist were more up my alley i'd definitely buy it for the sake of new songs.

[Fennz]

After playing WT, I can't see how anybody can say WT>RB2.